Category Archives: Mormon Studies

In Memoriam: Ardis E. Parshall (1959–2026)

We are sad to let you know of the passing of Ardis E. Parshall. She died on Sunday, February 22, 2026.

A graveside service will be held on Thursday, February 26, at 1:00 p.m. MST. The location is Larkin Sunset Gardens, 1950 East 10600 South, Sandy, Utah. Ardis Evelyn Parshall will be buried near her beloved parents, Bernice Edith Taylor Parshall and George Edward Parshall.

Keepapitchinin began in 2008. It is not just a blog, but a digital library of the Mormon people, with a special emphasis on those who were forgotten. Ardis wrote her last post here on April 10, 2025. Since it was her 8,400th post, she stopped, although she continued conversations on Facebook and Threads. Continue reading In Memoriam: Ardis E. Parshall (1959–2026) →

Corianton: BYU Screens the Restored Movie

Last night I took part in an event showcasing the 1931 film Corianton: A Story of Unholy Love, a cooperative project of BYU’s Film Archive and Maxwell Institute. We laughed, we cried (well, I cried anyway, when Shiblon realized that Relia really did not love him as a suitor). We talked about reception history and gender and race. We heard that some additional footage has turned up, and that as soon as it can be safely copied from its explosive nitrate film, Ben Harry will be able to place some as-yet-unknown sequences into the movie to be shown at some future date. We had a full house (360!). It’s been a while since I last had so much fun.

My job was to talk about the development of the whole Corianton phenomenon, and try to help viewers better appreciate the movie while they watched — and do all that in under 15 minutes. Here are my remarks. I promised during Q&A when there were questions I could not answer without reviewing my files that I would answer them here … but I can’t remember what was asked! Will try to respond to anyone who reminds me.

Corianton: A Story of Unholy Love

(Remarks before the Showing of “Corianton” at a BYU Event
Sponsored by the Harold B. Lee Library and the Maxwell Institute
27 January 2023

If we read the few verses in the Book of Mormon that speak directly of Corianton we might occupy a minute, or a minute and a half. How in the world is that enough to fill nearly two hours of our movie?

My assignment tonight is to give you the backstory, the development of “Corianton” from those few verses to the movie you came to watch, focusing on those details that will help you understand what you’re about to see.

Continue reading Corianton: BYU Screens the Restored Movie →

Review: Fact, Fiction, and Polygamy / MacKinnon and Alford

(Crossposted with “Dawning of a Brighter Day,” the Association for Mormon Letters blog)

Fact, Fiction, and Polygamy: A Tale of Utah War Intrigue, 1857-1858,  A. G. Browne’s The Ward of the Three Guardians, ed. by William P. MacKinnon and Kenneth L. Alford. (Tanner Trust Fund and J. Willard Marriot Library, 2022) 245 p., hardbound, ISBN: 9781647690694 ($24.95)

The very first Sherlock Holmes story, “A Study in Scarlet,” includes a lengthy sensationalized subplot involving vengeance meted out by fanatical Danites against defectors from the Mormon faith. Published in 1887, Arthur Conan Doyle’s story played off similarly sensationalized accounts of the perceived horrors of polygamy in Utah that were popular in both the United States and Great Britain. One could argue that the specter of Mormon patriarchs and their harems of kidnapped and unwilling women may have contributed to the ultimate success of Doyle and his Sherlock Holmes stories.

Continue reading Review: Fact, Fiction, and Polygamy / MacKinnon and Alford →

“Debunking” an Image: Not as Easy as You Might Imagine

How would you “debunk” the claimed identity of the subject of a daguerreotype?

I ask, because some people are confusing my questioning of the sufficiency of evidence, with a claim that I have “debunked” the recently released daguerreotype asserted to be Joseph Smith. I have not “debunked” it – it may well the one and only true and authentic camera portrait of Joseph Smith. I just don’t think the evidence for that is – yet – sufficient.

But if you or I or anybody else wanted to prove that that image (or the Scannel daguerreotype, for that matter) was NOT Joseph Smith, just how do you propose we go about that? It’s a much harder thing to do than you might suppose.

Continue reading “Debunking” an Image: Not as Easy as You Might Imagine →

First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve in the 1950 Census

With the release of the 1950 U.S. Census on 1 April, I’ve had fun looking up family, friends, and others – it’s not easy but gets easier the more I do, because I keep learning little tricks.

Members of the First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve who appear in this census:

.

Russell M. Nelson, 25-year-old physician/surgeon completing his residency in Minneapolis, Minnesota
.

Continue reading First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve in the 1950 Census →

Guest Review: Charles Shiro Inouye, Zion Earth Zen Sky

Zion Earth Zen Sky / Author: Charles Shiro Inouye. BYU Maxwell Institute, 2021. 271 p. Paperback. ISBN: 9781950304110. $19.95

The twin streams of Buddhism and Mormonism flow through Charles Inouye’s new memoir like water. Describing it using a haiku, I might write something like this:

Zion earth, Zen sky
Jesus and Buddha raking
In the Spring garden

While this follows the traditional styles of Haiku for format, it only hints at the mystery and wonder I found in Inouye’s new book, Zion Earth Zen Sky. As Inouye relates the story of his life, the influence of both Mahayana Buddhism and life as a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints seem to mirror each other in subtle ways. Inouye is a third generation Japanese-American, whose parents met in a World War II internment camp in Wyoming. They chose to settle after the war in Utah, rather than return to the West Coast where they felt betrayed by their neighbors. Farming in an isolated community in Central Utah, Charles and his siblings were dropped off at the local LDS ward each Sunday, as their parents felt they needed a spiritual upbringing, and the nearest Buddhist temple was hours away in Salt Lake City.

Continue reading Guest Review: Charles Shiro Inouye, Zion Earth Zen Sky →

“For Nothing is Secret, that Shall Not Be Made Manifest”: Deciphering Encrypted Passages in an 1836 Journal

Robin Jensen, historian with the Joseph Smith Papers, specialist in the history of the Historian’s Office itself and in so much more, recently sent me a scan of a page from the diary of Stephen Post (1810-1879, a Seventy who disaffiliated from the Church after the succession crisis following Joseph Smith’s death), the first recognizable date of which is 27 January 1836. Several short phrases or sentences on that page are concealed by a code. Even though it’s his project (whatever that project is), Rob has given me permission to write about decrypting those short bits. This is based on the report I sent to Rob after I decoded those bits.

Continue reading “For Nothing is Secret, that Shall Not Be Made Manifest”: Deciphering Encrypted Passages in an 1836 Journal →

William G. Heberhart: Responsibility for How We Remember Those Who Can’t Speak for Themselves

Here is a tale that is more of a “why do it” than a “who dunnit” or “how to do it.”

Yesterday morning I was surveying a diary kept by Joseph F. Smith in 1881, not looking for anything in particular but keeping an eye out for stories. My eye fell on this entry for 4 April 1881:

Wm. Heberhart, a “Jack-Mormon,” and thief, confessed to having stolen $2000.00/100 from the drug department of Z.C.M.I. during six months in 1880. The supt. took his note secured by a bill of sale of his property, for $2,000.00/100.

Well! I thought, there’s a story there! The following day, seeming to have forgotten that he had already written the above, Elder Smith wrote:

I was called away to the “Co-op,” where I found Wm. G. Heberhart who had confessed to having stolen 2000$ from the Drug Dept. of Z.C.M.I. while in its employ. We have evidence that he has stolen a much larger sum, perhaps about $7000.00 in about 6 & 1/2 months. He has turned over some property as indemnity and given his note for 2000$.

Continue reading William G. Heberhart: Responsibility for How We Remember Those Who Can’t Speak for Themselves →

Song of Names: A Mormon Mosaic Launch Party! Join us by Zoom

So … I’ve been pretty quiet about this. It’s so much more James Goldberg’s genius than mine, but the project did have its genesis here at Keepa, so …

Song of Names will be published electronically tomorrow (Friday, 24 July – Pioneer Day!), and we’re having an online launch party, and you’re invited! (Connection information at the bottom of this post.)

Song of Names is a celebration of individual lives who share our identity as Latter-day Saints. The collection draws on the “lesser known Saints” – supplemented with new stories to balance the collection geographically and chronologically – whose stories have appeared at Keepa: There’s “The Pied Piper of Dudley Port,” Hettie Hilda Harper, who invented Primary in 20th century England just as Aurilla Spencer Rogers invented it in 19th century Utah. There’s B.H. Roberts, chaplain of the First World War, writing elegies for the men under his care who died of influenza. There’s the young Jordi Ventura Subirats, whose letter of inquiry led to the first 20th century converts in Spain. There are William and Marie Graves, who “found the right church, but found the wrong people,” yet lived faithfully as Saints the remainder of their days. There are others you remember or will meet for the first time, and be blessed to have as your spiritual brothers and sisters.

Continue reading Song of Names: A Mormon Mosaic Launch Party! Join us by Zoom →