Why Mormon Immigrants from Europe Traveled in Second Class Rather than Steerage: or, What I Learned on Christmas Eve

Not the typical festive Christmas post; rather, it’s the understanding of a nagging question in Mormon history that finally became clear to me tonight:

When the Church arranged travel for its European convert immigrants through its own emigration department, they always tried to send large groups together, with returning missionaries who knew the ropes as leaders. The ship passengers were organized into wards for evening prayers and Sunday worship; they organized for efficiency in cleaning and cooking chores; they protected each other from being preyed on by other passengers.

Once they reached the US and transferred to trains, they followed the same organization. Being met by a Mormon travel agent at the dock helped protect them from all the wharf rats who tried to separate naive travelers from their money, or worse. Their baggage was transferred from ship to train (or train to train when they had to transfer somewhere on the continental route) under the supervision of an agent who checked to be sure all bags made it; they occupied whole train cars as a group to shield Mormon women from the insults of men passing down the aisles of their train cars.

With both ship and rail, the Church arranged special contracts with travel companies: “If you treat us right, we’ll send all our people by your company, which will be very profitable to you.” That resulted in various benefits of safety and comfort to our travelers.

Divisions between economic and social classes seemed to be especially pronounced in travel. Missionaries always traveled first class, both ways, not necessarily because of the greater comfort in first class, but in their endless pursuit of respectability. A clergyman had to travel in first class to protect his dignity; if he didn’t, other passengers and the crew looked down on him.

First class passengers were treated like ladies and gentlemen, not only with regard to luxuries aboard ship, but when they landed in American ports: They breezed through immigration checks without being questioned; they didn’t have to show that they had the required landing money; they could carry on with travel according to their own plans, without hindrance from immigration officials.

Second class passengers were not ladies and gentlemen, but they were still treated as competent adults. Their movements were not questioned; they could make their own plans.

Third class/steerage passengers, however, which included virtually all immigrants because of the vast difference in expense between steerage and even second class respectability, were in an entirely different world. They had to stand in long lines and answer endless questions – sometimes the questions were meant to protect them from unscrupulous would-be exploiters; more often, the questions were meant to protect the U.S. from the constant fear of “letting in the wrong people.” Third class passengers had to prove they had enough money with them not to become beggars on the streets of the port city; they had to be examined to prove they weren’t carrying contagious disease; they had to declare their destination; they were not permitted to talk to anybody until the immigrant bureaus released them – can’t have anybody coaching them, you know, on how to give the right answers to evade being sent back to where they came from.

The difference between how second- and third-class passengers were treated, it turns out, is why the Church sent all of its immigrants by second class and not by steerage, from sometime in the 1880s through the end of Mormon-sponsored immigration in the 1920s (changes in immigration law in the middle of the ’20s slammed the door on most immigration):

When passengers traveled by second class, they could be met at the dock by Mormon immigration agents. They could have the benefit of the lower-cost contracts negotiated with U.S. railroads. They could be organized, continue travel together, travel in more comfortable cars, have someone watching their luggage at transfer points – all because second-class passengers were treated as competent adults.

Our immigration agents were barred from access to steerage passengers. Mormon agents had nothing to say about which railroad companies or which routes such passengers were sent on – they couldn’t even guarantee that Mormon passengers would be allowed to travel in regular coaches and not herded aboard open-air cattle cars, as had occasionally happened.

And I finally understood that, after years of wondering why the penny-conscious Church agency bought second- instead of third-class tickets for European immigrants, when I saw this one sentence in a letter – rather, the DRAFT of a letter that was never sent, and could so easily have escaped preservation: “We have for years brought all of our passengers coming from Europe in the second cabin, so as to avoid the immigrant bureau, and thus be able to attend to the rail routing of our own passengers ourselves.”

This is an exciting understanding for me, the history nerd, because it takes me a step closer to really understanding the world our people moved through.

Image: The SS Montclare, Canadian registry, aboard which my grandfather Homer Taylor returned (Liverpool to Montreal) from his British mission in 1923.

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "Why Mormon Immigrants from Europe Traveled in Second Class Rather than Steerage: or, What I Learned on Christmas Eve." Keepapitchin.org, 24 Dec 2021, https://keepapitchinin.org/2021/12/24/why-mormon-immigrants-from-europe-traveled-in-second-class-rather-than-steerage-or-what-i-learned-on-christmas-eve/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2021, Dec 24). Why Mormon Immigrants from Europe Traveled in Second Class Rather than Steerage: or, What I Learned on Christmas Eve. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2021/12/24/why-mormon-immigrants-from-europe-traveled-in-second-class-rather-than-steerage-or-what-i-learned-on-christmas-eve/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2021/12/24/why-mormon-immigrants-from-europe-traveled-in-second-class-rather-than-steerage-or-what-i-learned-on-christmas-eve/">Why Mormon Immigrants from Europe Traveled in Second Class Rather than Steerage: or, What I Learned on Christmas Eve</a>

16 thoughts on “Why Mormon Immigrants from Europe Traveled in Second Class Rather than Steerage: or, What I Learned on Christmas Eve”

  1. Given the longstanding insistence of prejudiced immigration officials on both sides of the Atlantic that Mormons were recruited from the dregs of European society, I see this move as a two-fer for the Church. Not only did it provide the considerable benefits you outline, it portrayed Mormon immigrants as “competent adults”. Wonderful story, Ardis! Thank you!

  2. What a fascinating insight, and explanation. It’s small, but thanks for posting and Merry Christmas!

  3. How interesting! You have sent me to look once again at the 1895 passenger list on which I find my Swiss grandmother traveling from Scotland to New York. She is in 2nd class with a lot of people coming from Switzerland and some from other European countries and going to Utah. I have now found one man in 1st class and will try to track him down and find out if he was a returning missionary.

    You have helped me understand a little more about my grandmother’s journey: that she was not as alone as I have thought and there were Church members who could help her along the way. Thanks for sharing the insight you received in celebration of Christmas this year!

  4. The actual dollar/pound cost varied over time, of course, but typically second class cost twice as much, sometimes three times as much, as steerage.

    On the Titanic in 1912, second class was $60, while steerage was $15-$40.

  5. Thanks, everybody. I’m really surprised this got such attention, especially at Christmas and especially because the new detail isn’t, of itself, very dramatic. But I guess a lot of you are like me, in that you recognize that the little details tell a much bigger story, one that matters to a lot of us.

    Happy New Year!

  6. This is fascinating! I wonder if most Mormon emigrants would have been Second Class passengers generally. If not, this may have been the first time in their lives they were treated as competent adults by anybody at all.

  7. It really is. Of course you have to have filled in the background in order for that line to turn the key, but that one new fact, or the way something is worded to turn your mind in a new direction, makes all the difference.

  8. Fascinating as always. Matches what I’ve seen in the accounts in the “Saints on the Seas” database at BYU.

    I can add, based on what I saw there, that sometime before the time you are talking about the immigration agents were permitted to board the arriving ship and talk with the Mormon immigrant company leaders — that occurred in almost every case I saw in the 1850s and 1860s among those arriving here in New York City.

    FWIW.

Comments are closed.