The Paramount-Empress Theater on Salt Lake City’s Main Street, half a block from Temple Square, was one of the elegant movie “palaces” of the early 20th century. It had been built in 1911 for vaudeville and other stage shows, and in 1916 was refitted for movies, or “photoplays” as they were sometimes called. The 15 April 1916 issue of The Moving Picture Magazine trade publication tells more than you probably want to know with no shortage of hype:
A Fine Salt Lake Theater.
Paramount-Empress, Under Management of H.E. Ellison, Succeeds.By H.W. Pickering, Salt Lake Correspondent of Moving Picture World.
SALT LAKE, Utah–The Paramount-Empress theater, which opened in Salt Lake City the latter part of February as a house for the exclusive showing of the paramount program, has proved one of the most marked successes among the many successful theaters of this district. H.E. Ellison, the manager, who came to Salt Lake from the Princess theater, Denver, has won the approval of the theater-goers of Salt Lake by his methods and especially through his introduction in this city of the practice of “staging” his pictures. Notable among these efforts were the scenic and electrical effects accompanying the Burton Holmes pictures of West Point and Annapolis. An agreeable effect was also obtained in the showing of the “Trail of the Lonesome Pine.
The Paramount-Empress was fitted up as a photoplay theater from the Sullivan & Considine Empress theater, which had a varied experience as a vaudeville and stock house. For a large cash consideration, a Utah corporation took over the Sullivan & Considine theater and at great additional expense, remodeled the house for the showing of pictures. The large musical staff of the house is headed by Willard Weihe, who conducts the orchestra; Edward P. Kimball, organist, also assistant organist at the famous ‘Mormon” Tabernacle, and Franz Rath, pianist, whose work has been a distinct feature of the bills at the Paramount-Empress.
A model projection room on the parquet floor of the house gives a straight “shoot” at the screen, which is of the Minusa fibra variety. A large pipe organ, roomy and convenient rest rooms and nursery, an automatic ticket-selling machine and a very courteous house staff are notable features of the management and equipment of the house.
A grainy photo in that magazine confirms that despite remodeling to provide a movie screen, the theater retained the luxurious interior shown in this much clearer photograph taken while the place was still a live stage theater.
The building was again remodeled in 1941 to become the Uptown Theater, and was finally torn down in 1971 to make way for a new shopping mall which has itself been torn down to make way for the current City Creek Center.
Okay, so much for the setting.
One hundred years ago this very week, what do you suppose was playing at the elegant Paramount-Empress? Why, none other than a Mormon movie! or, rather, a Mormon episode of the newsreel series produced by Pathé Frères. I do not know whether it was a normal thing for a short news film to be as heavily advertised as this one was in Salt Lake, or whether the publicity was because of the local interest. Here are two of many, many advertisements to appear in Salt Lake newspapers in mid-March, 1918:
.

.

.
That’s right. The top of the bill was a movie starring Billie Burke (who would later play Glinda the Witch of the North in The Wizard of Oz), but every advertisement also carried word that the newsreel featured Joseph F. Smith playing golf, on a course – probably Brentwood – in the Santa Monica area of Southern California.
The drama! the action! the excitement!
I tease. The local interest in this short film was justified, I think – how often had LDS audiences seen themselves portrayed on stage or screen, in a production that was being shown throughout the country, in a favorable or at least normal light?
In the last few years of his life, Joseph F. Smith spent a lot of time in Santa Monica, resting, sometimes recuperating from illness, often with members of his family, and often with Charles W. Nibley, his best friend and the Presiding Bishop of the Church. The two men played golf – a lot. Letters of Smith family members to and from Santa Monica are peppered with references to those golf games:
“It rained yesterday and pretty much all night no golf. I can see that papa needs exercise, but this weather he can not get it.” … “Uncle Charlie left yesterday and will, no doubt, be with you before you receive this. I suppose you are having your golf games on a nice carpet of green by this time.” … “Bishop Nibley arrived promptly at the golf links at 3:10 this afternoon, and at once led out on the links with a perfect drive down the fairway: followed variously by Col. Clayton, Wesley and I, and later we were joined by Ex-Congressman Joseph Howell. Enclosed you will find a score card that might be interesting to you.”
And perhaps best of all, this report in March from Salt Lake City to the folks in California:
We have had quite an attraction at the Empress Theater during the first part of this week, and nearly everybody in Salt Lake city, I believe, have gone to see President Smith and Bishop Nibley play golf. When I saw the announcement I was just a little bit anxious and took in the show early Monday. But I was greatly relieved in seeing a picture that you could be proud of, and in its travels over the Pathe circuit nobody will have cause to be ashamed of the President of the Mormon Church.
I do not know how the filmmakers happened to know about President Smith and his golfing, or why they chose to film it, or how and why President Smith agreed to it. And while quite a few Pathé films survive, just as many have not. I have been unable to find any reference to this golf film in catalogs of that company.
And that’s the way we were, one hundred years ago, in March 1918.
And some of us, who have spoiled way too many a good walk, would also be interested in seeing that scorecard! Any chance that the person who received the letter kept the scorecard too?
Nope. I’ve been through his papers from top to bottom, with nothing like that found.
From https://history.lds.org/chdaily/8042015?lang=eng:
Presiding Bishop Charles W. Nibley introduced his close friend President Joseph F. Smith to the game of golf. Once, Nibley recalled, President Smith’s ball was within a hundred feet of the hole. “A slight stroke should have driven the ball nearer the flag,” he said, “but the inclination to look up as one tries to hit the ball got the best of him.” Twice President Smith took his eye off the ball at the last second and his stroke fell short. “The third time he went up to it and hit [the ball] a whack that sent it rolling one hundred feet beyond the flag. His son, Wesley, who was playing with us, called out, ‘Why, papa, what did you do that for? You knew it would roll away down there in the ditch!’ The President straightened up and said, rather severely, ‘Well, I was mad at it!’”
Charles W. Nibley, “Reminiscences of President Joseph F. Smith,” Improvement Era, vol. 22, no. 3 (Jan. 1919), 194–95
That’s funny! Thanks, Gary.
Since playing golf is ultimately frustrating–see, for example, the professionals who play all the time hit the ball off into the trees or the lake or the parking lot–I wonder if Bro. Joseph F. managed to get “mad at it” with never a sharp word escaping his lips. If so, he was a better man than most!
I’m no golf fan, but I’d buy a ticket to see Joseph F. play.
A commenter on Keepa’s Facebook page (I’d give him credit, but he hasn’t answered my question about whether I can name him) points us toward this James B. Allen article that has photographs (stills, alas, rather than a movie) of Joseph F. Smith, Charles W. Nibley, and Heber J. Grant, golfing (separate shots, not together).
James B. Allen column, 2012
What a delightful article! I love the story of Joseph F. commanding Heber J. Grant to give the game a try.
Fascinating, Ardis. Thanks! Chet and Shirl Clawson probably became the local representatives for Pathé News in Utah around 1916, the same time President Smith hired them to become the official filmmakers of the Church. They were based in SLC but occasionally traveled with General Authorities out of state, such as when Heber Grant went to Nebraska to inspect land around Winter Quarters for purchase by the Church. They filmed Joseph F. Smith engaged in activities like automobiling, and they filmed President Grant in the ’20s golfing. I always assumed this was in Utah, but I suppose it’s possible it wasn’t; the Church Archives identify the location of the course.
So there are at least two possibilities, which are either that the Clawsons traveled with Pres. Smith to Santa Monica and filmed that game, or another Pathé News representative based around L.A. was already there and shot it. Third option: in 1920 the Paramount-Empress commissioned a newsreel about Utah’s delegation to the Republican National Convention–people like Reed Smoot. We’re not sure who those filmmaker(s) were. Maybe the Paramount did something similar here?
My best bet is on Shirl, though. Thanks!
^ Church Archives DON’T identify the location of the golf course.