Conversation at Dinner

From the Improvement Era, January 1952 –

Conversation at Dinner

By Alice Morrey Bailey

Jeanette held every moment of the evening as if it were as precious as the gardenia in her corsage, because it was the last. This was the last time Richard would call for her, the last time he would meet her, both his hands outstretched to hers. They were having dinner in the Emerald Room, and somewhere, somehow, during the evening she must find the words to tell him.

“We’ll take this, and this,” he was telling the waiter, indicating with his pencil the items on the menu. “And the lady is absolutely not to know what is coming.”

Jeanette gave him a sidelong look. “Plotting again! Perhaps I won’t like it.” That was only one of the dear things about Richard, his delightful surprises.

“I guarantee you’ll like it. Who knows better what you will like than I do? I will tell you this, though. It comes from Nova Scotia,” and he was off on a word trip of bays and inlets, slim-sailed boats, and picturesque fishermen. “It’s all blue and green — blue water and grassy banks, pointed trees and shrubs. The cottages are of slate, and there is a scarlet roof here, a bright red boat there, to point up the coloring. A marvelous place to go. I’ll take you there someday.”

There it was again! His words made her more aware that the time might be short. For her it was gone already. Never had she known more than she did this minute that she loved Richard, with a love that was as complete as it was hopeless. The same thing must not happen to him. There was a sudden dryness of her mouth, a sudden bleakness that fell over the enchantment. “Richard!” she said.

Richard looked at her quickly. Was there a flash of apprehension in his eyes? But no! They were cool and noncommittal as he leaned back in his chair, but there was an air of watchful waiting about him.

“Yes?” he said finally, and she hardly knew how to begin.

“You are such a good companion,” she said and stopped.

He bowed slightly, amusement tilting the clean line of his mouth. Her eyes fell before the level look in his, sliding down the dark sleeve to the smooth brown of his knuckles, the hard slenderness of his fingers. It took courage to go on, but she did it with an air.

“Skiing,” she said. The wind in her face on the long slope they had taken together. That was her love for Richard. “No one ever had such a gay companion — such a sporting companion.” The words sounded brittle and insincere, but they set the pace. Richard was toying with the saltcellar, tipping it straight up so that a little white river poured a mound on the table cloth.

“Music.” Symphony music, and two people lost in the magic of sound. Two currents merging with all the little rivulets of melody swirling and eddying about them. Out and beyond, down through the forests and pastoral lands, through the city and beyond, to flow with majesty to the sea. “I never heard music until I heard it with you.”

That was sincere enough. Too sincere for the light touch. His eyes met hers for a brief instant.

“Skating,” she said quickly and could go on only because the dark fringe of his lashes shadowed his eyes again. He shaped the little mound of salt with his knife-edge. She was really handling this with finesse. It was a way out for Richard, with pride and a light goodbye. What happened to her in the small hours of the night after he was gone was another matter.

“I shall never forget you,” she said, and as she went on, all richness faded out. The way became very narrow, the gate very straight, and life seemed to stretch out be- fore her in the grayness of disinterest. Life without Richard! “I shall never forget the good times we have had — the hikes, the ballet, the theater, and the long talks — especially the long talks; we have enjoyed so much together.”

He eyed the little hill critically. “The headboard is too small,” he complained.

“The headboard?” Jeanette looked down. He had built a small grave of salt, with a toothpick for the headboard. “Too small?”

“For that fine epitaph. Here lies friendship. With garlands of eulogies. Or shall we always be friends? Would you like that, Jeanette? I could go on writing my gabby letters even after I had picked up the newspaper telling of your wedding to so-and-so, son of such-and-such.”

That hurt. “Richard! No!” She could never bear that. It had to be quick. It had to be final. “It was only — ”

“It was only because you thought I was falling in love with you, and you wanted to stop me, let me out gracefully. Wasn’t that it?”

Suddenly the enormity of her presumption overwhelmed Jeanette. She felt the dull red creep up her cheeks.

“Yes,” she admitted truthfully, “because I couldn’t see marriage ahead for us. Before it was too late.”

“Because of the difference in our religion,” he stated,

“Yes,” Jeanette said simply.

Richard leveled out the mound of salt. “It is too late,” he said.

His words hung in silence. Jeanette’s pulse began a steady, slow pounding that was suffocation in her throat.

He continued, “It was too late the minute I met you.”

Jeanette opened her mouth to speak, but no words came.

“I didn’t believe in love at first sight,” Richard went on, “too many things involved. But sure as you live, something happened when I saw you. Something wonderful. Do you remember that day?”

“I remember,” Jeanette said, unsteadily. Would she ever forget it? Richard, a brilliant streak on the white slope of Alta, against a back- ground of pointed firs, swerving to a stop where she had tumbled into the snow.

“Any bones broken?” he had asked, giving her a hand, and she had come up laughing with him, their faces flushed in the winter sun, with the blue, blue sky overhead. The fresh sweetness of the air that day had remained in their relationship throughout. Oh, how was she going to give him up?

“You looked like an ad for winter sports — with that scarlet and white outfit of yours. It was more than your mouth, and your eyes, and the blue-black glints in your hair. It was more than all that. Something so strong, some essence, some force, I should have felt it in the dark. It sang in my veins: Here she is! This is the one!”

Jeanette sat silent. It was an uncanny description of how she had felt herself.

“I’ve looked at it,” Richard went on. “I’ve examined it from every angle, but there it is. No different tonight than it was that day! This is it, Jeanette. Deny it if you can.”

“I can’t deny it, Richard. The same thing happened to me.”

“Jeanette!” Richard made no move to touch her, to reach for her hand, but he was visibly moved. Relief and joy flooded his face, and his eyes embraced her, his voice caressed her. “Jeanette, I love you.”

“I love you, Richard,” Jeanette said simply, because she could not honor him with less than the truth.

Time stood still. The waiter came then, deftly serving them the creamy lobster on its red half-shell. It could be like this forever, with Richard loving her, with her loving Richard, Everything fell away from this one glorious fact — their love for each other. It was beauty too sacred to mar.

It was a tide upon which to drift, and tremendous temptation to do just that. But marriage was more than soft music, lights, and perfume. It could change to ugliness and death in sudden and vicious alchemy without the fundamentals, without the essentials, and without faith. The proof of that was all too visible on every hand. Yes, she loved Richard. Richard loved her, but this could make no difference in her decision. It would only be infinitely harder, now.

“Time is heaven,” Richard was saying. “Time with you — to talk things out, to work together. Is there one single thing in which we disagree? One single subject that we haven’t discussed?”

“One,” said Jeanette, with ice in her heart, laying the issue on the table between them, “only one.”

“Why have we steered around religion?” Richard wanted to know.

“It is so personal and so sacred,” Jeanette said, feeling her way.

“That, and fear,” Richard agreed. “I was afraid it would come between us. I have thought a great deal about it. I wanted to talk about it, but I just didn’t dare.”

“Richard! You did? So did I.” They both laughed, and their laughter was like a bridge over a chasm. “I was afraid, too. And it might!”

“It might,” agreed Richard soberly. “Jeanette, remember the day I asked you to take that hill with me when we were late?”

“It took all my courage,” Jeanette confessed, remembering the dizzy incline that skirted a sheer canyon wall.

“But you did it,” Richard exulted. “Now we must take another. Ready?”

“If you say so, I’m not afraid,” assented Jeanette, wondering tremulously what, exactly, he meant. “What, Richard? I’m ready. What is it?”

“I love you, Jeanette. I want to marry you, but I never will until we agree on the subject of religion.”

The hill was heady; the descent was sharp, but they took it together. “That,” said Jeanette, “is exactly what I’ve been trying to say to you.”

“I want children. I want a home. Divided faith is none at all. I’d rather lose you quickly than to lose you to bickering and frustration, and to the deep sorrow I have seen come to other homes. I’m thinking of little Jeannie and little Dickie now, you know,” he finished with a rueful grin. “Know what I mean?”

“I know exactly what you mean, and I’m with you all the way.”

“Make no mistake. I want you, I will fight for you. I’ll pray earnestly, and I’ll study diligently. I may as well confess, I like what I’ve seen of the Church in Mutual and your socials. Give me your books, and I’ll give you mine. Somewhere truth is to be found. I’ll not change my belief without honest conviction, but I’ll not let you go easily.” He laid his hand, palm up, on the table. “Is it a deal?”

Here was a man — a man who could lead! Here was a man she could follow, once he was converted, for he would go nowhere unless it was right. Knowing how it would end, knowing where the search for truth would lead, and with no fear for study, Jeanette put her hand into his. Richness flooded over her; joy poured back into her heart. The way was still narrow, the gate still very straight, but both led to beauty.

“It’s a deal!” she said.

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "Conversation at Dinner." Keepapitchin.org, 24 Mar 2017, https://keepapitchinin.org/2017/03/24/conversation-at-dinner/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2017, Mar 24). Conversation at Dinner. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2017/03/24/conversation-at-dinner/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2017/03/24/conversation-at-dinner/">Conversation at Dinner</a>