I have long gathered what I could find about the evolving LDS understanding of suicide. I’m far from being able to write about it, even to the extent of a blog post, but I found this bit last night that I think is so compassionate and beautifully stated that I feel like sharing it now, even without surrounding context.
George H. Brimhall, once president of Brigham Young University, died by suicide on July 29, 1932. The next morning, his friend James E. Talmage broke the news to another friend distant from Utah:
This morning’s paper announces the death of our good brother, George H. Brimhall, at Provo. He was near the completion of four score years of life and has been ill for many months; indeed, his death has been long expected. But it seems that worn out as he was, almost prostrated physically and nearing the inevitable collapse mentally, he could not wait for Azrael, ((Although not a Biblical character, Azrael was the “angel of death” in ancient Jewish folklore. He was not seen as a terrifying figure – not the Grim Reaper, in other words – but, as his name suggests, he was the “helper of God” in summoning souls from life.)) the death angel, to call upon him on the next round, so he had to summon the messenger, which, as it appears, he did with the help of his hunting rifle. I think that the manner of his passing may well be left with as little comment as possible. He has accomplished a great work and has gone to a great reward.
A beautiful and proper tribute for an event so sad.
For a very touching, very honest treatment of Brimhall’s death, see Mary Jane Woodger and Joseph H. Groberg (a Brimhall great-grandson), From the Muddy River to the Ivory Tower: The Journey of George H. Brimhall (BYU Studies, 2010), pp. 200-2017 (and endnotes).
That is a really good response in such a sad situation.
I can understand the desire for “as little comment as possible” in 1932 — but I am glad to know of the manner of Brimhall’s passing, and of his friend’s compassionate response.
Thank you, Ardis. This is extraordinary, and beautiful.
Bravo, JET.
Elder Talmage wrote similar sentiments in his journal entry of July 30, 1932: “Word is published today of the death of our beloved brother, George H. Brimhall, which occurred at Provo yesterday afternoon. Brother Brimhall’s life has been marked by one good work after another, particularly in educational and Church activities. He was my senior in classes in the old days at the Brigham Young Academy, now Brigham Young University, in which institution he rose through the several ranks and reached the position of presidency. For several years past he has been designated President Emeritus of the Brigham Young University. There is an element of tragedy in his passing. For many months he has been ill and his death has been expected; but, worn out in body and under a mental collapse, he seems to have been unable to await the next call of the messenger of death, and summoned him with the aid of a hunting rifle. I am sure the man was wholly irresponsible and that every circumstance will be taken into account in the final judgment as to his splendid life and sudden death.”
Very touching. Thank you for sharing this, and also thanks to Gary and Jim for the additional information.
Thanks for this. I hope some day you’ll write another post with more of your collected thoughts. I came to get some bleak midwinter light by catching up on Keepa. This is timely and enlightening, as ever.
Thank you for publishing this beautiful thought. My brother committed suicide when he was 21 years old in 1971. His was a pure, sweet, innocent and beautiful soul. He was abused very badly by my father, both physically, mentally and emotionally. It broke him. He died of a broken heart and shattered spirit at his own hand, but I have never held him responsible for it. He went into the loving arms of Jesus and was healed of all his torments. My dad had his torments, too, and I am sure he has been healed of them, too. In fact, they both came to me in a “dream” not very long ago, together, both of them very happy.
Compassion and empathy will never grow old. I’m glad you found this, Jan.