From the Relief Society Magazine, 1960 –
More Precious Than Riches
by Betty Lou Martin
“Ted, come here quick. Look at the new living room set that the Andrews are getting.” Carolyn Hayes watched curiously out the window. “Honestly, they’re always getting something new. Why, only last month they got a new car, and the month before that …”
Ted Hayes put his arm affectionately around his wife. “Now, dear, we’re not interested in what the Andrews get new. After all, they don’t have any children to buy for, and we have three to take care of. they can afford things like that.”
Carolyn turned dark, intent eyes upon Ted. “Really, Ted, I don’t mean to be envious, but I can’t help but admire the nice things that Barbara and Chris Andrews have. Why, Barbara even has a dishwasher.”
“But just think, Mrs. Hayes, you have three dish wipers and one potential one. What more could you ask for?” Ted teased in his good natured way.
Ted, with his clean-cut appearance, his blonde curly hair, and his appealing blue eyes, could always make Carolyn smile. he had a way about him that would make the world seem rosy and bright, even on a rainy day.
“I’d like to see the time that you or the children finish the job of wiping the dishes for me,” Carolyn laughed. “At least, I know that you have good intentions.”
Carolyn finally got the twins, Jimmy and Jenny, ready for school. They had just walked out the door when the baby, Cathy, started to cry. “Oh, Cathy, you’re supposed to sleep right now so Mommy can get her washing done.” Carolyn sighed. “I can see that this is going to be one of those days.”
After several unsuccessful attempts, Carolyn finally finished the washing, then she made the beds and did the breakfast dishes. She worked through the lunch hour, and by the time the nine-year-old twins came home from school, Carolyn was exhausted. “I really should iron a few of those pieces before I start dinner, but I’m just too tired.”
“Mother,” Jimmy called from the living. “Mrs. Andrews is here to see you.”
Oh, no, thought Carolyn, and I look so untidy.
Barbara Andrews sat across from Carolyn and chatted to her about their new living room set, and the trip that she and Chris planned to take to New York. Carolyn listened with excitement. if only she and Ted could take a trip like that, but they could never afford it. Besides, they wouldn’t have anyone with whom to leave the children.
“Oh, Barbara, it all sounds so wonderful. why, I’ve never hardly been out of the State, let alone to New York,” Carolyn said.
Barbara was her usual, well groomed self. “I am excited about it, Carolyn. Of course, we always take a vacation every summer. Why, it just wouldn’t seem right if we didn’t.”
Carolyn felt even more conspicuous in her soiled blue cotton dress, with her dark hair disheveled. Barbara was trim and neat in a fresh cotton skirt and blouse, and her blonde hair was beautifully combed.
“Well, I really must be running. I’m meeting Chris for diner in town tonight, and then we’re going to take in a show. Do come over and see my new furniture, Carolyn.”
The thought of a show sounded relaxing to Carolyn, and when Ted came home, she suggested that they go.
“It’s fine with me, honey,” Ted replied. “We can all go to a drive-in.”
As it turned out, Carolyn wished that they had stayed home. Cathy wouldn’t go to sleep, and the twins kept bouncing around in the back seat of the car. Every few minutes they had to have some popcorn, and then some candy, and then – “a drink of water, please, Daddy.”
Carolyn did take note of the beautiful moon that night, and her thoughts went back to the days when she and Ted were courting. The next thing she remembered the show as over, and Ted was taking the speaker out of the car.
“Ted, I’ve been to sleep; why didn’t you awaken me?” Carolyn asked.
“You were sleeping so peacefully that I just didn’t have the heart.” Ted winked at Carolyn.
The next day started out the same way for Carolyn, and she didn’t have a spare minute to visit with Barbara. Suddenly it occurred to Carolyn that Cathy’s second birthday came the end of the week. “We’ll have to have a little family party,” she mused. When the twins came home from school, Carolyn told them of her plans, and they eagerly helped her plan the occasion.
The night of the party finally arrived, and little Cathy was proud and happy. she laughed and talked and tried to blow out the candles on the cake which Carolyn had taken so much time decorating.
Carolyn looked around at the happy, laughing faces of her little family, and she knew that every moment of exhausting work was worth it. What would she ever do without them? They were more precious than riches. Just then a knock came to the door, and when Carolyn answered it, Barbara stood before her.
Barbara looked around at the gaily decorated table, at the cake with its two single candles and one to grow on, and at the brightly wrapped presents on the table. “Oh, I’m sorry, Carolyn, I didn’t know that you were having a party. It’s just that I …” There were tears in her eyes as she spoke. “I get so lonesome when Chris isn’t there. Oh, Carolyn, you have so very much to be thankful for.”
Carolyn thought with amazement, all this time I have been admiring her beautiful things, she has been wanting what I have. she took Barbara by the arm and led her into the dining room.
“I’m so happy that you came, Barbara. You’re just in time to have some cake and ice cream with us. Little Cathy will be delighted, too. She loves visitors.”
As Carolyn set a place for Barbara, she turned toward Ted and gave him a radiant smile that said, “Thank you for all the happiness that we have together.”
Ted, in turn, wondered what he had done to deserve such a lovely, glowing smile from his beautiful wife.
I find this tale mildly disturbing. Carolyn seems overwhelmed and on the edge of burnout. In 1960, I was nine and my sister was eight. We often did the dinner dishes together. My husband has taken charge of kitchen clean up almost every night for over 40 years, marshaling the children to the task when they were still with us and on his own since our nest emptied. Surely Ted, bless him, could wash the dinner dishes with the kids, at least some of the time. And, in my humble opinion, if the twins are old enough to go to school, they’re capable of making their own beds. Carolyn is doing no one any favors by not allowing them to learn these basic human survival skills. How much our expectations have changed in 50 years!
It also seems overly contrived to me. Like Mary Lynn, it seems nine year olds ought to be doing more. My four year old helps to dry (non-breakable) dishes on occasion,and we all know that earlier generations were more skilled in domestic arts than we are today. 😉
Thinking further, Little House in the Big Woods has four year old Laura and six year old Mary in charge of making their shared bed and washing their plates at every meal. That was set in the 1870s!
I had a writing teacher describe writing like this as ‘selling your soul for a pot of message.’
Maybe poor Carolyn truly is burned out and needs so help in some way. But she only has one pre-schooler. She doesn’t have a child born every other year, plus cows to milk and chickens to feed and cloth to weave and clothes to make, all while cooking over a wood fire. The Relief Society Magazine had plenty of stories about pioneer women doing all of that without turning a hair. But that wasn’t the point that this story was trying to make.
I think today, at least among Mormons, Barbara would have explicitly confessed her infertility problem. From what I have heard in our area it is anything but rare. IIRC in 1960 that was something you just didn’t talk about…