Advent: A Partridge in a Pear Tree

From the Relief Society Magazine, January 1968 –

A Partridge in a Pear Tree

By Emma Lou W. Thayne

“I hate Christmas! I hate going home, hut it would he worse to stay here.” Jenny Harrow brushed a straggle of untinted, almost brown hair off her forehead and sank onto the familiar hardness of her desk chair. “But here we go again. Vacation, and another ordeal at home. If only I could just black out for two weeks and be right back here starting a new year.”

She whisked a stack of papers into a drawer, closed it deliberately, and stared unseeing at the suddenly very empty room. “After twelve years of teaching, you’d think I’d be used to it — going home, that is.” She knew that in seven hours Miss Harrow, the good school teacher, would be plain Jenny Harrow, unmarried daughter, home for Christmas.

The tree by her desk, which moments before had been gay with tinsel and packages, drooped straggly and ill-shaped. The floor and the children’s desks were littered with party leftovers. The sun, through the arduously tinted windows, fingerprinted the third grade efforts of seventy-two sticky hands that had glued and painted them. Jenny was tired, but more than just “three-thirty tired.”

Far down the hall she heard him coming. The clomp and skid were unmistakable. It had to be Widdy. What had he forgotten now? Wondering, she shook her head and smiled. Two days ago it had been a stocking. Now, who in the world could lose a stocking — with his shoe still on?

When the class colored, Widdy never could find a black. “I don’t like dark things anyhow, Miss Harrow.” When they sang he never followed the words. “It’s more fun to look up, Miss Harrow.” In reading group he raced ahead and could never locate his place when his turn came to read. “I can’t wait to find out what happens, Miss Harrow.”

Widdy could not wait for anything. Life was an urgent magnet, drawing him eagerly into its dynamic flow. And, with a wistful expectancy, he ran to it unimpeded by trivia such as socks and crayons, words and turns. And now he panted into the doorway, his husky shoulders raised in a huge sigh. “Hey, Miss Harrow, I brought you something.” He slammed a bedraggled package into her hands as if passing a stick in a relay. Then he slid, turned, and airplaned around the corner of the door.

He caught the jam with his arm just before disappearing and thrust his matted blond head back into the room, smiling so hard his eyes almost closed. “Oh, and listen, Miss Harrow,” his voice was out-of-breathy. “I made that so you’d have it to hang on your tree when you go home. It’s just like one we used to have that I liked a lot. But it got broke. And …” He was suddenly sober. “And merry Christmas. You sure are a good teacher, Miss Harrow.”

He tipped his head pensively, then smiled again and was gone. The clomp and skid down the hall echoed his hurry.

Jenny looked at the box, its tissue clinging perilously to the misshapened container. It was easy enough to open. Inside, resting on a lumpy piece of incongruous cotton, was a tiny bird cage. It had been built of toothpicks, glued tenuously to key rings of three different sizes to create a kind of Japanese lantern. Except for a tiny gold ring at the top, it was painted green, with some of the excess paint oozing at the intersections.

Inside the cage hung a battered little bell, suspended from the gold ring by a wire from a plastic bread wrapper. And glued onto the bell, its wispy feet one glob of goo, was a canary, cut out of a magazine, yellow on one side, a printed ad on the other. Its edges were irregular and it drooped a touch, but its identity was sure.

What a job for an eight-year-old! thought Jenny, especially Widdy! She could picture his stubby fingers working with those toothpicks. How tedious. It must have taken him hours. She rested an elbow on the desk and dangled the cage by its Christmas ornament wire. It would make any tree.

She stared dimly through the green bars, past the yellow canary and began hearing the only bird song she could associate with Christmas. “And a partridge in a pear tree …” yes “… four calling birds, my true love gave to me … and a partridge in a pear tree.” The first day of Christmas. Jenny peered into a long-ago living room. How long ago was it? Twenty-five years? Impossible. But there was the tree outlined against the window, the dark heaps of awesome newness silhouetted at its base. Oh, how she had wanted that rubber doll—a real Dy-Dee-Doll! No one had ever had such a rubber doll before. You could really bathe it, and put powder on it and hug it hard. And it would feel so real.

Corinne was asking for one, too. Then they could play with them together, maybe in Corinne’s house trailer by the garage. She could let her new doll sleep in the special pink bed with the drawer under it for clothes, the one she had painted with Mother, the one they had made out of the “lug” the peaches came in. Corinne said hers would be named “Geraldine.” Jenny’s would be “Florence” or “David,” depending on whether it was a boy or girl. She always had to see what color the eyes were before she knew for sure.

On Christmas morning Father made them eat breakfast first and then line up according to age to march in to the tree. She always felt sick with anticipation. They began their arch, four brothers and Jenny, laughing a little hysterically. Three times around. Each time they spied a new treasure. A basketball for the boys. A wagon, almost like new, for the littlest. A doll house, full of rooms and furniture, of course for her. She was the only girl. But where? Where was her Dy-Dee-Doll? Father turned on the lights and they sprang at their surprises from Santa. Ignoring the doll house, she searched frantically around the tree, upsetting gifts and even moving chairs.

“What are you looking for, Jenny?” Mother laughed. “Santa wanted to surprise you with this playhouse. See, it has lamps and rugs and curtains.”

“But, Mother, where’s my doll?” She had been so sure. They must have known how important it was.

“Oh, Jenny, those dolls—you wouldn’t want one. They’re poorly made and terribly expensive. Look, come and see how much fun you can have with this little house. You have other dolls.”

Sometimes that winter Corinne let Jenny bathe her rubber doll. She was a good friend and she said she would let her tend her baby any time she wanted

Jenny caught the bird cage in her hand. So now, Jenny, she thought, it’s time to go home again. She laid it tenderly back on its lumpy bed and smiled at the thought of Widdy. She would take it home all right, and hang it in a place of honor.

She locked her room and walked toward the office for a final check of her mailbox. The halls were deserted and sounded of the eerie quiet of a silent school, unnatural and uncomfortable. The office door was open, across from the display case that still flaunted its Christmas joys. Principals, she thought, must also be the last to leave the ship. But voices from the inner room meant that Miss Riley was not alone. Stepping gingerly through the outer door, Jenny headed for the mail slots. She heard the ordinarily calm Miss Riley almost shouting, “I’m aware that you have a problem, Mr. Reynolds, but you can’t just accuse without proof.”

“Without proof! Good grief, what does it take?” The man’s voice was excited, but not belligerent. “I saw this kid in the back yard by the pen. The gate’s locked and nobody would just be walking through. What was he doing in there, if not stealing my bird?”

“Maybe he just wanted to look, Mr. Reynolds. This boy is full of curiosity — about everything. And he likes birds.”

“Yes, I guess he likes birds! And he took my best pigeon. Every kid on the street saw him with it, and I haven’t seen it since.”

“Well, what’s his story? Have you talked to him about it? Don’t you think it would be fair to hear his side before you come charging in here accusing him? Why didn’t you ask …?”

“I would have,” the man interrupted. “I tried to find him, but no one was home at his house, as usual, and I figured the only place I would get any satisfaction short of calling the police was to come here. Most of the kids say you’re fair and tough — well, that’s a funny thing to call a lady, but I need you to do something.” He paused and softened a little. “I don’t want to hurt the boy, but those pigeons are about the only thing I have that mean much to me.”

“I understand your wanting to get the bird back all right, and I would like to help, but if you knew Widdy better …”

Jenny started. Widdy! Widdy in trouble? Widdy a thief! Oh, who would have the nerve to accuse him of anything malicious! She set her jaw to quiet her turbulent anger and strode uninvited into the inner office.

She looked into the dark eyes of Widdy ‘s accuser, nicer eyes than she had expected, and blurted, “Why, Widdy Turner wouldn’t hurt a fly.” Had anything ever sounded so trite?

The man looked to Miss Riley for explanation. She gestured a quick, “Mr. Reynolds, this is Miss Harrow, Widdy ‘s teacher.” Then to Jenny she said, “Miss Harrow, Mr. Reynolds thinks Widdy stole his prize pigeon this afternoon.”

“Think? I know. I saw him.” He was firm. Everything about him was firm, his forehead that ledged deep eyes, his jaw that worked, even when he wasn’t talking, his hands that nudged a crease in and out of the hat he held. Jenny thought, That crease doesn’t have a chance.

“What makes you think — or as you claim — know this?” Against her will, Jenny’s voice mellowed. “I know this boy like the back of my hand (trite again — sure sign of distress) and I know he’s incapable of willful malice.”

“Well, let me tell you about it then, since you’re so sure. No thanks, I don’t want to sit,” he said to Miss Riley’s sudden attempt to play hostess. He half sat on her desk and looked directly at Jenny, appraising her tailored good grooming, though his eyes never left her face. She shifted her weight, suddenly aware of a stray hair and of ankles never quite slim enough.

“This afternoon I came home early,” he started. “I’m going on a new shift tomorrow. Nobody is ever home at my place in the daytime since my wife died, so I was surprised to see someone moving around in the yard. I was in the bedroom and it took a minute to get to the back door. By the time I did, he was gone.”

“And it was Widdy you saw?” asked Miss Riley. “Are you sure?”

“Sure I am. I know all the kids on the street. Sometimes I play football or baseball on the lawn with them. Keeps me in shape. Most of them are pretty good kids. Wish we’d had some. But, anyhow, this Turner boy seems sort of strange — never really part of the gang. He’ll play for a while and then wander off without saying anything, not even ‘so long.’ But I know him.”

“Oh, know him, Mr. Reynolds?” injected Jenny. “From just watching him? From never having talked to him? Nobody knows Widdy that way.”

He glanced at her but went on, “Well, anyway, a couple of minutes later I went out to feed the birds, and Blossom was missing. She couldn’t have got out of the pen by herself. I knew that. So I walked out front to talk to the kids. They were standing around that big elm tree as they always do after school, even when it’s almost freezing like today. There were tracks in the snow and I could see where someone had jumped the fence. I asked the kids, ‘Have you seen anybody with my pigeon?’ They all nodded and one of them said, ‘Yeah, Widdy Turner just went down the street with it.’ So, as I told you, I went to his house. Nobody there. I didn’t know what to do, but I figured you would. So here I am.” He shrugged as if his case were closed.

Jenny’s mind whirred. How could Widdy have been in that yard and taken a pigeon and still have been here at school handing her a present, all at about the same time? School had been out — what — an hour and twenty minutes? He had been a busy boy. But what did he want with a pigeon — someone else’s? And where was he now?

Miss Riley filled the blank. “The only thing to do is find Widdy. Do you have any idea where he might be, Miss Harrow? Did he say anything at school?”

“As a matter of fact, he was here, not ten minutes ago. He came back to bring me a gift. Come to think of it, I’d like you to see it.” She found herself saying it much more to Mr. Reynolds than to the principal. “It would help you to know Widdy.” She opened her large bag and drew out the crumpled box.

Carefully she removed the lid and held up the curious cage. “He made this and gave it to me for my tree.” She handed it to the man. He took it gently and fingered its fragile props.

“Look at that bird,” he said after intricate scrutiny. “The glue on its feet is still wet. He must have placed it on the bell and put the top on sometime since school, maybe even since I saw him in the yard. So what did he do with the pigeon in the meantime?”

“Why don’t we go back to your street and look,” Jenny proposed, unconscious of a poised ease that had never been hers around men before.

Miss Riley walked back to her desk and plumped into a chair. “You two go hunting and I’ll get on the phone. If he’s not home, someone will have seen him.”

Despite windows twinkling with Christmas tree lights, the neighborhood was cold and deserted as the early dusk turned the gray slush on the walks into crackling mounds and valleys. Jenny even found herself clutching Mr. Reynold’s arm as her three-inch heels wobbled for footing.

“There’s where he climbed the fence.” He pointed, outwardly unmindful of her hand under his arm, but holding both hands and arm close in an unspoken welcome. “Come through the gate and look. Sorry I didn’t have time to shovel again this morning.”

The snowy yard showed several sets of footprints, and theirs joined the pocked path to the bird pen in the far corner of the yard. Almost before Jenny could see the birds in the dim twilight, Mr. Reynolds gasped, “Hey!” and ran toward the cage. “Look, she’s here! Blossom’s in here. How in the world?” He began examining the catch on the pen and motioned Jenny to join him. “That kid’s put it back!”

“What a relief! That Widdy—trust him to do the unexpected,” smiled Jenny. “I knew if he’d taken it, it wasn’t for anything mean. Which one was it anyhow?”

“That one there, the one with the brown blaze on its head. See, the one with … Hey, wait a minute. There’s something on her leg.”

He opened the door and reached for the pigeon. She snuggled with familiar ease into his open palms. He detached a piece of paper that had been fastened to its right leg with a wire from a plastic bread wrapper. Releasing the pigeon, he unfolded sticky layers of a note and squinted to make out its hieroglyphics. “Dere Mister Renalds,” it began.

“Here,” said an amused Jenny, “this is my department. I’ve been translating for years.” She took the wrinkled paper and read with little hesitation, even in the near-dark:

DERE MISTER RENALDS,

I BARROWED YORE PIGEN CAUSE I NEEDED IT FOR A EXPERMENT. I HAD TO SEE IF IT COULD BALENCE ON A BALL. THANKYOU.

YOURS TURLY,

WIDDY TURNER

P.S. IT COULD.

PSS MERRY CHISTMAS

Jenny looked up from the note and into the nice eyes that still looked bewildered. She was glad of the half-light that might disguise the unexpected emotion that filled her. “That Widdy,” she managed, “he had to make my canary authentic.”

Dan Reynolds put his hand on her arm. She could feel its firmness through her wool coat and interlining. He looked hard into her eyes that were now brimming with unashamed tears. He said softly, “You must be terrific — as a teacher I mean.”

Even Jenny’s ears pounded with her pulse. The years of being almost happy melted in her glow. The agonizing Christmases of the past fell away in the magic of that moment of acceptance. So what if Roger Dixon had passed her up with his mistletoe in the seventh grade. And David Mace — what if he had left her standing by the fountain and sneaked off to the Christmas assembly with Judy? The echoes of failure ran distant now. “No, I’m not going to the Snow Ball” … “Yes, Mother, I am chairman, but I haven’t a date for the dance” … “Yes, I’d love to be your bridesmaid” … “No, I’m not the least bit superstitious about its being three times” … “Oh, Corinne, a baby in December … How wonderful!” … “No, I’m not married yet” … “Yes, Father, I’ll be home for Christmas … I know, with all the boys gone …” Then, loud and clear … “You must be terrific!”

It would never be the same. That elusive “partridge in a pear tree” … the gift of the first day of Christmas — it was hers. Widdy had given it to her, and this man smiling down at her had confirmed the gift.

All the Christmases of the past blurred into one big, bright image — of a canary, yellow and cocky, singing a jubilant carol as he balanced, just right, on a battered bell.

Jenny laughed and kept looking into the nice eyes. “A good teacher, Mr. Reynolds? Yes. Yes, I am.” She soared with the “Thank – Goodness -It’s – Friday” feeling that only a teacher could know, and added, “And I’m going home for Christmas.”

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "Advent: A Partridge in a Pear Tree." Keepapitchin.org, 01 Dec 2015, https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/12/01/advent-a-partridge-in-a-pear-tree/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2015, Dec 01). Advent: A Partridge in a Pear Tree. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/12/01/advent-a-partridge-in-a-pear-tree/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/12/01/advent-a-partridge-in-a-pear-tree/">Advent: A Partridge in a Pear Tree</a>

10 thoughts on “Advent: A Partridge in a Pear Tree”

  1. Ooohh, good start! I love stories, and look forward to your tradition. Thanks for including me!

  2. The trouble with those rubber baby dolls is that if you inadvertently left them on a heating vent or under the radiator, they melted. Or so I’m told. I have only the faintest memories of what happened to my first doll. It’s probably a good thing, or I might have been traumatized for life.

    In the meantime, it’s so good to see Miss Harrow reframing her experiences in light of the fact that she really is terrific . . . er . . . as a teacher, I mean.

  3. What a delightful story! Of course, Emma Lou Thayne never disappoints. 🙂 Thank you for sharing some “ghosts of Christmases past” for our present enjoyment.

  4. Wonderful. And a first for my fiction reading here on Keepa: an author I’ve actually met. What a wonderful person she was.

  5. And just a hint, mind you, just a hint that the formidable Mr. Reynolds just might be interested in squiring that terrific teacher about town come the new year. Bless Widdy Turner for bringing them together.

  6. I have met Emma Lou Thayne a few times also. My daughter was in charge of the Thayne Center at Salt Lake Community College for several years, and I met Emma Lou at some of the programs there. So, it was fun mr me to see her as the author here.

  7. “The clomp and skid down the hall echoed his hurry.” That’s a delightfully precise description of how this third-grader makes his presence known in the hall.

Comments are closed.