What is doctrine? What is policy? Maybe some illustrations from our 20th century history will alleviate some of the confusion on display in the past few weeks.
A doctrine is a central, eternal principle of the gospel, given by revelation through God’s representatives on earth.
It’s true that our teaching of doctrine may be altered – the principle is eternal, but our understanding is finite and mortal: continuing revelation may expand our knowledge of what we had thought was established doctrine, or experience and maturity may shift the emphasis of doctrine. It’s even true that, on occasion, some few things that were taught as doctrine, or that had been received from previous generations as doctrine, have turned out to be faulty or false; continuing revelation corrects as well as expands our understanding of the gospel. Doctrine, though, is beyond the power of man to change; it is Truth with a capital T, which we struggle to comprehend.
A policy, on the other hand, is seldom if ever understood to be eternal. Policies change as needs change: practices adapt to social change in the world, to the scale of Church growth, to greater understanding of doctrine. Policies are the day-to-day practices, worked out by mortal men and women, outlined (we hope) by inspiration, to help us incorporate doctrines in mortal life. There is nothing sacred about a policy, except insofar as it leads us to understand and live by doctrine.
Some examples of eternal doctrine and adaptable policies from the 20th century can give greater perspective to the differences:
Baptism. As the first ordinance of the gospel, baptism is a doctrine; associated – unchangeable – doctrines are that baptism be by immersion in water, that it be performed by one authorized by priesthood, and that it not be performed on infants, but only for those who have reached the age of accountability (established by revelation, and therefore doctrine, as the age of 8).
Policies associated with baptism help to implement the doctrine in an orderly way; these policies changed from time to time in the 20th century and undoubtedly will change again as the needs of the Church change. Some related policies are the baptismal interview (which helps to establish that the candidate understands the seriousness of the covenant; the questions asked in the interview have been added to by policy, such as, for example, questions about abortion as that issue became a prominent one); the wearing of white clothing (not an essential element of baptism, but one which adds to the symbolism and perhaps the solemnity of the ordinance); the creation of a membership record (which doesn’t affect the validity of the ordinance, but does meet other scripturally mandated calls for order in the church, and for a record of sacred events); the timing of confirmation (whether that is done “at the water’s edge,” in the next following Fast Meeting, or according to some other timing); and even the definition of “age of accountability” in the case of delayed mental development.
Other policies related to baptism that the records indicate have changed over time are the timing of baptism of children: The doctrine says they should be baptized when 8 years of age – but does that mean it must be done on the 8th birthday, even when baptism is done outside, and the birthday comes during winter? or is it okay to wait a month or two or three, even when baptism is done inside so that weather plays no role? There have been policies – sometimes local, sometimes general – governing such details. At other times, at least in central and southern Utah, it was a practice for all the kids in town over 8 who hadn’t yet been baptized to be rounded up on a random afternoon, taken down to the irrigation canal, and baptized, with or without their parents’ knowledge. In the early part of the century, policy dictated that a member of the bishopric or another designated ward official performed all child baptisms; in the latter half, honoring a father’s priesthood and the intimacy between parent and child altered that practice. In the latter half of the 20th century, policies were set – and occasionally altered – governing what happened to the records of children who had been blessed as infants, and who were therefore known as “children of record,” who were not baptized when they were 8 or 9 or 10.
There is no doctrine requiring any of the details covered by these policies, but the policies help families and bishops and mission leaders know how to incorporate the doctrine into the practical life of the Church and its members. The policies change as the needs of the Church change.
Temple attendance, especially by women. Temple ordinances, beyond baptism for the dead, are closely allied to marriage and posterity, but the endowment is also “an endowment of power” beyond or outside of the marriage relationship. That endowment, spoken of in various revelations recorded in the Doctrine and Covenants, is a doctrine; to whom it was given, and when, are policies that have changed over time – not because the doctrine changed, but because Church leaders have endeavored to protect its sacredness while also sharing it as widely as possible.
It has long been policy for missionaries to receive their endowments before serving … except when it wasn’t. For much of the 20th century, when temples were few and transportation expensive, missionaries who were called from places that were distant from Utah served without having been endowed. That was policy, to serve a practical purpose.
Because temple ordinances are so closely tied to marriage and posterity, it was the policy for part of the 20th century that single women not receive their endowments unless they were going on missions or preparing for an immediate marriage. (This does not seem to have been a policy for single men, however.) At some point – and it varied over time: see policy – single women who were deemed unlikely ever to marry were allowed to go to the temple.
Otherwise temple-worthy married women whose husbands were not members or not temple worthy, may or may not have been allowed to go to the temple, depending on the time period. In all cases, married women going to the temple without their husbands were required to have written permission from husbands; I am not aware that the reverse was ever true, that married men required permission from wives (but I also do not know for certain that such was never the case; I just haven’t happened to run into any pertinent example or discussion). During some eras, married women were simply not permitted, with permission or not, to enter the temple without their husbands.
The doctrine was that the endowment is necessary for exaltation; the policies took into consideration the assumption that a woman could not be exalted without her husband, so there was no point in a single woman receiving the endowment. (Again, I haven’t happened to run into any relevant example of the reverse, of a married man being denied the endowment because his wife was not with him, but I do not know absolutely that such was never the case.) The policy was an attempt to protect the sanctity of the doctrine, or to regulate access in a practical manner.
A point relevant to the current issue: When church leaders explained to members or local leaders the purpose for denying temple recommends to women married to non-members, they usually mentioned their knowledge of women being pressured to abandon their temple garments, or ridicule of the garments by unbelieving husbands, or pressure on the woman to reveal things she had covenanted not to reveal outside the temple. They spoke often about the need for spouses to be united, and not wanting the temple to become a divisive issue between them. Their concerns were real, but that concern was a side effect, not the origin of the policy barring women married to nonmembers from the temple: the policy arose because of the nature of the endowment itself as a vehicle to exaltation.
Women sealed to multiple husbands. Whenever the issue of polygamy comes up these days, someone is certain to claim that Mormons still practice a form of polygamy because a man can be sealed to two or more women, as long as only one of those women is alive and not divorced from him. Eventually someone is certain to point out that a deceased woman can be sealed to multiple men. Confusion and contradiction ensues.
The policy about sealing a deceased woman to all husbands whom she married in life is a policy growing out of the Extraction Program and other practices associated with genealogical work and temple work for the dead, not one that grows out of any issues concerning polygamy. For much of the 20th century, a deceased woman could be sealed to only one man, even if she had been married multiple times in life.
In my family, a great grandmother, Charlotte Pace Lee, was married to three husbands, named Hobby, Hall, and Hobby (the Hobbys were brothers, just to make things more interesting); Charlotte had children by all three husbands. Charlotte was first sealed to Hall, because the Hall descendants got to the temple first. Then descendants of Hobby (1) appealed that sealing, claiming that Charlotte should have been sealed to Hobby (1) as her first husband. The First Presidency – it could be done only by the First Presidency – cancelled Charlotte’s sealing to Hall, and she was sealed to Hobby (1). Then descendants of Hall appealed that decision, claiming that Hall was Charlotte’s favorite husband, and she should be sealed to Hall (I dunno what evidence they had of that). So the First Presidency cancelled the sealing to Hobby (1) and Charlotte was sealed again to Hall. That wasn’t the end of it; there were continued wranglings over who Charlotte should be sealed to.
Eventually – due to situations like Charlotte’s, I assume – the policy was made that sealings would be done for first marriages. Period. End of discussion. The Lord will all work it out in the end.
Then in the late 20th century, the Church began the Extraction Program to supply names to the temples. This meant that someone would gather all the names and dates from, say, a book of marriage records in some county, and temple sealings would be done for all of the couples. A book of death certificates would be extracted, and baptisms done for everyone named therein. These extracted ordinances formed the original basis of the old International Genealogical Index (IGI). But the problem was, if you were extracting marriage records, that fact of marriage was all you knew about the couple. You had no way of knowing whether this was a first or a fourth marriage for either the bride or groom, because nobody was researching the complete lives of these people, the way you would if they were your grandparents.
So eventually the policy was established that sealings would be done for all marriages of the deceased, regardless of how many people either bride or groom ended up being sealed to. Period. End of discussion. The Lord will all work it out in the end.
Policies in matters like this are practical work-arounds, a real-world effort to carry out the requirements of a doctrine in a world where real life isn’t as cut and dried as we could hope.
Priesthood racial restriction. Here is an example that I think the whole Church, gradually and with difficulty, is coming to understand was an incorrect doctrine, one that came into the Church with so many other general Christian understandings and misunderstandings that were not explicitly corrected by direct revelation. It was taught as a doctrine, no doubt about it.
But there were also policies associated with this “doctrine” that shifted from time to time. During the mid-20th century, sometimes black girls and women were allowed to go to the temple for baptisms for the dead; at other times, policies barred them from even that much association with the temple. (Black boys and men were barred because – by policy – boys and men are required to be ordained priesthood holders to hold a temple recommend. But this raises a historical question that I have long had but not been able to resolve, yet: for much of the 20th century, children under 12 years of age were admitted to do baptisms for the dead – there are accounts of temple trips as Primary activities. Were any black boys under 12 included in such trips? Did the question even come up, and if so, how was it answered? I do not know.)
Policies over who was included in the restriction also shifted. President McKay apparently attempted to define the restriction as narrowly as possible, to those of black African descent. Dark-skinned peoples from other parts of the world were exempted from the restriction: Australian aboriginals, Fijians, Filipino Negritos are the groups normally cited as exempted. I know from personal experience that a man from Madagascar was also ordained to the Melchizedek Priesthood before 1978, even though, given the geography, the Malagasy must partially be of African descent.
Policies over demonstrating one’s eligible ancestry (or eliminating the ineligible, I suppose) for Church members in South Africa and in Brazil were also altered through the century: Instead of having to definitely prove one’s eligibility, ancestry was investigated only when there was a definite question.
These policies, shifting as they were, were all attempts to implement the assumed doctrine in a practical, day-to-day fashion. The issue gets confused when people insist “it was a policy, not a doctrine”; it becomes less confused when you distinguish between the assumed doctrine and the policies that grew up to implement it.
-oooOooo-
We could go on almost endlessly, identifying a doctrine and then noting the various policies that have been implemented, altered, abandoned, reworked in an effort to implement the doctrine according to the practical realities of mortal life.
In the current confusion over the new same-sex family policy, some – many – are analyzing the policy as if it were an eternal, unchanging doctrine, parsing the Handbook wording as if it were a finely crafted legal contract. That’s a mistake. We’ll do better to identify what eternal doctrine is at stake – perhaps the apparently eternal nature of male and female, both of whom, united in marriage, are necessary to exaltation – or some form of that idea, if I haven’t got the wording exactly right – and then to look at the policy as an attempt to protect / teach / implement that policy in practical, day-to-day terms.
If history is any guide, we can expect the policy to be adjusted from time to time, as experience teaches where it is too harsh and where it may even be potentially necessary to tighten up, as exceptions and circumstances and realities and understanding are brought into the discussion.
If I had any standing to offer advice, I would encourage everyone, both those who find the policy most painful and those who take satisfaction in it, to be patient. If God is directing this work – and I believe he is – and if Church leaders are men of good will who receive divine inspiration – and I think they are – then with time will come greater understanding.
On all sides.
Thank you for this, Ardis, as I think there are many people out there, myself included, who are helped by this distinction between doctrines and policies.
However, I think there is an interesting dynamic at play when a policy enters the public debate. After this policy was announced, for instance, some persons attacked it for various reasons. Some other persons, and the Church itself, understandably then felt the need to defend the policy. As the defense is rather strident (perhaps to match the rhetoric of the attack), it perhaps unwittingly begins to shift the policy from the policy space it so comfortably occupied into the doctrinal space. In other words, the policies are publicly justified as if they are eternal truths. I don’t think this dynamic is helpful.
Very helpful. Thank you.
I haven’t read the entire post, but wanted to make a comment on the issue of consent of unendowed persons to their spouse’s receipt of his or her endowments. The current policy, set forth in the handbook, is as follows:
I can tell you that this change was made sometime in the past 30 years, and I am inclined to place it in the early or mid-1990s, but I cannot recall the exact year.
On baptisms for the dead: there was a man in my home ward in Provo, a professor at BYU and bishop of a BYU student ward, who issued a temple recommend to a black man in his ward (so, presumably, an adult) to do baptisms at a temple. This must have been before 1972, since the man went with a group to the temple in Manti. The appearance of a black man at that temple caused the temple workers some concern, and they called the Temple Department in SLC for instructions. “Let him in,” was the answer.
So, apparently, the requirement of priesthood ordination in order for boys and men to do baptisms was not completely consistent even in 1970.
Thanks, Mark — I often hesitate to say “This is the way something is” because so much of my knowledge is based on old records. That shoukd always be a caveat when reading things that can change — and people who know the current practice should always speak up like you did.
Thanks, Ender2k, I hope it does.
I agree with you, DCL, that much of what has gone on recently and publicly is NOT helpful, in large part because it solidifies people’s opinions and stands before they have really had the opportunity to reflect — that goes for those who immediately announced their intention to resign, those who defended the policy *as if* it were doctrine instead of a malleable policy, and much in between.
Thanks for that additional example, Mark. I think it really goes to show both how we sometimes don’t understand policies and how fluid they can be, and also how hard Church leaders focus on the doctrine and try to be sure policies support and do not replace doctrine. It may not always work that way with fallible mortals, but
I think the desire and effort are there.
See page 488 of “Ezra Taft Benson: A Biography” by Sheri Dew regarding policy change on temple recommends for “worthy members married to an unendowed spouse.”
“Many Saints from around the world wrote emotional letters thanking President Benson for opening the temple to them. As one woman explained, ‘I express the gratitude that only those who ave been denied something for a long time can understand…I will always remember you as the Prophet who opened the temple doors for me.'”
As always, a thoughtful and (more importantly) fact-based piece on a critical issue. I think one of the most important aspects of the LDS doctrine of continuing revelation and living prophets and apostles is that it provides a self-correcting mechanism as the Church moves forward. I have read closely the recent excellent biographies of Pres. McKay (Prince & Wright) and Pres. Kimball (Edward Kimball) and found them both very comforting in their illustration of how God works with “[His] servants in their weaknesses” (D&C 1:24).
It’s sometimes hard for me to tell the difference — it seems more like there’s a doctrine/policy spectrum, and they meet in the middle. At the extremes, it’s clear: the Atonement is a doctrine, and “don’t cook in the church kitchen” is a policy. What we do is policy, and what we teach is doctrine. (It might not always be capital-T truth, as we’ve seen with our teachings underlying racial restrictions, but we teach it because we believe it to be). But sometimes I can’t even tell the difference between what we do and what we teach. Elder Oaks says “The Lord has directed that only men will be ordained to offices in the priesthood”: is that a doctrine, because we teach that it’s a revealed principle from the Lord, or is it a policy because it’s about a practice, and there’s not much theology to explain why? It doesn’t seem useful to make the distinction; I prefer to think of it as policy tied up with doctrine.
These policies bound up with doctrine seem to be less flexible the closer they get to the asserted doctrine. For example, priesthood ordination policies shifted for people whose ancestry was not certain at the time, but there didn’t appear to be hardly any flexibility for those who were positively believed to have inherited the curse of Cain — changing that part of the policy required a revelation, not just a practical adjustment.
I share your hope for greater understanding, and for adjustments of the latest policy from time to time. But I fear that a policy that’s so closely tied up with doctrine that it defines people as apostates, leading others away from the Truth, doesn’t seem likely to be very flexible.
Thank you, FMc — that’s another case of a change happening recently enough that I haven’t run across it in historical records. And what a besutiful way of recriving it, as “opening the tempke doors.”
“Self-correcting mechanism” — another helpful way to see policy adjustments. Thanks, bfwebster.
Few things about this life are as clean and neat as we’d like them, are they, Mike? Still, the more perspective we get, through time and experience, and allowing for further inspiration and clearer teaching on any given issue, the less confusing or contradictory things may appear.I’m pretty confident that policy vs. doctrine will become clearer with perspective.
We’re still in the earliest stages of sorting through gender issues, whether that’s same-sex relationships or women and priesthood. I know we want answers now, but I have to believe that answers will come, and that being impatient, or insisting that we know now all that we need to know, are responsible for much of the frustration and anger people are expressing. IMO.
My grandfather in Centerville, Utah was outside working when his older brother and some people from his ward came down the nearby hill. His older brother had just baptized a boy in the ward. Grandpa said that he wanted to be baptized, too, so he ran to find his father to see if he could be. His father said yes, so the ward leaders headed back up to the reservoir where grandpa was baptized by his brother at the age of 9 years 4 months and 18 days.
At my most recent temple visit, the proxy for the Lord at the veil was a black man. It was both a thrill and a tender mercy for me to have him take me in hand.
Thank you for this post and the grace with which youve delineated some rather harsh things we’ve experienced.
Thanks Ardis, this was great to read and discuss!