You know the legend of Daedalus and Icarus, right? Daedalus makes a set of wings for his son Icarus, out of feathers and wax. Icarus disobeys his father’s caution, flies too near the sun, his wax wings melt, and he falls to earth. Here’s an unusual depiction of that legend, from the 16th century Flemish painter Pieter Bruegel the Elder (( Or, as is now believed, probably an early copy by an unknown artist of a lost Bruegel original )):
.

.
If you don’t know this painting already, you might have to hunt for it. You see that pair of legs kicking in the water, toward the bottom right corner of the painting? That’s Icarus, after he’s fallen. The joke, of course, is that everybody else – a fisherman, a shepherd, a plowman, anybody on the nearby ship – is so intent on their own day-to-day affairs that they don’t even notice the extraordinary being in their midst.
That’s how it feels, sometimes, to be an unmarried Latter-day Saint. Marriage and the nuclear family are such fundamental assumptions of Mormonism, they are so basic to the day-to-day identity of members and expectations of leaders that nobody seems to notice the needs of the extraordinary one – the never-married, the widowed, the divorced, the childless, the Latter-day Saint with some other peculiar family situation – who has fallen in their midst, even when that exotic being is struggling, maybe even drowning, right under their noses.
It isn’t just the Conference talks, or the marriage-and-the-family lessons that are a part of every Teachings of the Prophets manual, or the Sacrament meetings that are consciously devoted to family themes (yesterday, my ward’s theme was “Strengthening Marriage and Other Family Relationships”). It goes a lot deeper than that and is far more subtle: The pervasive assumption of marriage reveals itself every time a class on any other topic devolves into a discussion of how to teach that topic to children; every time a Sacrament meeting speaker’s talk devolves into a narrative of “how I met my wife”; every time a speaker casually throws out the line “this applies to singles, too” without the slightest indication of how such a thing can be implemented by singles (my prime example of this is when three speakers tossed out that line in a ward meeting devoted to Family Home Evening); every time a speaker repeats the bit about “no blessing will be withheld in the eternities” and then continues under the assumption that he has adequately dealt with the needs of single members.
Because marriage is the default assumption, it seems unlikely that there is going to be any adaptation of Church rhetoric in the foreseeable future to acknowledge the needs of single members. I think it is up to singles ourselves to work out what we can. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about what I need from the Church – most of which I am not getting, at all – and here are some of the conclusions I’ve reached:
1. I am a child of Heavenly Parents, who know me individually and value me as me, regardless of any other factors of my life.
2. While the Gospel teaches about a life to come and preparation for the eternities, the Gospel is also a guide for this earth life. My mortal life is a preparatory period, as much as is the life of any wife or mother, and I have the right to divine guidance – whether through teachings of the Church or through personal revelation – to progress and prepare throughout mortality.
3. Marriage and family is not a reward for righteousness. Absence of marriage and family is not evidence of divine disfavor. I reject all attitudes in married people – often unknowingly projected, I’m sure – that families are worth more to God and to the Church than singles. Marriage may be superior to singleness; married people are not superior to single people.
4. I am not a priority in the agenda of the Church any more than I am a priority in the life of any human being. I can either be devastated by that reality, or I can do as I must do in every other aspect of life: Cope and succeed on my own, alone, with real but generally intangible divine help, and with whatever sporadic help is sometimes available from mortal friends.
5. I need not take personally any of the criticisms implied by the emphasis on marriage: Failure to find someone with whom to build a life in time and eternity is not a sin of which I need to repent. A lesson on the necessity of temple marriage for exaltation is not a divine commandment on which I must act (that is, there really is nothing I can do today to make marriage happen, and Mother Nature has long since written finis to the possibility of children in mortality.) The most I can do is understand the doctrine and be open to the possibility of marriage; there is no practical step I can take toward marriage today. (( And, as readers, don’t you dare presume to give me personal advice in this area of my life: Don’t suggest I move to some fictitious place where worthy and compatible men are a dime a dozen; don’t suggest I lose weight or dress differently or take up some hobby or learn to flirt or lower my standards. I am not within your stewardship, and gratuitous, unsolicited “solutions” are offensive. Just don’t go there. ))
That’s it, so far. I’m working on it.
I deleted a long, whiny section about what the Church ought to be doing with regard to singles – it’s bad enough to be seen as a malcontent, without adding the social crime of whining. All I’ll preserve from that section is this:
I don’t mind at all that the Church stresses marriage and family, and I don’t really mind (if I say it often enough, I might convince myself) having my worship time hijacked, as it was yesterday, by speakers who lectured me on the importance of spouses cuddling for 45 minutes every day, and going on dates together, and daily couples prayers. Fine. If that helps you married people, I can tolerate, if not appreciate, the advice.
But I, as a single woman, need counsel on living my life, too, with my peculiar needs as a single: If cuddling is so important to mortality that it becomes the subject of Sacrament meeting discussion, then how does a single woman supply that lack within the bounds of the Gospel? If intimate companionship is so important that a weekly date with your spouse is counsel from the pulpit, then how can a single woman fill the gap? If prayer as a couple is important, then what does a single woman do without the support of a husband with whom to pray?
Singles also need doctrinal guidance. We have mixed doctrine, historically: Will I have a chance to marry later, under the oft-repeated but difficult-to-justify-scripturally claim that no blessing will be withheld if I am worthy? Or will I be forever a “ministering angel,” a servant to others, denied exaltation, as was once widely taught?
So, what say ye, whether married or single? Singles, do you feel as unseen as poor Icarus in the painting above? Marrieds, are you sure you have any idea what it’s like for singles to listen to the talks and lessons geared toward you?
Take care to keep your comments general – unsolicited personal counsel from strangers on how I ought to live my life is unwelcome and will either be deleted or mercilessly ridiculed.
Comments regarding same-sex marriage, whether fer it or agin it, are not appropriate on this thread.
Howard W. Hunter, “The Church Is for All People,” Ensign, Jun 1989, 75
This is an edited version of a talk given 26 February 1989 at a Single Adults fireside satellite broadcast:
“For fifty-two years I enjoyed the sweet companionship of my dear wife. We are still married, for our marriage was sealed in the holy temple to continue on through eternity. Yet with her passing I became one of that increasing number who currently live on this earth as single members of the Church. Among those who serve as General Authorities of the Church are some who have been raised in single-parent homes, some who are now single because of the loss of their companion, and others who, following such a loss, have found a new relationship of marriage with worthy and loving partners. Some who served as General Authorities have preceded their wives in death, leaving their wonderful wives to once again experience that state of singleness which they left at the altar some years before.”
I know this doesn’t address all concerns, but I use it only to point out that church leaders are more aware of singles than we probably give them credit.
IDIAT, that shows an awareness of singles. It does not, however, address any of the needs of singles. It does not teach doctrine, or provide practical advice, or define a place in the Church for singles. It is limited to the widowed who, presumably, have benefited from mortal marriage and look forward to a reunion in the next life — something that is in stark contrast to the experiences of those of us who have never married.
Thank you for speaking out on a topic that needs to be addressed Ardis. I understand that the Church really believes that “marriage and family” are important, but with so many week after week lessons on the subject at times it feels like we have turned into “The Church of Family of Latter day Families”.
I teach Elders Quorum in my ward. There are several divorced and never married men that actively attend our meetings. Between the Ezra Taft Benson lessons and the “Teachings for Our Times” we had at least 5 or 6 lessons within two months time that were directly on “Marriage and the family” and many that could easily turn into “Marriage and the family” lessons or become largely focused on that (such as the upcoming “Chastity” lesson #17 in the ETB manual).
I try to control the discussion as much as possible so that the single men in the room aren’t feeling totally beat down by the time the lesson ends, but I still cringe every time that I have to teach one of these lessons. I wish that we had more lessons that focused on bringing everyone to Christ and then let those individuals decide how to apply those principles to their lives be they married or single.
I wish that we had more lessons that focused on bringing everyone to Christ and then let those individuals decide how to apply those principles to their lives be they married or single.
Me, too, andrew h.
Marriage and family is the default, it seems, even when it doesn’t need to be, even when it shouldn’t be. Case in point:
My home teachers are two single men in their 40s. Both still live with their parents. (Don’t read into that any hint that they are overgrown boys playing video games in the basement. Both are employed and productive men, both fill responsible ward and stake positions. Family circumstances in both cases make it reasonable for them to live as they do. The fact that they live with their parents is only relevant because they are members of nuclear families, even though they are sons rather than heads of families.) Last month, the message they brought to me was how wonderful it is to be part of a family, especially one with children (the mother of one home teacher has recently become a grandmother for the first time). Family, family, family. Children, children, children. Seemingly no awareness of how inappropriate such a message was for me. Did they want me to celebrate their good fortune? Fine, congratulations. But how did that message help me in the slightest? In my own home, yet! When they set up the appointment for this month, I agreed to the date but also said that I did not want any more messages like last month’s — if they brought a message, it had to be something applicable to my own life. We’ll see.
This is a really important post, Ardis. I hope it is widely shared and generates some very useful discussion.
Thank you, Gary. All God’s children need a place in the circle, don’t we?
I was almost 30 when I married. By some standards, that’s still pretty young, but by LDS standards, I had been a threat to the community for several years. If nothing else, all my friends from college had long since married.
I don’t know if I would say that I was constantly pressured to get married. Certainly there was some pressure, particularly from one member of my stake presidency while I was at BYU. But since I was already almost desperate to get married, I think the external pressure was kind of besides the point.
Some of the well-meaning attempts to help me get married were awkward. Some came close to “Why can’t you marry my friend/daughter/sister? It’s not like you’re marrying anyone else.” The perception that it was all up to me, and the single women in my community had no say in the matter, was bemusing.
I am quite confident that if I had not had the dumb luck to run into the woman I married at just the right time for her to be receptive to the idea, I’d be single today. And if I’d continued single, I’m not at all confident I could have remained active in the Church.
On the other hand, my stake has a 30-ish single woman in our stake Relief Society presidency and two of the best Sunday School teachers my autistic son has had have been single men. So the picture is not entirely dismal.
I think there is a fear that making Church more meaningful and rewarding for singles will somehow make procrastinating marriage more acceptable, and we must avoid this at all cost, especially for single men. I think the first step to addressing that fear may be to recognize that getting married, in the world we live in today, is actually a surprisingly difficult thing to do.
My daughter came home from a similar lesson yesterday where she was taught that to get to the highest tier of the celestial kingdom, she had to be married in this life. And the teacher, or at least her version of it, made sure to explain that this is a probationary time and you really do need to get married in this life, although it will all work out in the end if you don’t get married in this life.
She was, as to be expected, a bit confused. So we added in a bit of historical context to the changing nature of the top tier of the celestial kingdom marriage requirements and she was like “Oh, so we don’t really understand it?” And we were like, yep.
This was SS. Her YW lesson was all about the importance of dating. She’s 14. Sigh.
Addendum: She also said that she kept thinking about her friend who has said that she has no interest in getting married (again, 14, so who knows how that will change) and wondered if she should mention that to see where she would fit. But decided to doodle instead.
Ha! Doodling (or Facebooking) is a well-adapted technique for coping while in meetings.
I don’t know how teachers can justify saying some of what they say. That lesson is bound to stick with some young person who has no reasonable opportunity for suitable marriage. It’s so unnecessary.
I’ve long thought that LDS programs for single people were inadequate, and too marriage-focused. Segregating single people into their own wards is often effective in introducing people to their future spouses, but no ward can serve two masters: if marriage is the ward’s goal, than gospel living will be secondary. It’s also infantilizing to have activities for older single people “chaperoned” by younger married people, as if a ward activity was for High School students who needed to be kept from making out in dark corners.
“If that helps you married people, I can tolerate, if not appreciate, the advice.” The thing is, it doesn’t help. I’ve been in a bad marriage and a good one, and neither was improved by generic advice from the pulpit to cuddle or to go on a weekly date, or even to pray as a family. If a relationship is good, it’s because you’re already doing what’s good for the relationship, and if it’s bad it needs more targeted intervention than generic platitudes. In the spirit of Alma 31:5, I’d much rather improve my family relationships by hearing the word of God and learning to follow Jesus better, than by being given a generic “to do” list for better relationships.
I don’t have a lot of good ideas about doctrinal guidance, or the particular needs of single people, but the biggest thing I’d like to see, is talks, lessons, etc. that address a *general* audience of people who want to follow Christ. (And I mean *general* — I get so tired of hearing that certain talks are meant as general advice and the exceptions (e.g., single people) will have to figure things out themselves. If there are exceptions, then the advice isn’t general, is it?)
For example, I also teach EQ, and recently had the task of teaching an ETB lesson on the roles of mothers and fathers to a large and mostly childless quorum. The ETB quotes were mostly a to-do list for parents, but most of us weren’t parents, and some of us would never be. I’ve never been closer to throwing up my hands and giving up, but I figured that if I dumped the lesson on someone else, it’d be worse. We ended up talking about what kind of person you need to be to be a good parent, with the understanding that that sort of becoming won’t be wasted if children never come. Focusing on making the lesson applicable to *everyone* — even if children were a long-desired and never-fulfilled blessing (we do have some older elders), or if children were not desired — resulted in a good discussion that we could never have had if a general-but-not-really discussion was for parents only, and treated childless people as exceptions. It was hard to figure out how to make that lesson generally applicable (empty assertions that all women are mothers or all men are fathers are worse than useless, if you ask me). Still, the work of making lessons generally applicable seems like the only way to address a body of Christians, instead of some kind of support group for the *right* kind of person.
I like hearing of your personal experience, Kent.
Like you, I’ve ween more opportunities for service by singles in recent years. I’m glad for that. On the other hand, such callings are callings and are extended only by leadership. Singles need to serve and progress in our personal lives regardless of whether or not we’re noticed by leaders and receive callings. Many of us — certainly me — would welcome the right kind of teachings and assistance in making that progress, regardless of calling.
Mike R., that sort of creative reworking of a church-wide lesson — one that is supportive of the intended purpose but also addresses the circumstances of the class members — is so rare, but is, in my judgment, absolutely perfect. Thank you for showing that it is possible.
Thank you for this, Ardis. I’ll be considering your words for a long time.
My situation has fluctuated over the last couple of decades. Several years after our temple wedding in the mid-90s, my husband lost his faith and ceased all church activity. In the meantime, we went through many years of infertility. So although I’m married, I went to church alone for a long time. It was strange and awkward. People didn’t know how to deal with me or how to include me. A few people wanted to argue with my husband by proxy, to get me to explain to them all of his objections to the church so that they could refute them. Very occasionally people have tried to recruit me into reactivation schemes.
Then, after we’d more or less given up hope, we had two kids. Now I go to church with the kids. It’s rough. My son in particular does not suffer sacrament meeting gladly, and by the end of the seventy minutes–usually the worst of my week–I’m done in. I finally realized that I simply cannot have a Primary calling at this point in my life, but I don’t think my bishopric really gets understand why I can’t.
My wish is for just a modicum of awareness in some of the blanket statements people love to issue about the father’s priesthood leadership in the home. If there are going to be any religious practices in my family whatsoever, I will instigate and lead them. I assume all those insistent on men presiding under all circumstances would prefer religious practices, like prayer and FHE and scripture study, to no religious practices. And there’s no priesthood in our home. My kids don’t get the access to priesthood blessings before school or in illness that other kids do. A home teacher is simply not the same–often home teachers aren’t even available. My children will not be baptized by their father.
Last year my daughter came home from Primary in tears because of the things her teacher had said about atheists, not realizing that her father is one. Church is so, so hard for our family as it is. Please, church leaders and teachers, look around you, think about everyone and our varied circumstances, and don’t make it harder. That’s all I ask.
EmJen, you’ve got to be kidding. Please. Days of polygamy past. Ardis, I doubt your post will have any effect on the message du jour, but it needed to be written. Bravo.
Oh, Eve! Thank you for that sometimes painful illustration of the problem of not addressing the varying personal situations of even faithful, active Church members.
WVS, I don’t expect even to be the most minor blip on the radar. I only want to let other singles, or those in marriages or families that aren’t going to be featured in any of the standard marriage-and-family lessons, start thinking about our situation in a setting that isn’t just griping about what “they” do to us with a single-minded (see what I did there?) emphasis on marriage. Thanks.
The Brethren really can’t teach anything but general principles in Conference. The miracle, for me, is that this very general advice has nevertheless sometimes touched me deeply and helped significantly in keeping my marriage going.
My bishop has offered specific, tailored advice that is nonetheless built on those general principles, and it has also touched me deeply and helped significantly in keeping my marriage going.
Please don’t read into those statements that my marriage is particularly troubled. I think all marriages require effort to keep them going.
There is a gap between the specific, tailored counsel of my bishop and the general counsel of the Brethren. I think priesthood quorums, Relief Society, and Sunday School are supposed to fill that gap. From the comments here, it sounds like that is often not the case. Why? What might help us do better?
Mike R.,
Having spent some time in young single adult wards, I can offer some tentative observations:
1. Yes, they often see a lot of their members get married.
2. Once about 30% of the ward gets married, the effect on the morale of the rest is devastating.
3. The 30% who get married would probably have gotten married at about the same age anyway.
I am not a fan of singles wards.
I think priesthood quorums, Relief Society, and Sunday School are supposed to fill that gap. From the comments here, it sounds like that is often not the case. Why? What might help us do better?
I don’t know why it isn’t happening, Kent, but it is not. And I don’t want to invite a litany of examples of what can be felt as brutal remarks by class members who think they’re only repeating doctrine — we’ve all heard those remarks, and there isn’t any need to rehearse them.
Perhaps it’s a lack of imagination, the assumption that everyone else sees and feels and experiences life just like I do, when of course they do not. Perhaps there is some vague awareness, but leaders and teachers simply do not know how to adapt — we’ve seen far too little adaptation to model our own teaching after.
And I do want to repeat: I see nothing wrong with the Church teaching the ideal. They need to. That’s fine. I only mind that we don’t add to that ideal the kinds of teachings that would be helpful to those who don’t meet the ideal. (We teach the Atonement as well as the Fall; we teach repentance as well as the commandments not to sin; we teach resurrection as well as the cause/purpose of death — why can’t we also teach those who cannot meet the ideal, no matter how much they would like to, what we need to learn? And if nobody is going to teach us, we need to come to some understandings on our own. But this is not in any way a call for the Church to lessen its emphasis on marriage. Just a wish that the teachings were more inclusive.)
I agree that our church needs to emphasize more on individual discipleship (honestly, I’ve been pleasantly surprised by an increased emphasis on Christ in the meetings I’ve been attending). I recently participated in a Facebook conversation in an LDS support group for wives of husbands in certain occupations. The discipleship issue is something LDS moms need to hear as well. We are taught that our life will find ultimate fulfillment in motherhood, and many of us realize that it’s not actually the case. Different women have different talents and interests. Some women really do love playing with their children, taking them to activities, and sob when their kids are old enough to go to school. These women cannot think of anything that would ever give them more joy. Other women feel motherhood is somewhat unnatural and don’t get the same satisfaction. Due to LDS teachings, these women often feel defective – they are getting blessings that other women don’t get the opportunity to have, yet they do not have the bliss they are told they will experience. Motherhood is not the purpose of this life, it’s learning how to become a righteous disciple of Christ in whatever capacity you are placed.
Ardis, I would not presume to give you advice on your personal situation because 1) I’m sure it would be bad advice and 2) the idea of chucking a hymnal at the speaker has probably already occurred to you.
I have seen some lessons very tenderly adapted to the needs and situations of the class members. And I’ve seen some teachers really ride rough shod over their classes. I’ll have to think about this and see if I can think of any ways to influence this outcome from the outside. (The teacher can always influence it from the inside.)
Thinking aloud here:
We recognize a need for boundary maintenance, but we aren’t willing to leave it with bishops and parents, where it belongs. Hence we try to do our own boundary maintenance in Church meetings and classes and through the grape vine.
Excellent Ardis. Life is, at least in part, about learning the lessons that knock us over the head in a fallen world. In the church, comparatively few of us know about the kinds of things that single people experience *as adults.* By excluding these voices, those of us who are, for the moment, married, deprive ourselves of important experiential testimony. I’m sick of the sense that single people are in some liminal phase waiting there in suspended animation for the next step. BS! They are living in mortality NOW, just like everyone else and their struggles and triumphs are as valid as anything that happens to a married person. To a much lesser degree, the things you mention in your post are true of those of us who live in troubled marriages, whose spouse may be abusive, or unfaithful, or just a huge jerk. The idea(l) of eternal marriage that we get to hear about all the time hurts like hell from here, too (although I’m not trying to suggest it’s even close to the same thing) and requires some adaptation. Your active attempts to make your faith meaningful to you is an inspiration to me.
Since i started meeting with my ward’s high priests group i’ve become much, much more aware of this issue—the high priests (at least in my stake, but i think this may be a more widespread practice than that) have particular charge to make sure the older (which i think means older than 50?—it’s a fuzzy line) unmarried folks in our ward are taken care of, not just temporally and spiritually but also socially.
I mean, i will say that when i taught classes or spoke in sacrament meetings on the topic of family in the past i made an effort to be non-exclusionary beyond a “single people too” line (and i think i did a reasonably decent job of that), and i’ve hung out socially with plenty of single people in and out of the church, but until i actually had the opportunity to sit down and have a heart-to-heart discussion with someone and hearing a man’s loneliness as it approached twenty years since his wife died, or a woman’s sadness at never finding someone to spend her life with and trying to avoid beating herself up over her own imagined failings about it, or a woman’s triumphs mixed with sadness as she recalled the successes and failures raising her seven teen-and-younger children after her ex-husband left her for another woman to start a whole new family with…
I’ve tried to understand the depth of these feelings. I’ve learned that i can’t. I can empathize, and i can sorrow with those who sorrow (and joy with those who joy, too!), but i’ve never experienced any of these. But: It was offered in a different context with a different application, but i think it works here—when Elder Holland this past (or the one before?) general conference offered the line that “i may not be my brother’s keeper, but i am my brother’s brother”, he spoke to all of us in all of our dealings with those around us.
I don’t know what many of you on this thread are going through. I can’t. But i promise that if i’m given the opportunity, i will stand with you against the sadness and worry and fear and stress (and, yes, misplaced social opprobrium) as far as i am able. (And maybe, if i’m lucky, i’ll learn that “as far as i am able” is further than i’d hoped it would be.)
(And sorry—that went on longer than i’d wanted to. If you made it to the end, thanks for putting up with the length.)
The theme for the YM, YW, and youth SS this month is Families. That’s two hours of indoctrination on this subject for five Sundays straight, plus Duty to God/Personal Progress requirements and family discussion.
I get the impression that Church Leadership feels the “traditional family” is under attack from–pick your favorite bad guy–immorality, divorce, unwed mothers, abortion, delayed marriage, childless marriages, birth control, co-habitation, legalized same-sex marriage, transgender operations, etc. To combat these trends, they’ve chosen family life as portrayed by June and Ward Cleaver as the hill to die on. And as these trends are not going away, the rhetoric from our Church Leaders will become more intense, not less.
Historically though, LDS trends on all of the above topics follow those of society at large, with a delay of a decade or two. So I’m not sure the preaching makes much difference.
45 minutes of cuddling?! Oh hell no. Thank goodness that is not doctrine!!
Are church leaders still operating under the assumption that single people just need to “get off their butts and get married?”
That was the basic message even until a few years ago. Much helpful…
Ardis,
Great thoughts, much needed.
As a religious educator (seminaries and institutes), I share your concerns and want to do a better job teaching what the totality of scripture offers to the entire body of the church. Though there is much in the scriptures that is pro-marriage/family, there are other important passages we never quote that would be of value for all of us, single or married.
Luke 11:27-28, for example — a woman says to Jesus, “Blessed is the womb that bore you,” i.e., blessed is your mother. Jesus replies, “Yea rather, blessed are they that hear the word of God and keep it.” One way to read this is that the more blessed role is not motherhood (as wonderful and holy as that is), but being one who believes and keeps God’s word. That’s a scripture that might be deeply reassuring to many saints, and maybe productively troubling to others. But how often does it get quoted and taught among us? It also could be read as a statement like Mt 12:48-49, Lk 14:26, and many others in which Jesus prioritized ties to him and to the “family” of the church over ties to mortal family.
Another thought: teachings about celibacy were emphasized from the beginnings of Christianity, right alongside teachings about marriage and family (e.g., Mt 19:11-12 about those who are eunuchs for the kingdom’s sake, or 1 Cor 7:32-35 about the spiritual advantages of being unmarried). These teachings are part of our scriptural inheritance and of potential value to all of us. If we really believe in living by all God has revealed, we ought to be thinking about them. This is not to suggest that we ought to adopt the hierarchy of ascetic merit early Christianity developed (virgins are best, the married are only a notch above fornicators) – just that our efforts to minister to one another, leaving none of us out, ought to include taking seriously the whole of our scriptural and historical heritage.
I agree with everything that has been said. I know friends who stay home on Mother’s Day instead of being asked that ALL women should stand, because even if one isn’t married that person is still an influence for others.
Yesterday I played the organ and was not surprised when I saw the songs were Love at Home and I have a Family Here On Earth.
I think part of the problem is that people just don’t take time to think about what they are saying or doing or teaching, etc. My dear aunt lived unmarried for 90 years. She always put on a good front and none of us knew how she was hurting. My son worked for her once a week during her later years. After work he would take her to Baskin-Robbins for ice cream and she would open up and tell him things that she never told any of the rest of us.
Not to change the subject, but I am seeing other situations where people march in and cause hurt. I walked down the hall yesterday with a ward member who was quite emotional. She lost her husband to cancer about six months ago. She said to me that she didn’t realize how hard his death would be and how lonely she was and how hard it was for her to sit through lessons on couple’s relationships, etc.
The other situation is when a RS or GD class is on missionary service and how we should be good examples and good missionaries to others, and a non-member or inactive member is sitting the the class wondering if this is why so many people are trying to be her friend.
I love the parallel you draw between singles and Icarus. Feeling alone and drowning is a situation that most people can relate to at some point in their lives, and it should stir in them compassion for those around them actively experiencing the feeling. The stories are important and need to be shared as often as possible. Does it seem to you that single members are asked to speak and teach disproportionately to their representation in the church? Also, how can allies learn to speak in ways that are comforting and inclusive of single members?
I’m in one of those mid-singles wards and they come with their own set of frustrations but mostly they seem to at least try to fulfill the needs of the ward members. Yesterday, our bishop met with all the women of the ward while his counselors met with the men. They entertain questions and concerns for an hour with the promise that they would try and address them in next week’s fifth Sunday meeting. The very last comment from yesterday’s meeting really stuck with me. She pleaded with the bishop to in the preparation for next weeks meeting find some way to tie Christ and the atonement into their remarks.
I get so very tired of hearing the same advice that tends to get recycled over and over for single members. It’s either some sort of promise that if we’re good enough we’ll be blessed with a spouse, or silly dating advice likely found on the yahoo homepage or a teen magazine from 1957. And it’s never advice on how to live a good meaningful life without a spouse and offspring, it’s always geared towards becoming a married person.
I can work those things out on my own, it’s just so exhausting at times.
Comments are now coming in so fast that I can hardly respond to them individually. Please know that I am reading them and appreciate the personal experiences and the thoughts you express. Some of what has been said is directly helpful to me.
Thank you all.
An important and powerful post, Ardis. I wish I had something useful or helpful to say, but alas, I do not.
Great post!
One idea that I pitched to my (mid-single adult) branch president is to revive teacher development. I initially did it in the context of I-can’t-stand-another-SS-lesson-by-an-egomaniac-who-only-talks-about-themselves, noting that lessons are valuable inasmuch as they involve people in discussion on application of gospel principles to our lives. I want to one of the classes the other week, and was delighted to hear the emphasis on knowing the audience, and ministering to their needs.
I believe that the reason speakers like Okazaki, Uchtdorf, and Holland are so beloved is that they have a universal message of Come Unto Christ. They make no distinctions about gender, race, marital status, profession, or abilities. They welcome all, and show us ways that apply to everyone. Seriously, what I wouldn’t give to read the material Ozakazi was developing for the RS manual!
I wonder if one reason we talk about marriage and family so much is that marriages and families are so prone to disaster. If someone appears to be talking about cuddling, they are probably implicitly talking about the fear of ugly marital collapse. It’s just more pleasant to talk about “strengthening marriage” than “decreasing the likelihood of major drama and trauma.”
Marriage is an ideal, but it’s also a risky business. I definitely think we need stronger narratives for community life beyond family, but it may also help if we do better at directly acknowledging that families are more like patients on an operating table than pictures of perfection.
Such important stuff. Not only do those that are in the *ideal* LDS marriage situation suffer but those who are married where both spouses differ in matters of faith. My children have hardly been able to attend classes this month because fear of the marriage rhetoric being strong and inadvertently denigrating to not only us their parents who are in a very happy mixed faith marriage, but many others that they love dearly that do not, or cannot fit into those ideal marriage boxes. Christ came for all of us. All. Of. Us. We need to teach that.
I’m trying to decide what to do with this information. When first linked, I thought a lot of the standard things that privileged groups say about marginalized groups. Then I realized what I was doing, so I read. Obviously, I needed to hear these words. I didn’t understand the depth (and probably I still don’t) of hurt that can happen.
It hurts that people feel this way. I want to know what can I do to make lessons better for single persons.
I currently teach Sunday school to youth ages 14-17 in a largely non-LDS region, but honestly, I was thinking about Elder’s Quorum just now. I’m new to the area, but I know that at least 5 or 6 of the regular attendees (out of a couple dozen, tops? So a pretty significant percentage) are unmarried, and most of those never have been. And they’re not all 20-22. One brother is in his 50s.
So I thought, if I taught in EQ, I could do better. I could teach “This is how single people should approach this” as at least part of the lesson. But I worry that would come off as patronizing at best, and probably ill-informed.
So my honest question, when assigned a lesson (or talk) about marriage or similar, how should I approach it so I can involve the single members and make it edifying for them? How can I ensure that I am sensitive to everyone’s needs and feelings?
Ardis, I love everything about this blog article. Kudos to you. You have shared your concerns in a manner that instructs as well as conveys. I love your five numbered points.
One thing I try to get across to my fellow ward members (when I bother to work-up the courage to attend) is that the Lord did not form the Church to create pure or perfect persons. He formed the Church so that we might grow together and become one; a pure or perfect people; the Bride prepared for the Bridegroom.
And THAT marriage is THE MARRIAGE that we should discuss at church meetings, and not our comparably-irrelevant personal marriages. The more we can become one as a people, the more the Bride will be prepared for the Bridegroom.
Really, really good stuff.
Here I was mentally griping about how the EQ is increasingly becoming too young for me (all this talk about fathers and young children when I have already baptized all of my kids and have a daughter in college — sheesh! give something to us older Elders, please!)
I am sufficiently chastened.
Ardis, Thank you for this article. Don’t you think the emphasis on marriage was to raise our children as Mormons? So, we could expand our Church and beliefs? Our Church has had single events and few come. Usually fear of being matched up for a forever marriage. lol. How scary is that!!!!? Alice
There are multiple valid readons for emphasizing marriage, Alice, I’m sure. Some have to do with providing the best possible environment for each new generation to grow in righteousness. I am also certain that marriage is more than parenthood, and that the eternal bond between husband and wife has its own significance beyond that of parenthood.
To you and others who have mentioned the Church’s program for singles, other than singles and midsingles wards: There may be some good local programs out there, but I’ve never happened to be part of one that addressed the needs spelled out in this post. Singles programs are social programs, even when they aren’t matchmaking efforts. Meeting social needs may be important to many. It isn’t what *I* need, though. I don’t need amusement. I need answers, and counsel, and guidance on making the most of mortality within the realities of a singular life.
Richard Redick, I believe you are very much mistaken. The purpose of the Church *is* to assist mortal men and women along the path toward becoming more and more like God, which implies eventual purity and perfection. There is definitely a communal aspect to that growth, but in the end salvation and exaltation come to individuals, not to groups whose individual components may not qualify. Presumably, we could achieve perfect unity in joint sin or rebellion or slothfulness — that unity would not be an acceptable bride for the bridegroom, even if it meets your criterion for unity.
And I wonder how someone can legitimately claim an interest in “growing together to become one” if he doesn’t attend meetings with those whom he oresumably wishes to be united? This is not the personal condemnation it might at first appear: I always attend Sacrament meeting even when I have largely given up hope of hearing anything relevant from speakers; at least I’m fully present for the Sacrament itself. But it’s been more than two? three? years since I have attended Relief Society, and much longer than that since I’ve been to the temple. (I’m not trying to project any false image of myself here at Keepa. I struggle, but I have a sure witness of too many points ever to turn my back on the Church.) Separation is hardly a recipe for unity.
Just wanting to make sure my position with this post is not misunderstood: marriage is a key gospel doctrine. Its importance shoukd not be underestimated, nor shoukd we cease teaching the ideal. But we need to add to that — even if the adding is done individually when the group doesn’t provide it — counsel and support for those who fall short of the ideal, in whatever ways we fall short.
Ardis:
1) The purpose of the Church is “to invite all to come unto Christ and be perfected in him.” It is not to invite each, but all. There is a difference.
2) The Church exists for the perfection of the saints; not the saint. Again, there is a distinction.
3) Certainly, individual sanctification is an objective of the Lord’s and of his church. I spoke nothing against that, above.
4) We believe that through the atonement of Christ ALL MANKIND may be saved. It does not say each one of mankind who faithfully charts his or her way along the path to individual perfection (like a teen who charts their way toward Duty to God or their Young Women’s Medallion).
5) You need to understand that there is a collective aspect to the plan of salvation that you are, apparently, blind to.
6) Part of the reason I must rally the courage to attend church is because I attend with a bunch of nice persons who are just as blind to the collective nature of the Gospel. The highest laws of Zion were given so that every man might consider the interest of his neighbor as his own (law of consecration and stewardship….if that does not demonstrate to you that there is a collective aspect to the Gospel of the Kingdom, I don’t know what will).
Last of all, did you just wake up on the wrong side of the bed this morning, or are you always this disagreeable? I paid you a well-deserved compliment, and you respond by lecturing me (as if you have the superior knowledge!). You need to learn the Gospel, my dear, before you attempt to teach it.
4)
In my experience, admittedly limited to just me, the best way to apply a lesson topic to the members of the class is to ask for help. Start by stating a clear principle of the gospel. Then say, “Our circumstances are all so different. How do each of you interact with this principle?” Give class members time to respond. Eventually they will. Then they will express their applications–or their concerns. As I acknowledge each person respectfully, others will express themselves, offer help, or make suggestions. When the time is over, I restate the principle and end the class. Then everyone thanks me for a great lesson when they taught it. It’s not fool proof, but it usually works.
Ooh, do married men also get told to “learn the Gospel, my dear, before you attempt to teach it”? I didn’t think the object of the post was to show *by example* how easy it was to ignore the important contributions of Mormon single women.
Thanks for this post, Ardis. Currently I teach early morning seminary and am, I believe, the only unmarried teacher in our stake. We teach in pairs, so there probably close to twenty of us. As seminary teachers we are able/supposed to attend some extra firesides, including the annual CES fireside in March, to which spouses are invited. This year Elder Holland was the speaker and early in his talk he said this:
“Brethren and sisters, I think we have to start earlier to teach our students the place of marriage and family in the great plan of happiness. Waiting until they are of marriageable age puts us way behind the curve.”
A couple of minutes later he said:
“As always, your first and most penetrating lessons to your students will be the lessons of your own life. You show them in word and deed that your marriage and your family mean everything to you because they should—they must.”
It’s not that I disagree with what he says, but despite the fact we were sitting in a darkened chapel, I felt horribly conspicuous and out of place. And I remember thinking about the time President Hinckley’s side comment about one earring per ear suddenly became a church dogma. Was somebody going to pick this up and run with it? Were we going to be hearing in the next weeks that seminary teachers have to be married? Obviously that didn’t happen but I was definitely shaken. And yeah, hurt: whatever abilities I might have as a teacher are secondary.
This doesn’t answer any of your questions, but I had to share with somebody. Thanks for listening.
Thanks, Richard. Thanks for coming, and now thanks for leaving.
Great illustration of our common experience, Cate. Thank you for a great comment.
It’s not that I disagree with what he says but … I felt horribly conspicuous and out of place.
That’s the dilemma in a nutshell. We believe the doctrine, we support the teaching, but we’re left out in the cold despite everything we have done and can do. We need to know that there is a place for us anyway.
LOL, Mike R. I want you on my side, and never an opponent. 🙂
I don’t know if my non-member input counts, but I have also recognized in my church exposure an uncomfortable amount of assault by ideal. I was invited to a marriage class which I happily, if reluctantly, attended. After two consecutive class sessions where individuals talked about how much more meaningful their temple marriages were than my crummy time-only marriage, even in mundane earthly ways (“there’s more intimacy!”, “we’re so much more connected!”) I just had to stop going.
I realize this isn’t quite what you’re experiencing. As a non-member I’m expected to be less than ideal in many respects, but I suppose it at least gives me a taste and it’s not a pleasant one. I do notice the “marriage, marriage, family, family, children, children” and when it happens I cringe a little on behalf of friends who don’t fit that mold despite being faithful members.
Of course it counts, Matt, and thank you. One way I combat related issues in my Gospel Doctrine class is to insist that we talk about ourselves, not other people. I don’t tolerate responses that focus on other people’s sins, or other religions’ assumed teachings. The first lesson I attended in that class, while the previous teacher was still teaching, was an Easter lesson that quickly became a chorus of criticizing one church after another for supposedly not believing in the Resurrection. It took a while after I began teaching to curb that habit and steer discussion toward our own faults and beliefs, but it’s been a very long time now since anybody tried to build “us” up by running “them” down.
So we *can* learn, if somebody notices the problem and makes the effort.
I love your five points, Ardis, and I think they pretty much describe how I interact with the church as a never-married woman. One of the strengths of the church that I have lately come to realize is the way it throws together a bunch of people of disparate backgrounds, economic status, education, experience, etc. It accomplishes this by requiring us to attend a congregation defined by geographic boundaries. Most non-Mormons choose religious communities based on affinities like political leanings, pre-determined belief systems, etc. We are stuck with each other, and we must learn to love each other if our wards are to function at all.
Like Ardis, I have no problem with marriage being a fundamental tenet of Mormonism. But as she points out in her conclusion number 4, I just move on and deal with life in and out of the church, not expecting a lot from lessons. I have told my RS president (who succeeded me as RS president) that I will no longer be attending any RS lessons on marriage and family. I’ve had enough. What I crave is doctrinal understanding, and a sense of the role of the divine in my life. When I was RS pres., my main emphasis was trying to get the sisters to search the scriptures and to become immersed in the doctrine.
As for singles wards, I was in them for many MANY years. I enjoyed them, made lifelong friends, and in one case, my decision to leave my resident ward and go back to a singles ward saved my testimony and kept me in the church. Yes, they are/were often meat markets, marriage machines, however you want to characterize them, and I had my share of heartache over unrequited love/crushes on men I went to church with. But their effect overall was to teach me to become a responsible adult member of the church, fulfilling callings of leadership, visiting teaching, and more. There was definitely an infantile side to the social scene, but those wards did make me a better member of the church.
I guess in general, I’ve gotten to a point of saying, “It is what it is,” and partaking of those aspects that feed me or allow me to serve others, and forgetting the rest. I haven’t had the imagination to envision the kinds of things Ardis suggests, though in reading this piece, I find myself saying, “Yes, yes!”
Here’s to more conversation leading to action.
Thanks, Ardis.
Ardis, I am so grateful for your perspective on this, and your emphasis on meeting the needs of the individual. My circumstance is more in line with ZDEve (#14) than the ideal of a priesthood-led home, and I too struggle with knowing how to deal with children who ask why daddy doesn’t come to church, and how to interact with leaders who some times seem only to want to talk about why my husband isn’t active, rather than how to strengthen the people that come. I hope my experiences, and reading your insightful comments, will help me minister to individuals as individuals more effectively.
And, when I read about your philosophy on teaching Sunday School, like #51, it makes me wish I were in your class every week!
My daughter became a Beehive recently and her new YW leaders and class presidency came over to welcome her. Both YW leaders are single, never been married. The class presidency was supposed to talk about how important the Young Women program is. “It’s important because it prepares you to be a wife a mother,” one girl said. I could see the leader wincing. “And a disciple of Christ,” she said. “That’s the most important thing.” The girls kind of nodded but I could tell they didn’t get it.
To those girls, “wife and mother” is the thing they most think of. There’s a tension there: those are important roles. Young Women need to be enthusiastic about them. But the most enduring role is that of disciple of Christ, and it’s the only one that’s completely dependent upon their own agency, not whether they get married, not what their marriage is like, not whether they can have children. I really want my daughter to focus on that, first and foremost. She will then be prepared for whatever life hands her, and know that her essential identity and worthiness does not depend on what her family turns out to be.
Thanks for the article, Ardis. I very much appreciate your writing and perspective.
Your point number four is the one that hit home to me the most when my wife died and I was single again. But not only am I no one’s priority any more, no one is my priority either. I try to make connections, but it is hard when you are on the outside looking in.
CS Eric, isn’t that a stark realization? I’m trying to remember that that is true of many of the people I meet, but despite the many blunt reminders of that fact in my own life, my self-centeredness keeps me from often remembering it is equally true of others.
Thanks to all recent commenters whom I haven’t acknowledged individually. Your contributions are making this a valuable discussion.
I really appreciate Eric Ehlers’s question above, because it’s that kind of questioning from the privileged (those who fit the mold, if sometimes imperfectly) that I think will help to create more of a welcoming space for singles–and others who aren’t part of the “ideal.” That is, recognizing that when a teacher or class turns a lesson into “how do we teach this to our children?” it shuts out a large portion of many wards’ audience, rather than “How do we each apply this principle to where we are individually?”–including singles, married without children, parents (whether married or not), older people who might not have children at home, etc. It’s such a simple thing, yet it seems to be impossible in many areas for people to acknowledge.
Most of the wards I’ve lived in (regular wards, not singles wards) have had a significant number of single people on the ward roster, and only a handful of those people actually attending church. In Seattle, it was something like 300-500 single people on the rosters, with about 30 attending. Some might have just dropped off the church’s radar and decided to no longer practice, as my sister did, but many, many seem to be people who feel that after a certain point, whether that’s 25, or 31, or 40, that they were no longer welcome at church, that they didn’t have a place.
Some people can stick it out to just wade through the “you’re not welcome here” messaging, and good for them. They’re stronger than tenfold others, who are just as much children of God who deserve to feel like they are included in the gospel of good news, too.
I’ve read this four times today. I love it.
Two weeks ago I walked out of a stake conference during a talk that I described to my dad as feeling like a game of spiritual “Uncle.” As if someone was standing behind me, whispering in my ear “How many more painful statements can you take? Five? Six?”
So I appreciate your #5 especially, because that’s where I need to get to. For me, I’ve stopped apologizing for my lack of spouse and children, and I’ve started speaking up when the family talk gets to be too much, and I definitely call people out on the patronizing throw away “this applies to all singles” garbage. It might be waving my sword at the windmill, but it’s become one of my coping mechanisms.
Ardis, I love this post. I have a daughter who just turned 29, & a VTer who is approaching 50, & a good friend who is in her 60’s and is seriously the most knowledgeable person I have ever met on the subject of family history, & all three of them are single. Each of them deals with the “family” emphasis a different way. The good friend just morphs straight into family history anytime family comes up. It works for her, & I am glad for her. The VTer served as our RS President about 6 years ago & she was fabulous in that capacity, but I see a drawn look on her face when the speaker announces the topic is family- again. My daughter is getting that same drawn look. Granted, those are all observations, but so is this: as a 62 year old married woman, I do not need advice on how long or how often to cuddle with my husband. That falls under “none of yer darn business!”
I was personally thrilled when we had an entire month of the theme “Keeping the Sabbath Day holy”. It felt like a breathe of fresh air to finally have the Sacrament talks focused on how to better prepare individually to partake of the Sacrament, how to use the Sabbath Day to show our devotion to the Lord, & some of the blessings associated with keeping the Sabbath Day holy – like Leviticus 26 – and the flip sides of not referencing the Sabbath. Scuttlebutt here says that the push on talking more about the Sabbath came from the first Presidency & the Twelve, so I am hopeful that we might be treated to a few more topics besides the family, and how to have more effective councils. Our stake spent several years on the councils, hearing the same things from the same people, over & over. I know repetition is a good way to learn, but after a certain point, we are all human, & we tune out.
I have felt the pain of being a never-married, single sister. BUT, I have also experienced so much joy. I see a common attitude among singles in the church that asks “what’s in it for me?” I don’t know why I haven’t been blessed with my righteous desires, but I do know I have made covenants to serve, teach, and love. It’s not always easy, but I choose not to see a division in my ward of singles and married couples. I choose to be part my ward family. I choose to learn from their experiences and mistakes as they learn from mine. I choose to love the children and youth in my ward. This life (my single life) is not all about me.
I also appreciate Eric Ehlers’ questions and would ask, why can’t we approach marriage/family/children lessons from the perspective of relationships in general? It seems that the same principles apply in being a good family member, friend, neighbor, co-worker as any other, and it is a far richer discussion when all can be involved.
There is no need for any single member to deny that the religious needs of single members can be different in some respects from the religious needs of families. There is no need for any single member to apologize for hoping to have her singleness factored into gospel teachings in some ways, at some times. This life is not solely for families, either.
Katherine…so true!
I’m getting tired, and I apologize if that fatigue makes me sound grumpier than intended. I do appreciate the ongoing discussion.
Katherine A., you’re right that some principles (respect, say, and patience and generosity and sincerity among many others) apply to non-family relationships as well as they do to family relationships. But marriage and family relationships also have dimensions that must be acknowledged in a religious setting that are not true of relationships with friends and neighbors:
No one makes the same crucial and eternal temple covenants with friends as they do with a spouse.
No one has the obligation, and certainly not the right, to step into a crisis and give direction or take the same intimate action in the case of a ward member as a parent has in the case of a child.
No one has the same right and privilege to claim support (financial, emotional, whatever) from a neighbor as they do from a spouse or parent.
And on and on. Marital and parent/child relationships are special, and crucial, and essential, and eternal in ways that are rightly addressed in Church settings. We can’t NOT address those relationships. But while we’re doing that, we ought to also give some thought and assistance to those who do not have the obligations and blessings of those relationships and whose valid spiritual needs must be met in other ways.
So, 47 year old, never been married woman here. I really appreciate your thoughts, Ardis, and have some of my own to add, particularly on the topic of singles being less “invisible” in the church.
I believe that one of the big reasons that single people feel invisible is at we are, literally, kept out of sight as young singles. I was in singles wards until I was 29, and at the time I thought it made a lot of sense. Singles wards allow young adults to socialize, and (more importantly in my mind) give young adults chances to learn leadership in roles that would probably otherwise be filled by older, more experienced ward members.
However. Singles wards also keep the singles neatly corralled away from the main body of the church. This means that the married folk in a “segregated” area literally DO NOT SEE a lot of singles functioning, growing, serving, and learning. Then, when older singles come back into the “regular” wards, we are oddities, and much in the minority. This structure keeps non-singles from learning how to interact with singles as adults. Is it any wonder that we get treated like youth? The last time we were seen, we WERE youth. And don’t even get me started on the concept of “graduating” out of a singles ward.
So I would love to see singles wards be much more limited, stop at a younger age, and the church as a whole learn how to deal with each other as brothers and sisters, not singles and marrieds.
Responsibility for this lies on everyone. I have been in regular wards as a young single adult where I was the only single person who went to ward activities. When I asked the other singles why they didn’t come, I was told, “that’s for the married people.” No, that’s for the ward, of which we are a part. Sure, it’s easier to hang out with, and relate to, people with whom you have a lot in common. But again, let’s define ourselves as sisters and brothers instead of by marital status.
Another thing we can do as singles is to join the conversation. We don’t have to wait for the teacher to comment on how a principle applies to us; we can make the comments ourselves. If everyone is talking about how to strengthen the spousal relationship, I can make a comment on how a certain principle helps me strengthen relationships with other people in my life. It probably won’t change the direction of the conversation, but I will have been heard. Some days that’s easier than others, and some days it feels almost impossible.
I must speak to be heard.
Thank you for this. I think it should be published far and wide. I am so uncomfortable with the exclusive language used at church and in official talks, publications, etc., and I’m the target audience, married with 3 kids. I can’t imagine the feelings the language and overemphasis on marriage and family would cause in someone whose reality is different. talking with single friends and using my imagination I guess fills in the gaps a little. I wish we focused on the core message of the Gospel. Come unto Christ. Be a better person. Serve others. Anyway. Thanks for your post.
I wish that single members would have more opportunities to participate in church leadership councils. I was invited to attend my stake council as the stake single adult coordinator, and as I visited with bishoprics and Relief Society presidencies in my stake, I realized how little representation singles have in local church governance (less to none at regional and higher levels). The curriculum, doctrinal explanations, and church culture will not change without many individuals sharing their diverse experiences with being single, which the Church classifies as anyone without a living spouse.
It wasn’t until I went to church as a childless/infertile (married) woman that I began to experience the damage/hurt that comes from our rhetoric. In a young LV ward every RS lesson would take a gospel topic (prayer, faith, etc) and the teacher would say, “Since we’re all mothers I decided to have my lesson be ‘how we can teach our children _______.” You can only take that so long before you volunteer to substitute elsewhere. After a few years of self-centered-ness I realized I wasn’t the only one feeling marginalized (single, lgbt, etc.).
I don’t think I am saying families are less important when I say I want the contributions and lives of single/childless women to be valued just as much as married/mothers (and I don’t want to just be valued for how I mother others not my own).
I’ve found it makes a lot of people upset when I ask that we teach that the highest and holiest calling we’ve been given is discipleship; and that I want to be valued as a Woman of God (woman of valor – eshet chayil in hebrew). For my testimony, for my character, my for service, and for my discipleship.
It took personal revelation to be able to process that God values my contributions to building the kingdom of God even if my church doesn’t (value it in the same way).
As much as it hurts to be infertile, I can’t even begin to understand the struggle it is to be single or lgbt in the marriage rhetoric. There literally isn’t a place for so many of our members in our plan of salvation. (sigh) Godspeed, Ardis. I have many friends in your position. I’m not sure how we can train our members on the ground to minister individually. That would help balance the teaching of the ideal generally, but I don’t think it will trickle down until we hear something different from the top. I’m kind of hopeless about the whole thing.
What I have noticed quite often is that no one is speaking up to point out that there are differences. Since we are all fallible beings, sometimes people say things that may bite and sting. In my own Ward, I hear a lot of people feeling left out of the conversation, but I don’t hear any of them actually speaking up during a lesson or speaking to the teacher afterwards about how they are feeling. I think sometimes the oversight of the many accidentally tramples on the souls of the few. I find this so terribly sad. This happens on so many levels. People say things during lessons that are not doctrine, but presented as such and all I hear are crickets unless I jump in and say something. I think we need to be braver and to invite discussion to make others aware of the tender feelings around them. Most people are just trying their best and are truly unaware how the discussion/lesson may be striking someone. Kindness is needed, but so is bravery and courage to bring new ideas to the discussion. Speak up kindly and see what happens.
Amen (I agree)
I’m considerably more hopeful than you are, Kristine, and I hope this post shows that. There is no despair in my post or my outlook, and a clear and explicitly stated recognition of my worth in the sight of God.
-oOo-
Too often, the course of the Bloggernacle is something like this: Somebody states a problem; readers add their agreement and sympathy, sometimes overstating the problem described by the original poster; more and more commenters join in, each telling their own experiences and opinions, and often seemingly trying to top the comments that went before; finally, commenters agree that Church leaders don’t care, that the Church does more harm than good, that the only principled thing for a member to do is to oppose the Church in one way or another.
Keepa has a different pattern. Keepa is a place where we can acknowledge difficult personal experiences and difficult events or attitudes in our history, but at the same time acknowledging the good will of Church leaders and members, our support for the Church, and confidence that improvements will come.
I appreciate commenters supporting that attitude of the Keepa community. I insist on preserving Keepa as a place where faithful members can express their faith, whether explicit or implicit, knowing that they won’t be attacked or made to feel the scorn of those who think they know better. Please help maintain the Keepa community, and don’t expect to express the same hopelessness or disdain that is sometimes evident elsewhere.
This post identifies a weakness in rhetoric, but it is hopeful. I am confident that the additional guidance I need as a single can come from ward and general leaders without any heartburn on anyone’s part — it only takes awareness and good will to begin the process. I believe in the goodwill of my fellow Saints and especially of my Church leaders. And in the meantime, I’m not wringing my hands in despair — I’m actively thinking about my status, and seeking understanding. The five conclusions I list are entirely faithful and consistent with established doctrine — I’ve just had to arrive at those conclusions on my own, without the help that *could* be given.
Sorry for my rambling and lengthy comment. I’m too tired to work on brevity and elegance.
No need to apologize for being over long in your comment, Ardis. I can only wish that my “rambling” could ever be so elegant.
This /has/ been an interesting and inspiring discussion. Keepa truly is a unique place. Thanks.
There are many different reasons for becoming single after getting married. There are perhaps fewer reasons for not marrying.
Whatever the reasons are, the work of the Lord is done when we all keep the commandment to multiply and replenish the earth and see those children raised in righteousness. This should be everyone’s objective unless age or other physical limitations prevent that. We have to love everyone regardless of what phase of their life they are in.
If we cannot have children we should do all we can to help our community grow stronger.
I like to give those well meaning marrieds the benefit of the doubt here. I think they honestly don’t know what to do with us. On the one hand you have the newlyweds who think they know everything about both being single and now being married. And then on the other you have the long time marrieds who have completely forgotten how to relate. And I think they so desperately don’t want to hurt us but also have no idea what to say that they end up either stepping in it or ignoring us. And ignoring is easier. So I choose to educate rather than be hurt or ignored. I love that you told your home teachers to come back with a better lesson. I don’t see a problem with raising your hand when a lesson has veered off course and saying, “Hey, let’s talk about my situation for a sec.” I did this once while teaching a gospel doctrine class that had gotten very exclusive to the married club and everyone just kind of looked at their hands. But I wouldn’t change the subject and we got some good discussions going. There are tactful ways to do this but that’s not always necessary. My bluntness has been a blessing because I think the people in my ward and stake respect me and love me and for the most part know how to talk to me as a friend and fellow disciple rather than just some poor girl they wish they had someone to set up with. Singles have to speak up. We can’t expect people to change if they don’t know that they need to. Married people are going to talk about marriage because that’s what they know best. I’m really good at talking about being single.
Everybody has something that hurts them in church. The woman in a bad marriage, the teenager who doesn’t feel like he fits in, the childless couple. And it’s easy for us to pick out what hurts us the most because we’ve spent a lifetime protecting ourselves from that pain. We’re our own watchman on a tower. So of course we’re going to hear those talks about marriage and family more than others because they’re the ones that have the most potential for pain. Everyone is doing their best according to their own understanding, and that includes those who teach us and sometimes hijack the meeting (although people who have been to the Holy Land or missions to Nauvoo or who regularly find 1000 names every time they do family history should be banned from the pulpit). I don’t think that people mean to hurt us. In fact, I think that most people would have their hearts broken if they knew that they had. I’m just grateful that those things unintentionally happen in a place with intentional relief.
A couple of thoughts:
1.) My favorite type of ward is blended, the student ward I attended had both single and married folks, and I went to a really cool ward while single that was mixed with a regular family ward. We had callings in the ward alongside everyone else, while having our own activities and Sunday School. The vibe was truly awesome in that ward. Frankly, most of the singles wards I attended before that had a strange feeling to them, like things were out of balance and there was lots of stress and pressure just under the surface. I feel like the blended ward model corrects a lot of that bad chi. It may have also helped that this was outside of the mountain west — sorry, but going to church in Utah/Idaho/Arizona is generally weird. Hopefully it won’t always be that way.
2.) The older I get, the more I’m convinced that teaching in the church is far more about facilitating discussion than delivering some sort of rote message. My goal now when I teach is to do as little talking as possible, and to leave my agenda at the door. The Lord knows His sheep, and almost every time I “prepare” a lesson I feel like the spirit isn’t quite the same as having a real discussion because I’m essentially trying to edge out the influence of the spirit. I do think preparation is important, and the discussion should IMO be somewhat guided (and moderated, if necessary), but preparation is more about being ready with an appropriate scripture or thought or coming up with a decent list of thought questions than delivering whatever I may feel is the “right” message. Because that feeling, at least in me, is more often related to my pride than anything the Lord might actually want someone (and that person often is not me) to say during a lesson. Thus I feel my role is to a.) foster a spiritual environment, b.) keep the discussion at least loosely related to the main theme of the lesson, and c.) listen to what other participants say and let that inspire our journey through the topic at hand.
Everything about this post. Yes. Yes. Yes.
I’m going to share your thoughts and insights everywhere I can.
In my adult life, I have been married to a non-member (and experienced much of what ZD Eve pointed so eloquently pointed out) and I have been a divorced, single mother raising children alone. Only recently, I have experienced a more traditionally typical LDS family structure.
This is still a perspective I am desperately trying to get across in my ward and church activity. I sit and cringe at the generalizations of the rich tapestry of human experience, and I ache for the saints who are harmed (or ignored) by their faithful church devotion. Like Eve, my children would come home crying, or leave Primary feeling as if our family was broken, less than and somehow without worth. I am keenly, keenly aware of how our myopic focus on The Ideal Family, while possibly well-intentioned, too often ends up being a cudgel for tender flesh of many ages.
We are a covenant people, and we pledge to hold each other up, to become Zion. When we stand before our coreligionists in our faith communities, we are responsible in what we teach to keep those hearts- present and not- in mind. We must choose our words carefully, be mindful of one another, and not take hackneyed or platitudinous ways out.
Being told, ad infinitum, that “it will all work out” (after you are dead) denies the gospel message of *this life* here and now, and how vital and rich we should strive to make it, regardless of our familial status. I don’t think people who repeat that platitude understand how cruel and dismissive it truly is.
Thank you for writing this piece, Ardis. I will continue to speak up in my own spheres of influence, and I’ll be watching for and calling out for Icarus.
I’m currently married, and my formerly non-member 2nd husband recently joined the church, so I’m not even in a part-member family any more. But I spent many years as a divorced mother and then several more in a part-member family. I can relate to so much that you say here.
So many times over the years that I was single, I was assigned to speak on “strengthening the family” or asked to teach a RS lesson on marriage that it almost seemed like a joke to me. I would prepare my talk or lesson with so many tears, and consider calling the Bishop and asking “what are you thinking to ask ME to talk about this???” But following the spirit, and realizing that the Bishop did know my situation, I came to understand that maybe my ward members needed to hear from someone who had had the “ideal” situation, but didn’t any more. In every case, I had people I barely knew (whose situations I didn’t know) approach me and thank me and share a little bit of their story with me. What a blessing that was to know that even people who outwardly seem to have it all together had similar struggles to my own.
I’m not really going anywhere with this. I just wanted to let you know that your post resonated with me and now that I’m no longer on one of those “lists” that gets discussed in ward council every month, I hope I can use my RS lessons and occasional speaking assignments to include everyone.
I’d like to respond to Eric J Ehlers’ question. The short answer is “ask them”. It’s about dialogue. Teaching people in terms of principles is a natural part of the process. In the case of adults, however, we all pretty much know the facts of doctrine. The real learning is going to come when we structure our lessons as opportunities where people share from their own insights and experiences. How do you help people who are feeling left out? Make them a part of the conversation and listen to them. See their difference as a gift to the class, which it is. Reorient the focus from trying to teach to them, but discover what your community can learn from them.
I opted to stay away from church activity for eight months shortly following a divorce because of this feeling of “falling short.” It seems singles are often looked at with pity of confusion, divorcees are looked at with suspicion (as a male, it was an assumption that I must have either been disloyal or abusive, neither of which are true). We don’t make it easy for those who truly desire to be among the Saints to feel embraced when they don’t fit the ideal type. Single adult groups don’t seem to fix this either, as we seem to treat it as a dating scene among the elderly, widowed, or divorced. Many other religious groups seem to have thriving Bible studies or book clubs within their congregations for different demographics. Of course, they also don’t pound the pulpit of nuclear family as the highest achievement in mortal and eternal life as we do.
I haven’t commented yet because I wanted to listen, first. Thank you, Ardis.
I don’t have a great deal to say. I’m not only a failure at getting married (now,) I colossally failed my marriage. Almost every lesson at church breaks my heart.
Faith? I had that, but it got me nowhere. Repentance? I’ve tried, but I still don’t know what I did wrong. Baptism? My daughter’s struggles over becoming baptized because of the things her father teaches her are a constant stress. Holy Ghost? I don’t even know if I can hear Him any more. Let alone the ones actually ABOUT marriage and family.
But what I have begun to do over the past several years is to share that heartbreak. Not to vent or complain, but to be vulnerable. When I am vulnerable, it gives other people permission to be vulnerable, too. Either publicly in class, or privately weeks later. When people become vulnerable, they can be helped, and when they are helped by us, we become Zion.
I may never marry. I don’t think I can, at this point. But if it is my lot to be a ministering angel, I am content. Because it means I can serve and lift others to exaltation and eternal increase. Whether or not that is my eternity, it is certainly my mortality. I’m not good at it, but it is something I can do to be like my Savior.
So yes, my heart breaks weekly (if not daily.) I struggle to attend the temple because sometimes THAT is more than I can handle. But though I can’t stop my heart breaking, I can let other people see it, know that I am a safe place to fall, and do my best to bind up THEIR broken hearts. That makes it all worth it.
I agree with just about everything that has been said in this post and my heart aches for those who have had had these experiences. I don’t think most people are trying to be offensive. But may I say that when I was a mother of small children living in the Bay Area with a husband that worked 14-16 hours and had a long commute, living “the dream” wasn’t exactly blissful. In a world that doesn’t seem to value or celebrate the homemaker, deciding to be a stay at home mom wasn’t easy. I felt so bone tired and isolated! I can tell you a lot of young mothers envy single women who seem to be doing much more interesting things. And while family can bring you the highest joys, it can also bring you the great pain and sorrow. Living away from family support the ward becomes your family and about the only place that will give you any confirmation that you are doing anything valuable. In the end I think most of us will spend time in “singledom”. Look at our last two Prophets and Elder Scott. You could say that they are single fathers. I would like to suggest two thoughts 1) The grass is always greener where you water it and 2) I liked the proverb Sis Burton used in her last conference talk ” youThee lift me and I’ll lift thee, and we’ll ascend together.” We are all part of a larger family, we are all struggling and we are likely to blunder along and offend at times. Hopefully thread like this will help us all to be sensitive to issues but not easily offended. We all need each other.
I wonder if there are regional differences in this. I don’t know if i’m missing important observations because i’ve been married since my mid-20s and grew up in a prototypical nuclear family, but i’ve lived in several states (my international church experience was as a full-time missionary, so i don’t really trust my observations there), and the level of rhetorical inclusion/lack of exclusion (which i think are two quite different things) of unmarried members of the church that i’ve observed has been very different in different places. And i don’t think it was just that there was a particularly good or bad gospel doctrine teacher or bishop or whatever in any given ward i was living in, because when i go to church and visit nearby friends i generally find that it’s a regional pattern, not a ward-by ward or even stake-by-stake one.
Just throwing that out there perhaps mainly as a caution about generalizing one’s own experiences to the church as a whole.
I’m pretty sure Ardis is cautious about generalizing her experience to the church as a whole. There have been many (myself included) who have tried to write about this problem, and they’ve lived from coast to coast and border to border. Regional variation in no way accounts for the imbalance in manuals, teaching materials, monthly themes, and General Conference talks.
I appreciate your response, Ardis. I know this place is different than everywhere else. I guess I’m hopeless that things will be my ideal, but I’m not hopeless that things won’t get better. I always think we have potential for better.
I spoke on Mother’s Day about valuing Women of God; and I got a lot of backlash online about my idea but not in person in my ward. To me it’s insightful that in general as saints in Rexburg we’re a bit less than we think of ourselves but quite a bit more than people think of us (re being open and inclusive).
I’d estimate that upwards of 90, maybe 95%, of this post’s readers, both here and on the numerous Facebook discussions it sparked, completely missed my point; either my communication skills are worse than I imagined, or people are primed to see what they expect to see, and not a new idea. Still, the discussions about inclusion are valuable and clearly meet the needs of many.
The post, though, is not at all about social inclusion. Not. At. All. It’s about meeting the needs of singles, needs that are specific to singleness, factors that married people have no necessity to concern themselves with. That is, just as I have no practical use for yet another talk or lesson on “cleaving unto my spouse and none other,” a perfectly valid topic for married members, there are questions of vital concern to Latter-day Saint single members that are of no practical value to married members. This post was an attempt to express THAT need — not social inclusion, but inclusion of doctrine and practical matters that address matters specific to being single.
I’ll try again sometime to communicate that intent more clearly. In the meantime, the useful discussion of social inclusion is welcome.
hmmm – so are you saying recentering messages on discipleship (a general inclusive umbrella) and then in discussion applying it in married and single and childless perspectives…. Is not including doctrinal and practical needs of singles? That was my suggestion and I don’t see it as social inclusion. It is very likely the misunderstanding is all my fault.
THANK YOU!!!! THANNNNNK YOUUUUU!!!!!!
I am a single gay/SSA man in the Church, and I have found myself growing embittered by the constant pressure to marry. My bitterness is not something I blame the Church for necessarily, and in fact the more time has gone on the more I’ve realized, just as you have, that it’s okay that I’m not the Church’s priority and that I need to let go of my expectations of fulfillment from the CHurch. My testimony of the Gospel and of the Church are not based on what they do for me.
However, I find that I have begun looking outside the Church to get much of my affiliation and growth needs met. I’m fortunate to have an excellent singles ward with a great bishop (he can get pushy but he’s a good man who loves us) and my experience with the singles ward itself has been wonderful. In fact, we had a seventy come visit a few weeks ago and he said this in his address verbatim: “The Brethren want to express their concern, not so much that you’re getting married, but that you know just how good you are.” I almost broke down right there. It was such a beautiful thing that he did.
However, I find that in general, the climate of the single’s ward, and indeed the Church in general at least in terms of its culture, is not conducive to my emotional or mental health. The only reasons I go to Church are to take the Sacrament and use the tough environment to learn how to have patience and faith, and take the occasional but consistent insights that have helped me in my discipleship. The power of the Atonement has manifested itself through my church involvement and I need that more than anything, but honestly, my own best bet for getting and giving consistent companionship and support has been through my involvement in support groups for LDS SSA/gays as well as involvement in nonreligious causes like People Can Change and The Mankind Project.
THe more I’ve taken individual command and surrendered my life path to God and away from churchy cultural mores and pressures, the more joy I’ve found.
Kristine A., discipleship is of course something that all members of the Church can (or should) embrace. Discipleship is as valid and necessary for me as it is for you, and an emphasis on that would almost certainly unite us, or move us more in the direction of unity. Amen.
But as true as that is, it isn’t quite what I’m reaching for. Even while we need to increase our individual and collective discipleship, discipleship isn’t quite a one-size-fits-all proposition. As a married woman (and, I think, a mother?), you have legitimate gospel-mandated obligations to your husband and children; no one, not even in the guise of a fellow disciple, has more of a claim on your love and attention than your family does. You have made covenants with your husband that you have not made with me. You have the scriptural duty to teach your children “to understand the doctrine of repentance, faith in Christ the Son of the living God, and of baptism and the gift of the Holy Ghost by the laying on of the hands,” a duty that you don’t bear in the same way towards other disciples’ children. And so on.
It is entirely appropriate for the Church to teach you of those duties, to stress their importance, to provide you with tools to accomplish them, and all other related matters. And while those teachings and helps have no practical value to me, I fully support the Church providing them to you, and even doing that while I sit in the same room and hear the same counsel.
But just as married people have religious obligations and needs that are pertinent to them and not to me, single people also have religious needs and perhaps obligations that are particular to us and that don’t necessarily apply to you. One of those needs is to have a clearer understanding of the relationship of an unmarried person to the gospel — to the temple covenants and promises, for instance. That may be a matter of general curiosity to you, but it is of vital importance to us.
It is those issues that are relevant to singleness and not particularly relevant to marriage that I wish we could sometimes address. Those issues go well beyond general matters of discipleship common to all believers, at least for one who accepts the uniquely Latter-day Saint understanding of the purpose of mortality and expectations for eternity. Forgive me, please, if I misunderstand what you have said in earlier comments, but I’m not entirely sure whether you do accept unique LDS teachings that are more expansive than generic Christianity. If you have rejected those uniquely Mormon views as part of what you have called your “faith transition,” then I’m not sure it’s possible for you to completely understand what I’m trying to express.
I wholeheartedly agree that focusing on the principles and what is pertinent to us as individuals that are part of a bigger picture (insert life circumstances here) is beneficial to all. However, speaking as if the brethren and the gospel as a whole need a change is not what I think is needed (this article borders back and forth to me). The CHURCH does not teach these things. It is misguided, well intentioned PEOPLE that teach this. Teaching is going to involve individual interpretation no matter how to try to avoid it. The only thing that can really be done is for us to as individuals realize that others are on a journey of discovering as well and it is always going to be different than ours. It is up to us to set the example by including, acting, interpreting, preparing, asking questions and teaching in a way that we know to be most beneficial. The brethren are aware of our struggles and more importantly the lord is aware. If we come prepared and willing we will receive the insights the Lord is trying to give us and hopefully share those with others as appropriate so they to may find some applicable knowledge. I like that the article made me think but my conclusion is that it is not the churches responsibility to Tailor the information it is our responsibility to seek insight from the lord and it can be just as difficult to do that when you are married with children as it is when you are single. We can all feel like we are drowning and no one notices if we aren’t actively seeking the lord on our lives. (Sorry that was so long I guess it really made me think)
Ardis, Thank you for taking the time to put your thoughts into words. I have read them and pondered them, and thought about you and other dear friends and family members who are in similar life situations.
You always give me much to think about, and I appreciate your efforts to share in a way that builds up faith.
Have a great day.
This topic is all the most interesting given the recent Time article on Mormon dating. http://time.com/dateonomics/
Okay, Red89, I’ll take your comment as being intended to be helpful and uplifting … but to be consistent, you should, then, not expect the Church to tailor its message to assist families and couples, or men. I mean, by your thinking, we could offer all the Church’s messages in forms especially suited to children preparing for baptism, and it would be up to you adult priesthood holders to seek insight from the Lord on how to adapt those messages to meet the needs of heads of families, priesthood quorums, and the elderly.
Keep thinking. As I keep trying to make plain, my plea is not to have any Church message changed to fit me, but to have my needs included among the other messages taught by the Church. There’s a great gulf between what I’m saying and what you’re hearing.
But thank you for a thoughtful comment.
Ardis: I was single in the church until I was 34, so I have some measure of understanding. I can’t, however, completely empathize. So I am just going to give you the benefit of the doubt–that your perceptions are valid, that your thoughts are well developed, and that you have an absolutely important perspective to share with others. I’m not going to tell you that you are misguided. I am not going to read this and formulate counter-arguments. I’m not going to unearth your assumptions and fling them at you with criticism. You are very generous to give voice to your lived experience. I’m going to read this several times to let it (better) sink in. And I will try to come back again after some times passes and read it again. All my best to you in all your worthwhile endeavors.
I just got the Sept. Ensign in the mail. Family. Family. Family. And not everyone is family. Only those who defend “traditional marriage” count.
As a long-married grandmother, I realize that the church I found so helpful as we raised our kids might not have been so helpful to anyone who didn’t fit the neat little box. And I was ignorant of the pain that those who didn’t fit were feeling. The single mom. The divorced man. The gay brother. The widow. Any “other” you want to name. All defined as something less than except for the token comment at the beginning or end of a lesson, if you were lucky, about how it will all be worked out in the eternities. (And even those comments never included anyone who wasn’t heterosexual.) I’m sorry for my own insensitivity. I’m sorry I didn’t speak up sooner. I may have to speak up with my feet- is leaving the church what it takes to be heard?
Ardis, I’ve found in my scientific work that one of the most important parts of getting good answers is formulating good questions, which is often much harder than it looks. I sympathize with your effort to phrase the questions well.
So let me ask some questions about your question to be sure I understand it. Are you asking for lessons that teach what God expects of you or what God wants for you or what God offers you as a single member? I do feel like I’m still not sure what the question is we’re struggling to answer here.
Whether I’ll have any kind of answer after I’m clear what the question is is an entirely different answer.
No, Lynn. If I thought my words, reasonably interpreted, encouraged anyone to leave the Church, or to develop unjustified anger, I would close down Keepa in a heartbeat.
My post condemns no one and nothing. It does not ask the Church to change its message or its presentation of that message. I have no resentment whatsoever that yet another issue of the Ensign is devoted to the family. That’s fine with me. It’s appropriate and good and right. It’s largely irrelevant to me, but I trust valuable to some others.
What I hope for is not a lessening of the support for or teaching about the nuclear family. I’m looking for AN ADDITION to that message, one that is relevant to the conduct of singles’ lives, one that helps me find a purpose and hope for the future. (And while I’m focusing on MY needs — it’s my blog, after all — I can hope the same for all Latter-day Saints, whatever their situation.)
I acknowledge that much of the work for that necessarily falls on my own shoulders — the five numbered items in the post are the results, so far, of my work to find my place and purpose, demonstrating my acceptance of that personal responsibility. I hope for help from sensitive Church leaders, too, because nobody should have to find hope and meaning and doctrinal understanding wholly on her own.
Again, I have not called for change in anything. I have tried — with mixed success — to describe for readers what I need by contrasting it with what they have when so much of Church rhetoric, consciously and unconsciously, is tailored to the needs of their nuclear families.
This has been a weird experience. I did not expect the response this has drawn. There has been much relevant and valuable comment, and unfortunately a great deal of misunderstanding and misdirected anger as well. I’m very unhappy about that.
And the weird thing is, while not all of us are or have been married, all of us are or have been single. So why is this such a difficult thing for us as a people to talk about?
Thanks for your thoughts. As a bishop, I worry that we don’t do enough to make the single members feel they are part of the congregation and their input is just as important as the married members of the ward.
Admittedly, I know about as much about the specific needs of single people as my dad knows about finding a job in the 21st century. That is, I have enough experience to have developed some empathy, but I haven’t had to really wrestle with it long-term, and am in no way qualified to give advice that meets those needs. It seems to me, though, as much as I want to do something — to contribute, to make things better — that many of the specific needs of single people are difficult for us ordinary members of the Church to do anything about until the leaders of the Church develop better answers.
I mean, when it comes to general inclusion of single people in doctrinal and practical matters, there’s a lot that us ordinary members of the church can do to make sure that talks and lessons include the needs of single people in meaningful ways beyond just saying “this applies to single people too.” Teachings that strengthen families are important, but we don’t need to have full days of nothing but that — advice on family prayer can be included in talks about prayer, along with other teachings that are of significance whether you live with your family or not. Even calls to repentance for marital infidelity can be couched in teachings of more general applicability. (See, for example, Jacob 2.) We don’t need to leave any adult sitting in the pews thinking “Okay, this whole meeting just isn’t applicable to me at all.” (Even when Jacob thinks he’s burdened by being constrained to admonish a limited subset of his audience, I don’t think anyone is really excluded, since he starts with pride, and greed — sins that no one is really immune from.) That sort of rhetorical inclusion is something I know how to work on, as a member of the church.
When it comes to the particular, specific needs of single people, though, I’m at a loss to know what to do. Part of that, of course, is my own lack of experience, but I think a large part is that the theology just hasn’t been developed — there just isn’t a well-defined place in eternity for the never-married person, in LDS theology. There are plenty of folk-theological attempts to fit single people into the cosmology, but they all seem a bit insulting, not to mention doctrinally risky. What we need is revelation — and I don’t know how to do anything about that. I would love for every single person to be able to receive the temple endowment without feeling that realization of the promised blessings depends on being able to marry a faithful, LDS, opposite-sex spouse, but
I don’t know how to do anything about that. I can wrestle with the interpretation, and I can express my faith that though we may see through a glass darkly, God’s grace is for all of us, but in the end my conclusions are my own hope, not the doctrine of the Church. There are theological details that it would be really good to have.
When it comes to social inclusion, it honestly never occurred to me. (I’m introverted enough, and it seems to me like wards have plenty of social activities for them what want’s ’em, single or not). Upon further reflection, though, I’m beginning to think social inclusion, done right, is the best thing we *can* do, to address specific needs. I don’t mean just social events, though — I mean that I’m fairly sure that specific problems will not be consistently addressed if single people remain relegated to the periphery of the body of Christ. The people giving talks and lessons (and, for that matter, planning the curriculum) need to be the people who really understand those specific needs. When the ward council decides on sacrament meeting topics, someone needs to be there to say “Okay, how will we ask the speakers to do this in a way that doesn’t exclude the single members of the ward.” The social inclusion of single people needs to be so complete that no one can think about planning anything, from a ward social to a temple, without considering the single members of the church.
Kent, I appreciate your willingness to offer help and to clarify my questions. I don’t expect you or anyone else to solve any problems with a comment or two, though, and it’s probably best not to try to do that. They aren’t the kind of questions that can be solved merely by a recitation of data.
But because I believe you’re sincere, I’ll try to make my point more clear:
Marriage and family are extremely important for religious reasons, in the LDS view of the purpose of life and the eternal happiness of the children of God. Because of that importance, the Church emphasizes family in its talks and teachings and programs. That emphasis is, or should be, relevant and useful to a very large part of Church membership — either because they have marriages and families, or because they expect to marry and have families in the future.
Some of us, though, have no expectation of marriage and families in this life. I’m open to it, but realistically, nobody expects me, at my age and with my track record, to have that blessing in mortality. So much of Church rhetoric on the family is only theoretically important to me, and not relevant in my mortal experience or expectation.
But I still have to live out my life. My mortality should not be merely marking time, but should provide me with knowledge and experiences to understand my purpose and to progress toward God – for the same reason, if not in precisely the same manner, that couples and families have purpose and make progress.
With the heavy emphasis on the family, though, I’m left pretty much on my own to figure out that purpose and to make progress alone. I’m quite willing to work on that purpose and progress myself, but I also think the Church should have some interest in helping me, to some extent, just as it helps couples and families. That’s the point of this post: To point out that need, to help married readers understand that people like me aren’t getting the help we need when the constant assumption is that lessons and sermons on the family are equally relevant to all, and are the be-all and end-all of Church rhetoric.
You can’t give me answers, and in fact I do not want specific answers, from you or anyone else. You don’t know me well enough, you don’t have responsibility for me. Any personal advice, no matter how kindly meant, would be inappropriate and presumptuous, simply because it isn’t your place to counsel me.
But if you have general commentary, suitable to many and not targeting me, that’s fine.
Because, David B., most of you were single adults for relatively short periods of time. You think that gives you sufficient insight into lifelong singleness to discuss it intelligently, but it doesn’t. The needs and outlooks of single Latter-day Saints in their 40s and 50s and beyond are very, very different from the needs and outlooks of single Latter-day Saints in their 20s and 30s. I know. I’ve been both. You haven’t.
(That is, I assume this includes you, David, because I assume you’re married. If not, my apologies; imagine this comment were worded appropriately.)
You get it, Mike R., from top to bottom. Thank you.
Thank you, Bishop Brent. It’s almost certain that the singles in your ward need something they aren’t getting, even if they haven’t thought enough yet to put their finger on just what that is. Remember that what singles need isn’t only input into the affairs of the ward; it’s also receiving the doctrinal and other support they need *as singles*. Don’t gear everything from social events to sacrament meeting themes to couples and families. Make sure that *individuals* are receiving relevant counsel and assistance.
Thank you Ardis. Thank you…
Thank you, Ardis. My friend shared your post on FB and you have perfectly expressed how I feel. I’m with you. We don’t need less talk about families, but we do need more talk about individuals and how our eternal salvation, contrary to popular, Mormon culture belief, is not based on our marital status, but rather on our personal righteousness and whether or not we allow the Atonement to work in our lives. I’m so sick of hearing “I’m so grateful that my family will be together forever.” Wow, really? So, you know you’re going to be exalted, huh? Because last I checked, personal righteousness was a pre-requisite to exaltation, which I understood is a pre-requisite to an eternal family. My understanding of our doctrine as related to eternal families is that we need to qualify for the highest degree of the celestial kingdom to be together as a family and I don’t care how young you were when you got married or how many children you have, if you don’t qualify for eternal life with God through the Atonement, I’ll be interested to see what happens with that family you’re so darn sure is “forever.” Sigh…sorry, a little over hearing that phrase. Anyway, this was a beautifully written, much needed post and I hope that, because of it, in some small way, a few people will start thinking outside the box and just see everyone – married or single – as a child of God trying their best to get through this crazy experience we call life.
There is a problem with the social integration, too. When I go to ward activities, the families are all sitting together. I know there are several families that would welcome me if I asked to join them, but there is no natural place for me to sit. It is like I am back in the Junior High lunchroom, only EVERY table is the “cool kids” table, and I can’t sit there unless I am invited. I know there is no malice there–it is just that I am an afterthought at best.
Re Jen’s #60: most singles are not asking “what’s in it for me?” in selfishness. We’re asking because we’re expected to serve, serve, serve so much and never–at least I have never–felt given back to in anywhere near the same measure. It leaves one’s cup, which should be overflowing, completely dry. At least, that’s been my experience. Don’t feel loved enough? Go serve someone! Depressed with actual diagnosed depression? Go serve someone! Exhausted and sick, physically, due to chronic illness? Go serve someone, because that’ll somehow miraculously give you back the energy you already didn’t have in the first place.
I love serving. But sometimes it *isn’t* filling. Sometimes it’s draining. And sometimes asking, “what’s in it for me?” is a *spiritual* question borne out of severe anguish.
Sort of on topic but not really, I’ve often hoped that the children who die before the age of accountability are being saved in the eternity for faithful saints who either haven’t been married or who had their marriage terminated through no fault of their own.
They have to marry someone right? And it seems as though if they were too good for life on this earth they would be pretty great spouses in the hereafter.
Totally crazy? Feel free to delete my comment.
I think comment #108 just underlines part of the problem: we don’t have enough information about the eternal future of those who aren’t married for eternity during their lifetime. Plenty of stuff is taught (for want of a better word) about the everlasting unity of nuclear families, although the scriptural basis for much of this is lacking. Bottom line is we just don’t know and often speculation (not especially yours, Sariasis) just adds to the distress some feel when the “ideal family” is praised to the high heavens.
Sariasis (#108), I’ve thought the same thing. It kind of makes sense, right? But I’ve also heard many people say, “I believe that in the next life . . . . ” and come up with ideas that severely tested my vow of non-violence at church. (Really? You think God would do THAT?) I don’t know much about the Celestial Kingdom. But I do know that Mortality Stinks. It’s tough for everyone. If I see someone who seems to be leading a charmed life with no problems–I recognize that I just don’t know them well enough. That’s why it is so interesting to read people’s honest feelings about the way family and marriage is addressed in the LDS church. I don’t think very many people really want to go around stomping on other people’s feelings, but we still manage to do it.
Also, it’s probably just me, but a ‘nuclear family’ always sounds like something that’s about to blow up.
#101: Actually, no, i don’t think i have good insights into what the needs of single members are because i was once single myself—in fact, i know i don’t. I was just wondering why singleness is such a difficult (wrong word, but it’s the closest i can come up with) subject for us all to talk about, considering that it’s something universally experienced. The explanation you gave, though (that needs change with age*), though, works—thanks.
* On thinking about this, i’d add circumstance to age. I suspect that the needs of, say, a 60-year-old who’s never been married are different than the needs of a 60-year-old widow(er).
I appreciate you taking the time to address a difficult topic.
I have often been pained and hurt by local talks, lessons and testimonies.
I agree that it is up to us to make sure our own spiritual needs are met.
However as a single person, I have always felt loved and appreciated, in General Conference talks. The emphasis on meeting the needs of single adults in the church are felt strongly by the first presidency and quorum of the 12. It just takes time for that message to ‘filter down’ through area, stake and unit levels.
I have found that the singles program is very much what you make it. I have found that when i get involved and organise or promote activitiesi then will feel included, useful and loved.
I find it helpful just to remind and jog the memories of local leaders of the needs of myself and the other SA’s.
I have found it helpful when giving a lesson is to ask the audience to discuss how we can apply the lesson to our lives today as a married, single, widowed, divorced, young, older, lonely, tired, struggling, etc person. How can we apply this to our role as a ward family member? How can we use this gospel message to promote change within ourselves today? We usually get a good and helpful discussion that is sensitive and inspiring. I haven’t found a lesson or a talk where these questions didn’t fit. I usually find the older adults (often widowed, divorced, or single) will share a poignant experience that brings the spirit into the room. I’m not sure but i think we have to create a safe environment and then if still in doubt throw out a Sister Okazaki quote.
#108 Sariasis: please don’t ever say that to your single friend’s face. Those are exactly the kind of comments people like me get All. The. Time. It’s a microaggression and it’s insensitive, even if coming from a good place. It still basically says, “don’t worry! You’ll get married (therefore have value) after you die!”
There’s also that little matter of roughly equal numbers of little girls who die as well as little boys …
But Stacy is right: more than anything else, the barely disguised “reassurance” that “you’d be better off dead” is a hard one for many singles to endure, time after time after time after time. After time.
@115 I suspect it’s even worse for single men, who are often excluded even from the less-than-satisfying reassurance that they’ll get a companion somewhere in the eternities. After all, they can get married any time they really put their mind to it, right? [/sarc]
Which is not to say it isn’t bad enough for single women. But I think there are reasons both for high inactivity or partial activity among single members, and even higher inactivity among single men.
I suspect you’re right, Kent, and for exactly the reason you say: for every single woman who is ever pitied, there must be a single man who is blamed. A woman suggested today that it may not be as hard for men as women because men can still have a role in the priesthood. But I suspect we could make a case that the infantalising is worse for men because it denies men the very leadership callings that do go with the priesthood in the case of married men.
Maybe it boils down to individual temperament and circumstances rather than men vs. women … except there’s that thing again, that you pointed out about greater make inactivity. (Am I going in circles yet?)
I resonate with all of the well-spoken points you make above. I too have been frustrated at the lack of more general content at church that applies to me. However, I have learned to count it a blessing that I really have been forced to go to the Ultimate Source for counsel and guidance in my very different single life. I think I have gained more wisdom and understanding than I ever could have gained from Sunday teachings. However, why is it that I am still required to attend Relief Society when the lessons are geared to women with children, and they have no bearing on my life? Honestly, whether I should or not, I do leave the meeting when I see it heading that direction. I can get more out of reading my scriptures and counseling with the Lord during that hour vs. staying the hour, leaving frustrated and thus losing the Spirit.
Dede, I haven’t been to Relief Society in three years — it doesn’t address any of my needs, and provides no opportunity for me to meet anyone else’s needs; as it is conducted, it is a consistently alienating, isolating, frustrating, discouraging, pointless, worse-than-time-wasting experience. My bishop is aware of that, and it has no bearing in my temple recommend interviews.
Regular readers of this blog may well be surprised to read this. It isn’t anything I hide, just something I seldom mention because there seems little point in mentioning it. Just know, though, that you are not required to attend in order to meet anybody’s measure of your faithfulness, if attending does more harm than good in your personal circumstances.
This is not an invitation for anyone to scold or express sorrow, or to argue with Dede or me over our response to Relief Society.
I appreciate your honesty, Ardis. I’ve had some significant challenges to overcome at work, being in situations that as a professional I never thought I’d find myself in, really in over my head, which has driven me to my knees so frequently and to the temple. I didn’t want to jeopardize being able to go to the temple, yet have felt that attending RS was really torture for my soul, at a time when I needed pure doctrine and peace! (Why do doctrinal lessons turn into discussions about teaching children or going on dates with our spouses, when we are struggling to understand and apply the principles as adults? I think I answered my own question.) Fortunately, I did get called into Primary, which I love.
My ward meets my needs through receiving the Sacrament, and I am able to contribute well where I feel comfortable, as well as having home teachers that I really appreciate. These are the basics, and I feel good about this. Yet, I don’t feel a part of the ward community, despite really trying to get involved and help….my cup just got emptied as my efforts to build relationships were not reciprocated… But I count it a huge blessing to build my life outside of my ward. I have been blessed to have met so many great people and friends that I wouldn’t otherwise have met, and to also serve in the community.
Sometimes all it takes is having a friend to sit by in church. That would bring so many singles back. One of my friends is a widow and sitting together really helped even though there is 30 years between us. She began to come regularly, and I felt less like I wanted to flee the scene!
These are real feelings that single people have in a family-centered community. Feelings are not wrong or right, and are not to be denigrated. I feel that I’ve done my best to create positive solutions in working through my feelings, which have benefited me spiritually as well as my community. I’ve felt that the Lord needs me to be different, and I shouldn’t feel bad about being on the fringes because I have served well.
Due to a scheduling change, our ward had the Benson lesson on Fathers and Mothers (#15) today, and I thought of this conversation. Not that I have any more answers …
Ardis, I have been doing less blog reading of late, and just got to this today. As usual, you articulate difficult concepts with clarity. I always think I am sensitive to differences and circumstances, but this reminds me that despite all my sympathy and empathy, I really have only superficial understanding of other’s situations. For every time I find myself trying to be cognizant of others who are in a different way, there are probably a dozen times where I have spoken or acted thoughtlessly. I can only say thank you, and amen, for sharing your thoughts on this.
I can imagine making a good life long term as a single person, if that is in the cards for me, as much as I want to be married and a parent. But there’s that pesky patriarchal blessing, which says if I fail to marry and have children in this life, it was because I wasn’t righteous enough. I have trouble imagining how to live a spiritually confident life once my childbearing years are well and truly over, with these lines from this blessing echoing in the back of my brain until the day I die. Of course I wasn’t righteous enough. What is righteous enough? I was a faithful tithe payer and church attender, and did my visiting teaching almost every month in spite of being very introverted. But sometimes I whined and sometimes I stayed home from church activities where I knew there would be potential mates and often didn’t have the guts to march up to strange men and say hello even when I did go to those church activities. I fear that I will spend my later years endlessly dissecting my 20s and 30s to figure out what exactly my spiritual failing was. I fear I will end up mentally ill over it. And I wonder which others around me are silently suffering self-doubt for this same reason, and I feel that maybe we not only need more grace talk in our meetings, but more grace applied specifically to failures to realize our supposedly unique and tailored “missions” in earthly life–an idea that is very strong in Mormonism. The rhetoric is that only we can fulfil those missions, so if we fail to do so, the universe is permanently damaged by that failure, and how can permanent damage ever be fully forgiven? It’s an idea that inspires action for sure, which is useful in a church powered entirely by volunteers, but that I increasingly feel is incorrect. There may be things I’m better at than other and that I can use to bless others in particularly powerful ways, but grace can cover *anything.* Even if my lack of husband is evidence of my lesser righteousness (IF), perhaps we can stop pretending that this failure is a demerit that will follow me through the eternities, much as men in the church who don’t serve missions or leave early are often made to feel that nothing they do later in life can make up for failing to do their Really Important Mission.
Or maybe I’m wrong about grace. Maybe I’ve already messed up so much in this life with my poor church activity attendance that even grace can’t drag me out of the “ministering angel” reject heap of eternity.
Our ward’s fifth-Sunday lesson was on Sabbath observance in the home. Yes, a good bit of it dealt with handling children and such, but the bishop (who was the teacher for the whole hour) put forth some clear effort to keep that from being the focus, and explicitly included some mention of what those without children and/or spouses could do in terms of Sabbath observance, including some discussion of the fact that some of those things are the same as and some of those things are different from people with other family situations, and a direct statement that that’s not only okay, it’s good.
That sounded like something along the lines of what the unmarried people on this thread are asking for, but (looking ahead to any opportunities I have to teach stuff like that down the line) I wanted to ask: Allowing that you have an over-brief summary here and so can’t say with certainty, did my bishop get it right?
That sounds very right to me, David B. — A bishop (or teacher or speaker) might offer some examples specific to singles (or the widowed, or those whose non-LDS families have other ideas about the Sabbath, or whatever is appropriate to his ward members), or he might just teach principles that are applicable to everyone, leaving everybody to find a personal application. The first thing is to avoid the alienation that comes from teaching ONLY those things that can be applied ONLY by couples and families, as if the congegation were made up only of couples and families.
@1233 Other Marie:
I haven’t taken out and read my patriarchal blessing in years. It reads like it was given to someone else; there is almost no connection between what is in there and how my life has actually spun out.
Nevertheless I keep going to Church and continue to hold and use a temple recommend. I’ve simply put my patriarchal blessing on the shelf — both figuratively and literally.
I’m grateful that this discussion took place. I had to speak in sacrament meeting last Sunday. We have a much older ward, so our biggest group of singles are widows/widowers. It was a good exercise to incorporate productive thoughts that could be applied to all the adults in the room, not just the (very) small subset of married couples who still have children at home.
I am single and believe in the Church/gospel, although my situation (same-sex attraction) presents problems of its own.
I think the problem articulated by this post will actually get worse before it gets better, and I think this is because the Church has an institutional belief that it needs to counterbalance the world and its anti-family messages and practices. With traditional marriage failing and birth rates falling across the world, the Church has good reason to perceive its message as the solution and salvation for the world at large.
As someone with same-sex attraction, there are all sort of reasons I might be frustrated with the focus on the traditional family. But salvation is an individual matter, based on how I as an individual make and keep covenants according to the best of my ability. The attitude and practice of obedience is what prepares one’s heart, mind, and soul for eternity.
If I keep myself focused on the core of the gospel (i.e., faith, repentance, baptism, and living by the Holy Ghost) I am not likely to be bothered by a focus on other themes. I have so much repenting and changing to do, these core principles can keep me occupied enough.
To all my fellow single brothers and sisters: hang in there and remember: we believe not because of what the Church is not, but because of what and whose it is.
I read some of the quotes lifted from your post for the Tribune article and they are brilliant. I just wanted to say that in regards to what you need from your church regarding your life and counsel on how to live it–you don’t need it. You are brilliant and intellectual and whole and complete without the counsel from people who are not anymore inspired than you are. Judging from your own words, it’s clear that you have your head on straight. Listen to your own counsel, trust yourself. And don’t be afraid to look outside the church for love or anything else you need. It’s amazing how full and beautiful the world is out here.
Thank you, Nicole. Your words seem kindly meant, but don’t assume I am “afraid” of “the world out [t]here.” Rather than inviting me out, how about I invite you back in?
Ardis, the things you write resonate so much with me. Thank you. And thank you to Mark R. for framing the at-times very uncomfortable ambiguity of having never married and really not expecting to.
I have seen fabulous teachers and leaders and I have seen some dead abysmal ones. The ones who were really good taught doctrine, understood who they were teaching and strove to keep the teaching solid and thought provoking. The worst ones were the ones who assumed everyone was married and had children of whatever age. The most malevolent ones, in my view, used D&C 132 as some kind of platform to congratulate themselves on their impending exaltation and to condemn those who never married, regardless of whether or not they ever had a realistic shot at it.
I am an RS teacher and I try really hard to be the good kind of teacher but I know I am somewhat abrasive. One aspect of getting older is a vastly reduced capacity to accept trite folk explanations. But as a single one of the most humiliating experiences is to be a reasonably successful professional woman with a house and to be looked upon as a threat to marriages (even though I have never been a temptation to date somehow I am a temptress to all potential home teachers and must be chaperoned, even by little children, in my own home?) and to viewed as a pathetic waif. My bishop had counsel for Christmas: remember single people and invite them into your homes because they are lonely. Here’s a novel idea–if a single person invites a family to their place for dinner, maybe the invite should be accepted.
As the years have gone on I know this craving for doctrine to ease and clarify the very uncomfortable ambiguity of what happens to me, as a single woman, when I croak. Part of the relief I really desire is for my single life to be considered just as valid as the ‘ideal’ without vague and futuristic caveats of when I get to join the club of exaltation bound members.
Jenny, I wish I knew you. I have the same “vastly reduced capacity,” and think we would get along just fine. Cheers!
Despite not being Mormon (I was raised in another Christian religion), I can soooooooo relate to your points. Thoughts and worries have tormented me for several years now ….not only about the hereafter but about how to live now as an older adult single childless person. Thank you so much for writing this blog. I know now that I’m not alone and that my questions are intelligent and real.
Sometimes knowing you’ve been heard and that you aren’t alone is just what you need. Glad to hear from you, Ralna.