In Our Ward: Joseph Smith’s Seer Stone

LESSON: JOSEPH SMITH’S SEER STONE

Purpose: To help class members understand the history, purpose and use of Urim and Thummim, including seer stones, especially the seer stone used by Joseph Smith which has been in the news this week.

Lesson Organization

1. What is a seer stone? What are Urim and Thummim?
2. Why and how did Joseph Smith use such interpreters?
3. Why are they being talked about so much this week?
4. Why haven’t most class members heard about these matters before?

Introduction

I believe one of the major responsibilities of a teacher in the Church is to follow the plan of teaching outlined by the Church. While I approach Gospel Doctrine lessons a little differently from some teachers, perhaps, and ask different questions, I have always felt it important to teach from the assigned scripture block each week, and to discuss those scriptures with the purpose statement given in the lesson manual.

But I also believe that a teacher has a stewardship to her class members to teach what at least some of them need to hear, and this week, as I listened to the news and took part in discussions about the seer stone used by Joseph Smith, I have felt that some class members might have questions or be perplexed about some of what they have heard. This is obviously a topic that could not have been planned by the Curriculum Committee, and there is no formal lesson to answer questions.

So this week I am going to do something I have never before done as a teacher – lay aside the planned lesson, and teach something this class may need. That is unusual, and I will not be offended in the least if anyone feels that is inappropriate and would rather go into another classroom today.

1. What is a seer stone? What are Urim and Thummim?

The term “seer stone” may be unfamiliar, but no doubt we’re all familiar with the term “Urim and Thummim.” Let’s start there by reading the explanation in the Bible Dictionary under “Urim and Thummim”:

Urim and Thummim. Heb. term that means Lights and Perfections. An instrument prepared of God to assist man in obtaining revelation from the Lord and in translating languages. …

Using a Urim and Thummim is the special prerogative of a seer, and it would seem reasonable that such instruments were used from the time of Adam. However, the earliest mention is in connection with the brother of Jared … Abraham used a Urim and Thummim …, as did Aaron and the priests of Israel, and also the prophets among the Nephites … There is more than one Urim and Thummim, but we are informed that Joseph Smith had the one used by the brother of Jared … A partial description is given in JS-H 1:35. Joseph Smith used it in translating the Book of Mormon and in obtaining other revelations.

This earth in its celestial condition will be a Urim and Thummim, and many within that kingdom will have an additional Urim and Thummim …

While we don’t often talk about Urim and Thummim, except briefly in accounts of the coming forth of the Book of Mormon, you can see from this brief note that they are referred to several places in the scriptures, and you could spend an interesting half hour looking up the references given here. We’ll take the time to look at only a few.

Ether 3:21-28

21 And it came to pass that the Lord said unto the brother of Jared: Behold, thou shalt not suffer these things which ye have seen and heard to go forth unto the world, until the time cometh that I shall glorify my name in the flesh; wherefore, ye shall treasure up the things which ye have seen and heard, and show it to no man.

22 And behold, when ye shall come unto me, ye shall write them and shall seal them up, that no one can interpret them; for ye shall write them in a language that they cannot be read.

23 And behold, these two stones will I give unto thee, and ye shall seal them up also with the things which ye shall write.

24 For behold, the language which ye shall write I have confounded; wherefore I will cause in my own due time that these stones shall magnify to the eyes of men these things which ye shall write.

25 And when the Lord had said these words, he showed unto the brother of Jared all the inhabitants of the earth which had been, and also all that would be; and he withheld them not from his sight, even unto the ends of the earth.

26 For he had said unto him in times before, that if he would believe in him that he could show unto him all things—it should be shown unto him; therefore the Lord could not withhold anything from him, for he knew that the Lord could show him all things.

27 And the Lord said unto him: Write these things and seal them up; and I will show them in mine own due time unto the children of men.

28 And it came to pass that the Lord commanded him that he should seal up the two stones which he had received, and show them not, until the Lord should show them unto the children of men.

So the Lord showed a vision to the brother of Jared, a vision of “all things,” including his own pre-mortal spirit in the form of a man, and the brother of Jared wrote those things down, and “sealed them up.”

And yet the Lord did make provision for that writing to be known at some future time – how would he make that possible?

The Book of Mormon doesn’t tell us explicitly how those stones, or that Urim and Thummim, ended up in the hands of Mosiah, the king and prophet of the Nephites – the first time the Nephites learn of the Jaredites, those interpreters are already in Mosiah’s possession. The stones were preserved by the Nephites along with other relics – the Liahona, the sword of Laban, and so on – and when the angel Moroni told Joseph Smith about the existence of the Nephite record, he said this:

Joseph Smith – History 1:34-35

34 He said there was a book deposited, written upon gold plates, giving an account of the former inhabitants of this continent, and the source from whence they sprang. He also said that the fulness of the everlasting Gospel was contained in it, as delivered by the Savior to the ancient inhabitants;

35 Also, that there were two stones in silver bows – and these stones, fastened to a breastplate, constituted what is called the Urim and Thummim – deposited with the plates; and the possession and use of these stones were what constituted “seers” in ancient or former times; and that God had prepared them for the purpose of translating the book.

Eventually Joseph Smith received the plates, and the Urim and Thummim with them. This Urim and Thummim was the same one given to Jared. When the Three Witnesses were called, they were told that if they were faithful and accepted the call, “you shall have a view of the plates, and also of the … the Urim and Thummim, which were given to the brother of Jared upon the mount, when he talked with the Lord face to face … (Doctrine and Covenants, 17:1)

2. Why and how did Joseph use such interpreters?

In the interests of time, I’ve been selective in the verses we’ve read. The surrounding passages, though, say that whoever possesses and uses the Urim and Thummim is a “seer,” – a see-er – one who sees the things of God. Because of this term, and a few scattered references to Joseph looking into or through the Urim and Thummim, we deduce that these stones worked through sight – that Joseph and other seers saw the things of God, saw the translation of unknown languages, rather than, say, hearing them, or having them conveyed as pure knowledge straight to the mind. But beyond that, we do not know how the Urim and Thummim worked – Joseph Smith said remarkably little about the process of translating the plates, saying only that the work was done “by the gift and power of God.” What little we know about the translation process comes from others who witnessed at least part of the translation – Emma Smith, and Oliver Cowdery, and other scribes.

The Urim and Thummim that had been passed down through Book of Mormon prophets was not the only interpreter that Joseph Smith had and used, in translating the Book of Mormon. To introduce another of Joseph’s stones, I’d like to read a short account that was printed in The Friend magazine in September 1974:

A Peaceful Heart

Translating the ancient and strange looking writing on the gold plates was not a job that just anyone could do. Such an important work needed to be done by someone who was especially prepared by the Lord to do it.

Because of his spiritual nature and his willingness to learn the truth, Joseph Smith was tested and found worthy to be the translator of the book of Mormon. to help him with the translation, Joseph found with the gold plates “a curious instrument which the ancients called Urim and Thummim, which consisted of two transparent stones set in a rim of a bow fastened to a breastplate.”

Joseph also used an egg-shaped, brown rock for translating called a seer stone. The translating was done at Peter Whitmer’s home, a friend of the Prophet’s where Oliver Cowdery, Emma Smith (Joseph’s wife), one of the Whitmers, or Martin Harris wrote down the words spoken by the Prophet as soon as they were made known to him.

Martin Harris said that on the seer stone “sentences would appear and were read by the Prophet and written by [the scribe] and when finished [the scribe] would say ‘written’; and if correctly written, the sentence would disappear and another take its place; but if not written correctly it remained until corrected, so that the translation was just as it was engraven on the plates.”

Even with the help of the Urim and Thummim and the seer stone, it wasn’t easy to translate the sacred record. it required the Prophet’s greatest concentration and spiritual strength.

[This article concludes with a few paragraphs about a time Joseph was unable to translate until he had made write an argument he had had with Emma earlier that day.]

Joseph’s friend, David Whitmer, said that sometimes when the Prophet would try to translate, “he was spiritually blind” and could not do it. Joseph explained that when that happened it was because his mind “dwelt too much on earthly things.”

One morning the Prophet was unhappy with his wife Emma over a household matter. When he went upstairs where Oliver Cowdery and David Whitmer were waiting to continue with the translation, he still had a bad feeling about his wife in his heart. Joseph tried to translate but not even a syllable of a word came to him; and he knew why. Joseph went downstairs and out into an orchard where he prayed to the Lord.

After about an hour, Joseph returned to the house feeling humble and repentant. He asked Emma to forgive him for his lack of understanding. then he went back upstairs where he was able to translate without any difficulty.

David Whitmer also understood why the Prophet couldn’t translate just an hour before. He said, “Now we see how very strict the Lord is, and how he requires the heart of man to be just right in his sight before he can receive revelations from him.”

[The Friend, September 1974]

What, obviously, is different in this account from the accounts you are more familiar with?

In a 1992 talk, teaching new mission presidents in the MTC, apostle Russell M. Nelson spoke about Joseph’s use of this stone in translation:

The details of this miraculous method of translation are still not fully known. Yet we do have a few precious insights. David Whitmer wrote:

“Joseph Smith would put the seer stone into a hat, and put his face in the hat, drawing it closely around his face to exclude the light; and in the darkness the spiritual light would shine. A piece of something resembling parchment would appear, and on that appeared the writing. One character at a time would appear, and under it was the interpretation in English. Brother Joseph would read off the English to Oliver Cowdery, who was his principal scribe, and when it was written down and repeated to Brother Joseph to see if it was correct, then it would disappear, and another character with the interpretation would appear. Thus the Book of Mormon was translated by the gift and power of God, and not by any power of man.” (David Whitmer, An Address to All Believers in Christ, Richmond, Mo.: n.p., 1887, p. 12.)

[Russell M. Nelson, “A Treasured Testament,” Ensign, July 1993. http://www.lds.org/ensign/1993/07/a-treasured-testament ]

We don’t know a great deal about the origin of this seer stone. Friendly sources tell us that Joseph Smith found it while digging a well. Unfriendly sources claim that he found it while seeking for buried treasure.

Joseph Smith used this and other seer stones to receive revelations early in his work as a prophet. By the spring of 1830, however, he seems to have stopped using all seer stones, explaining that he had learned to receive revelation without the need for such props. When he no longer had a need for it, Joseph gave this brown seer stone to Oliver Cowdery; it passed to Oliver’s brother-in-law Phineas Young after Oliver died; Phineas gave it to his brother Brigham Young; it was part of Brigham’s estate when he died in 1877, and Zina Young Card recognized it for what it was and purchased it from the estate; she later passed it on to John Taylor, and it has been in the possession of the Church ever since.

3. Why are they being talked about so much this week?

This brown seer stone – much less familiar than the Urim and Thummim set like spectacles and given to Joseph Smith with the gold plates – has been in the news this week because the Joseph Smith Papers – a scholarly project of the Church – has just published a new volume of pictures and transcriptions of the manuscript that E.B. Grandin’s men used to set type for the Book of Mormon in 1829-30. That volume includes an introduction about the finding and translation and printing of the Book of Mormon. It also includes two pages of photographs, of Joseph Smith’s brown seer stone and the leather pouch that he kept it in.

This is the first time the Church has ever published photographs of the seer stone. Because of that novelty, and because the stone – a tangible, physical object, involved in what we claim are miraculous events – seems so out of place in a world that values hard-headed scientific objectivity, and where religion is most often a matter of emotions and ethics and other internal principles, the stone has been the object of a lot of sensational attention. Because the Church has not often talked about this seer stone, many Church members (including Joseph Fielding Smith) have denied its use by Joseph, and some have even denied its existence, believing that the story was made up by enemies of the Church to discredit Joseph Smith as a magician rather than a prophet.

The publication of these photos has brought on a storm of laughter and mockery, some of which might have disturbed some class members. Hence, this lesson, and the chance to talk about the stone in a believing atmosphere.

4. Why haven’t most class members heard about these matters before?

This may be the hardest question to address. If you haven’t heard of the stone before, why not?

For some people – me, for example – it’s hard to understand why you haven’t heard of it. I can’t remember the first time I heard about it, and, as we’ve seen from The Friend article and Elder Nelson’s talk, published in the Ensign, the Church hasn’t exactly been hiding the story. But I realize that most people are not as fascinated by Church history as I am, which probably accounts for why I noticed and remembered the stone, while many, many other Church members have not.

The Church has definitely not included this seer stone in the stories we tell about the Restoration often enough for everyone to have known about it. Why not? I can’t answer that, but I can speculate. History is a vast, complex body of facts and impressions and opinions. History is rewritten constantly, to suit the needs of new generations – that’s why there can be a new biography of Abraham Lincoln every year. That’s why there are so many biographies of Brigham Young – one will emphasize his abilities as a pioneer and colonizer; another will emphasize his conflicts with the federal government; a third will talk about him as a husband and father; and still another will stress his teachings as a president of the Church.

When the Church tells the story of the Restoration, writers pick and choose the details that are most essential, or easiest to understand, or which teach a principle that the Church needs to emphasize. When details are messy, or inconvenient, or don’t fit well with the modern world, Church teachers, like anybody else, tend to downplay or “forget” those details. My opinion is that this bit of our history has been mostly overlooked because it is a messy detail that complicates our clean, easy narrative. It doesn’t change anything essential – Joseph still translated the plates through the gift and power of God – but it’s messy. The story hasn’t been deliberately hidden – it has in fact been well known to the people who are interested in such things – but it comes as a surprise to others, especially when it is presented in as sensational and sometimes distorted way, as this has been presented this week.

When this volume was announced to the press this week, and the photos of the seer stone began to circulate, the Church released an article that will be published in the October Ensign which gives more background on the stone. [Write URL on board: https://www.lds.org/ensign/2015/10/joseph-the-seer]

[Questions and {attempted} answers.]

Conclusion

[Offer to provide other references to class members who want to read more. Explain briefly how I handle challenges to my own testimony, by backing up and evaluating what I know and why I have only assumed or mistakenly accepted. I believe the Book of Mormon is the word of God, and that Joseph Smith translated it by the gift and power of God – my testimony of these facts is independent of how or why or when or other details. If I hadn’t known of the seer stone earlier, I would have to incorporate these new details into what I already understood, but that does not change the nature of the Book of Mormon or of Joseph Smith’s prophetic function.]

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "In Our Ward: Joseph Smith's Seer Stone." Keepapitchin.org, 09 Aug 2015, https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/08/09/in-our-ward-joseph-smiths-seer-stone/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2015, Aug 09). In Our Ward: Joseph Smith's Seer Stone. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/08/09/in-our-ward-joseph-smiths-seer-stone/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/08/09/in-our-ward-joseph-smiths-seer-stone/">In Our Ward: Joseph Smith's Seer Stone</a>

45 thoughts on “In Our Ward: Joseph Smith’s Seer Stone”

  1. It’s obvious the seer stone will never be put on display in a museum, even in an exhibit devoted to the Book of Mormon. There’s too great a chance that visitors may receive or claim to receive revelations while peering into it.

  2. It’s also the kind of object too closely associated with sacred events to put on display.

  3. I have a couple of very random thoughts.

    The motto of Yale University is given as: Urim V’Thummim (Hebrew); Lux et Veritas (Latin); Light and Truth (English). How well they achieve this is, of course, open to question.

    Lao Tzu (571-531 BC) wrote (English translation, obviously):

    “The wise student hears of the Tao and practices it diligently.
    The average student hears of the Tao and gives it thought now and again.
    The foolish student hears of the Tao and laughs aloud.
    If there were no laughter, the Tao would not be what it is.”

    Tao here implies the True Way, or the Way of Heaven.

    I have found in my own life that it is helpful not only to see who agrees with my thoughts or course of action, but to also see who is mocking them. I become nervous of anything that is universally agreed upon. Satan will always be attacking the truth.

  4. I appreciate your honesty in this lesson plan. If I were in your class, and the opportunity presented itself, I might offer that our church leaders are called and set apart to testify of the truthfulness of the Gospel of Jesus Christ and the restoration in these latter days — but they are not called as historians. How wonderful is the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and how great a man was the Prophet Joseph Smith.

  5. One more random comment: Jared’s Urim and Thummin was very likely to have become an emblem of kingship among the Jaredite people. The kingship among the Jaredites managed to stay among recognized descendants of Jared, in spite of periodic interruptions. The last king of the Jaredites, Coriantumr, fled a horrendous battle and was taken in by the people of Zarahemla among whom he lived for “nine moons.” He wrote a history of his people on large stone (stella). Then Mosiah arrived with a group of fleeing Nephites and is shown Coriantumr’s stella. The next mention of the interpretors is that Mosiah’s grandson, also Mosiah, has possession of them.

    My personal thought is that Coriantumr took them with him and left them in the hands of the people of Zarahemla, explaining that they were a symbol of kingship. Then the people of Zarahemla passed them on to their king. That makes sense to me–but what do I know?

  6. Something else that might be worthy of mention: the seer stone photographs were released in a historical setting by the Church historian for a historical purpose — they were not released in an ecclesiastical setting for purposes of building faith.

  7. There are some very good ideas in these comments which may find their way into the lesson as it really goes. Thank you.

  8. Nicely done!
    A quick note on terminology- the Book of Mormon only speaks of “interpreters”, but early LDS very quickly started applying the terminology from the biblical analogue, Urim and Thummim. They’re not entirely interchangeable, though we have historically done so. The primary book on it is Van Dam’s, which I thought had a good review at the MI, but can’t find. Jeff Lindsay’s thoughts here.
    http://mormanity.blogspot.com/2008/08/cornelius-van-dam-on-urim-and-thummim.html

  9. Nicely done, Ardis. I do hope you’ll share how your class responds to the lesson, and what sort of questions were asked.

  10. I’m not going to worry about splitting that hair in this overview, Ben, although it’s obviously a distinction scholars must make. Thanksfor the link.

    I’ll give some kind of report in a couple of hours. Thanks for your suport, all.

  11. I, too, wish I could be there to enjoy this lesson with you and your class, Ardis. I hope everything goes well and that the Spirit can teach those who hear.

  12. As far as I could judge, the lesson went really, really well — so well that one woman refused to go out to be set apart for a new calling, because she didn’t want to miss a thing. There was lots of participation, both in the form of questions and in more testimony-type statements. One man challenged me over and over but in a polite way. The class was extra full, and virtually all eyes were on me virtually all the time, which is usually a sign of attention and interest.

    I was startled to learn from the first sentence that most of the class hadn’t heard any news whatsoever about the seer stone — one wanted to know which newspaper it was in (for readers away from Salt Lake, know that it has been in both newspapers and all TV stations, sometimes with follow-up stories). Once I realized that, I spoke in more detail than I had expected to about the new Joseph Smith Papers book, the press conference, and the attention focused on the seer stone pictures.

    There wasn’t any sign that I could pick up that anybody, old or young, had been at all disturbed by the idea of Joseph Smith using a seer stone, nor any upset that they hadn’t heard of this earlier. But when one class member said twice that there wasn’t any need for upset, that we could all pray for a testimony, I pushed back twice: I told her I was glad she understood and was having no trouble, “but we can’t blame people who might have such questions by assuming everyone is alike; if there is anyone in the class whose response isn’t quite so positive, I want them to know that I take their questions seriously. Of course it’s all right to need to work out how you feel.”

    Lots of participation, and far more than usual class members wanting to talk to me afterwards, not with questions but to say they were glad to have been there today.

    I also owe Mike R. thanks for his help. I used the Friend story from 1974 both because it was short and simple — appropriate for a too-short class period, and reinforcing the notion that while the Church hasn’t pushed the seer stone front and center, neither has it done a very good job of hiding it. But I needed that story to be read with real expression; the unfamiliar details, read in the usual sing-singiness with which most people read scripture aloud, would have been completely lost. Mike R. is one of the best readers of scripture and I can always count on him when I need something read especially well, so I asked him to read that story.

    A lot of people came up to look at the pictures in the copy of my book, too. I tell you, there was real interest in the object and story themselves, and I think real appreciation at having it explained where they could ask questions.

  13. Oh man! When I saw that you had posted your lesson here I didnt think it necessary to take up space in the classroom but now I’m wishing I had. I would have loved to have heard the comments and been part of the discussion!

  14. Yeah Ardis, I’m glad this went well. I too teach Gospel Doctrine (Central Texas) and decided that it was important that there be at least some discussion of this noteworthy announcement by the church. My classroom (the RS room) holds about 50 people and was full. Only one person was aware of the announcement this week. About 1/3 of the class had heard of JS’s use of a seerstone. Several people also indicated they were aware that the church had possession of the seerstone (something I didn’t know before). Two (young and new to the ward members) had anecdotes from their professors at BYU on Joseph’s use of the seerstone. I also put our discussion into the context of the Joseph Smith papers project and gave an illustration of how the art work we’ve seen has influenced our perception of the process of translating the plates (per the 10/15 Ensign article referenced in the church’s online announcement), as well as showing an image of the seerstone. I mentioned the church’s effort at transparency and the importance of being aware of the essays that can be found on the church’s website. I also felt that the class was very engaged, listening and processing. Several comments were made about God’s use of stones such as the Brother of Jared and the white stone given to those who are exalted. One excellent comment was made about how it may seem weird to us to use such a stone for translating, the concept of seerstones was common in JS’s day and would not have been usual to him or others. I made the transition into our prescribed lesson (#29) about how the church can and does adapt to the needs of the time and members. Seven men were called to meet the temporal needs of the widows mentioned in Acts and the church is making our history of our origins available for all.

  15. That sounds great, Jones — thanks for outlining it here, which might give ideas to other teachers who spend even a few minutes on the topic.

    I suppose it’s another manifestation of the echo chamber, but I’m still finding it hard to believe that so few people heard anything about this, when my FB newsfeed was virtually nothing else for about three days. I guess my friends group is way too focused on Mormon Studies types, like me. 🙂

  16. Great lesson! Glad you had the sense/inspiration to teach it. No mention of it here, that I heard of, but I teach the youth SS class and we were out under a tree that hour. I live in a small town in NW Washington. We call the local newspaper “the paper” because there is very little news in it, yet IT even had a 1/4 page article on the seer stone, complete with pictures of the stone and the leather pouch (which sadly looked like a, well, rocky mountain oyster, if you will, at first glance. Farming community here!) I read something somewhere about those who have eyes to see not bothering to look…as a convert, not a historian, I’ve know about the stone for years. Can’t read early history of the Church without encountering it; unless you gloss over it by feeling uneasy with our modern minds.

  17. Aw, shucks — you’re very kind. Class was great, and I’m glad you pushed back on the idea that the stone isn’t, or shouldn’t be troubling. I was going to say something there at the end about how my own reaction to the stone is faithful, but complicated. I’ve known about it for years and am immensely pleased that photographs have been released, but I’m not 100% at ease with its new prominence. Still, it doesn’t change what I already know and feel about the Book of Mormon. We were out of time, though, so I was very glad you said something at the end that acknowledge that it’s not simple for everyone, but that it’s still possible to respond faithfully.

  18. Glad to hear that it went so well—it speaks to a level of maturity among both the teacher and the class members (including that one person you mentioned who challenged you, but kept it polite—that’s not always easy to do).

    I find it intriguing but not actually surprising that so few people had heard the news—there’s a lot of stuff barraging us at all times, and we really do a good job at filtering out the things that don’t seem to concern us right at the moment. This is sometimes a positive, sometimes not, but either way it’s a good reminder that the things that catch the imagination of any one of us aren’t necessarily going to be things that even register with others, let alone seem significant to them.

    It makes the job of a teacher (of any subject, spiritual or secular) a bit more difficult, but also a bit more interesting, i think.

  19. I learned so much from your lesson Ardis! Now I know what to do for Family Home Evening tomorrow night with our teen/young adult children (once the 3yo is in bed).

  20. I appreciate your lesson spelled out here. I teach the Family History class all the time, so I never get into the GD class. Because of that, I really look forward to reading how you taught the lessons. I never heard one person talking about the seer stone today in the halls or in Sacrament Meeting. Maybe I should skip over my lesson next week and talk about the seer stone instead.

  21. I mentioned this to Rosa, who just arrived in the Samara, Russia mission. Her response was, “Oh, yeah. I heard about the stone and the hat–maybe in Sunday School. There was an episode of South Park that made fun of it, so it might disturb someone who didn’t know about it.” On to the next topic. So it was certainly no issue for her.

  22. Thank you for giving those of us in your virtual classroom the “chance to talk about the stone in a believing atmosphere.”

  23. Thanks for sharing this, Ardis! As to the question of “why haven’t I heard this before?”—I think one explanation that’s glossed over, but is probably a big part of the issue, is that for decades the major source of information to many church members was young men and women serving as full-time missionaries. There’s always this pull amongst missionaries to sell the gospel, and in that kind of environment it’s easy to gloss over the facets of the restoration that might cause questioning amongst potential converts.

    I still remember vividly the day my companion and I were teaching an investigator about the scriptures of the restoration. The investigator was knowledgeable in the common Anti-mormon arguments which abound in the Bible Belt, and so we attempted to answer their questions. My companion’s go-to answers where basically denials of seer stones or anything superstitious, and explaining that the Pearl of Great Price came from the Dead Sea Scrolls. I wish this kind of display of complete ignorance of church history was uncommon, but it was not. Thankfully, the strong current of anti-mormon literature in our mission served as a pretty heavy-duty bootcamp for most of us in learning all about this kind of thing. But I was always having to teach my companions about this stuff and it could turn into some really bad arguments.

    To that end, the better we prepare youth with this knowledge before they go out into the world, the better. I can’t tell you how grateful I am to have had the teaching of great parents and leaders who helped me know this stuff from an early age.

  24. Great lesson. We live in exciting times. Some times we fail to do more research then we should. The 1974 article is very informative. As a fellow GD Teacher you rock and make our the rest of our profession (if you will) a proud bunch. Not sure my Bishop would have given me the latitude you had, wasn’t my week anyway. Still struggling with my students and understanding the whole resurrection miracle and a greater love for Christ. The seer stone lesson might have caused a very bad case of the vapors. God bless you. I did talk in Sacrament Meeting and mentioned how exciting our days are with new publishing’s, artifacts and revelations.

  25. Thanks for putting this together and sharing. I’ve gotten a number of phone calls and questions about the seer stones. May I share your materials with these friends?

  26. Of course! If you think it’s the right approach to help any of your questioners, share away. I realize that its being written to be used in Sunday School might not make it the right approach for everybody, but I hope it will suit many.

  27. I wish I had been there, too. I didn’t take the opportunity to speak with anyone about the announcement, both because the issue didn’t come up, and because I was not surprised by the announcement, being (like you, Ardis) unable to remember a time since I joined the Church when I was not aware that Joseph used a stone.

    My Gospel Doctrine teacher was too busy turning a lesson about Pentecost and the selection of a new apostle (Acts 1-3?) into a mini-sermon on our duty to love gays like true Christians while never, never backing down on doctrine. Whatever that means to her. It’s been her hobby horse lately. :{

  28. Thanks for the lesson. It was great for my seminary class. We are still studying D&C and Church History since our school year is offset by 6 months from the northern hemisphere.

  29. New Iconoclast, we’re a week ahead of your ward. In the way that this lesson actually played out (my outline cannot, of course, take into account the questions that come up or the way discussion gos), I referred back to that lesson, and the selection of Matthias as a new apostle through the casting of lots, as an example of another pre-modern practice that, like a seer stone, might strike those of us unfamiliar with it as a form of magic, where believers in the practice are exercising faith that God will make his will known through that practice.

    Holly, I’m glad to know that you find it useful. I assume that you are not a regular Keepa reader, or that you are ordinarily a lurker, so you might not be aware of this: Your comment is the 40,000 comment made on the blog, and I announced a couple of weeks ago that whoever made that landmark comment would win a copy of the Mormon history I’m writing, She Shall Be an Ensign, when it is published next spring. Congratulations — I hope that’s also something you will enjoy.

  30. Lest anyone here bemoan a missed and wonderful opportunity for such a lesson, next year’s course of study is the Book of Mormon. This would be timely again in January. Thanks for posting this wonderful summary and lesson plan. What a blessing it must be for your ward members to have a Sunday School teacher who is paying attention!

  31. Steve (1) I wouldn’t be surprised if it ends up in a museum. Others of Joseph’s seer stones have. While we may view it as sacred not all even among church leaders have seen it that way. Were it up to me I’d not put it in a museum. But a lot depends upon how people view it in the future. Honestly I’m surprised they gave pictures. Although as I’ve noted elsewhere, the church has published pictures of the Holy of Holies in Salt Lake City. And this is arguably far less sacred than that.

    BTW – as an aside. Rereading Ether 3 it’s not clear to me whether the Brother of Jared’s U&T are two new stones God gives him or are two of the stones that lit his boat. I think it could be read either way. (There’s sort of an editorial aside by Moroni between the two bits of narrative)

  32. Wait, the 40,000th comment thing almost escaped my gaze. Congrats to Holly, but, ahem, CONGRATS TO ARDIS for hosting this wonderful place, where people have contributed 40,000 comments. Wow!

  33. “We do not overstate the point when we say that the scriptures can be a Urim and Thummim to assist each of us to receive personal revelation.”

    “Scripture Reading and Revelation”
    Elder Dallin H. Oaks
    Of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles

    Ensign, January 1995

  34. Great job, Ardis. I ama believer that this kind of lesson is necessary from time to time. In my class last Sunday, I just talked a bit about the new JSP volume and press conference, the October Ensign article and the pictures that hd caused a stir, and then reminded the class that we had already had a discussion of seerstones in this class during our BoM year.

    http://bycommonconsent.com/2012/05/06/teaching-the-stone-in-the-hat/

  35. Great article!

    I remember my seminary teacher telling us about the seer stone and how it was used to translate the Book of Mormon. I remember him telling us that it had been found while Joseph dug a well. It was described as being “chocolate” in color.

    I seem to remember him showing us pictures of some other seer stones that the RLDS(Community of Christ) church had in its possession. I seem to recall (perhaps incorrectly) that the seer stone had been seen on an alter in the Manti temple or something.

    Having some background on the stone,I was rather surprised and excited to see an actual image of it. However, I personally don’t see much that is mystical about the object, because it was a divine calling and faith that was the driving force in Josephs ability to translate.

    I get a little tired of certain people accusing the church of being dishonest and hiding history. Most information of which they are talking is available for anyone willing to look. To become truly knowledgeable about any topic, you must take your own initiative and seek out information.

Comments are closed.