This is not a story, really, but an illustration of learning about history by tacking little pieces of new knowledge to what you already know and, sometimes, adding little bits of new knowledge to Church history. Sometimes those bits are a lot more important than those in this post, but the process is exactly the same.
Last night, while searching for something entirely unrelated, I noticed this tiny story in the news columns of the Baltimore Sun for 23 November 1842:
A Mormon Meeting.
A party of one hundred and sixty-eight English Mormons, who were on their way to this country, in the ship Henry, bound for New Orleans, mutinied on the voyage; on their arrival at New Orleans, the Rev. John Snyder and two others who were pointed out as the ringleaders, were arrested. The New Orleans papers do not state in what the mutiny consisted.
Mutinous Mormons? That didn’t seem very likely – especially when the news story was told with what was supposed to be a comic flair: “A Mormon Meeting” – ha, ha, look what happens when Mormons get together! (I’ve seen the same kind of headline for innumerable stories in later decades about fistfights in black saloons, as if drinking and fighting were the noblest activities of blacks.)
But … there were enough concrete details – the name of the ship, the name of the “reverend” Mormon, the number of passengers – to be able to check it out. I went to the Mormon Migration project (the inspiration for the more famous Mormon Pioneer Overland Travel database) that organizes all known records of Mormons crossing the ocean in the 19th century. I put the name “John Snyder” into the search engine, and the first hit came for “John Snider” sailing from Liverpool to New Orleans in 1842, aboard the Henry. A winner on the first try!
I clicked through to “read more about this voyage,” which gave me some basic facts for this voyage. There were 157 Saints aboard, according to the Mormon records, rather than 168 according to the Baltimore Sun. The names of only 10 of those passengers, however, are known at the present date. I could have clicked on the name of any of those passengers and been taken to a screen that gave what biographical information was known for that person.
But because I was looking for a story about mutiny, I was more interested in the three “Accounts of this voyage” offered on that page.
The first link, “A Compilation of General Voyage Notes” from an account published in the Millennial Star, 1891, provided this information:
“SEVENTEENTH COMPANY, — Henry 157 souls. On Thursday, September 29th, 1842, the ship Henry, Captain Pierce, sailed from Liverpool with one hundred and fifty-seven Saints bound for Nauvoo, via New Orleans, under the direction of John Snider. Elder Snider arrived in Nauvoo January 23rd, 1843, but his company of emigrants were detained on the way because of ice on the Mississippi River, and did not arrive in Nauvoo till the following spring.
No hint of mutiny there, although I did note that the ship had arrived at New Orleans on 10 November 1842 and Elder Snider hadn’t arrived upriver in Nauvoo until 23 January 1843, more than two months later. I wondered what caused that delay? No hint in this record, except that while ice had delayed his company much, much longer, perhaps it had also slowed down a man moving ahead on his own.
The second travel account was the Journal of James Burgess. Burgess, his unnamed wife and daughter, and a Samuel Burgess who might have been related (all of them could no doubt be identified easily enough, but that wasn’t the point of my searching last night) were aboard the Henry. Of the voyage as far as New Orleans he wrote:
When leaving we had a fair wind for upwards of a fortnight afterwards it was changeable, we had considerable seasickness on our way no deaths until we got in the river and then we had the deaths of two children one before we got to Orleans and the other in coming up between [New Orleans] and St. Louis. We had considerable excitement on board through the captain. It was on the ship Henry of New York that we came on with Captain Peers. We had also Elder Snider for our leader. We arrived at New Orleans on the 20th of November being Sunday. We found people here from almost all country. It seemed rather strange to see them holding their market day on Sunday but however it is reckoned to be the best market day with them. Afterwards, we took our luggage off the steam boat “Galnare” for St. Louis. We left Orleans on the following Thursday. On our way we found it rather difficult to get up being short of water. We saw several steam boats that had been such of late with running on snags. We were obliged to stop several times on our way being short of water. We were stopped a whole week at Buffalo Island; while here we went out a shooting several times. We arrived at St. Louis on the 12th of December, 1842.
Oh, hey, what’s that? “We had considerable excitement on board through the captain.” No clue as to what the excitement was, but it does indicate something of an apparently unusual nature.
The third account was the Journal of Alfred Cardon, another of the passengers. Alfred is much more descriptive:
We had a fair wind which glided us swiftly across the waters. For the first fifteen days, joy, peace, and harmony prevailed to a great which made us very comfortable. The captain was very kind to us for two or three weeks, after that time he began to abuse us and insult us in every possible way that he could. Elder Snider and he differed from time to time. The captain swore he would keep us on the ship until we were starved to death. On the 14th of November 1842 we came to the mouth of the Mississippi River. Remained there six days on account of the evil disposition of the captain, who was determined to provoke us as much as possible. When Captain Taylor came on board to examine the log book he found a charge laid against Elder Snider and James Morgan for mutiny. J. Snider and do [i.e., “ditto,” meaning James Morgan] were sent up to Orleans. Joseph Parkins one of the passengers had a child that was on the point of death, which when Captain Taylor saw it he prevailed upon the captain to allow the child to be took to his house a distance of three miles up the river to a village called the Blaize. The next day I went on shore and the child was dead and about to be buried. A colored man made the coffin and dug the grave. The grave was about two feet deep with about one foot of water in it so that we had to stand on the coffin to hold it down while the dirt was thrown upon it. Captain Taylor acted in the most charitable and philanthropic manner a gentleman could act. We returned to the ship in the evening; a dreadful storm arose, so with great difficultly we reached the ship. The captain commenced to insult and abuse us in a most shocking manner.
On Saturday 19th Nov. 1842 a steamboat took us in tow and about midnight we arrived in New Orleans, Sunday morning we went ashore to view the place. The market was opened and the fruit and vegetables of all descriptions was laid out in excellent order. There were people of all colors speaking every language under heaven almost. There were a many slaves working on the streets chained together both men and women. The weather was warm like an English summer. We met with Elder Snider &c., and we rejoiced to see each other; spent the day in viewing the place &c..
Wednesday 23rd Nov. 1842 we started for St. Louis on the steam boat “Gulnare.” We gathered a few branches the first day when the boat stopped to take in wood. We came on very well for several days until we came to the mouth of the Ohio River. The river now began to be full of ice, and the water being very low made it very difficult to get along. We passed through one alarming place, called the graveyard, on account of so many boats being wrecked at there …
and so on, for the rest of the prolonged voyage upriver to Nauvoo.
So that was the source of the trouble, at least according to Mormon understanding, and confirmation that my Baltimore Sun article wasn’t just a story played for laughs, but had in fact really happened. Two more things I note from Alfred Cardon’s account:
First, while the account is sincere and there is no reason to doubt its general accuracy, it is written by a passenger who was not privy to the background of all he describes. He seems to believe that Captain Pierce brought his ship and its passengers across the Atlantic, then hovered near the mouth of the Mississippi for six days simply to inconvenience his passengers. That seems unlikely, no matter what ill will there may have been between captain and passengers – those days would have put the captain and/or the ship’s owners to additional expense, which seems extravagant and wasteful merely to annoy someone.
And second, if John Snider and James Morgan (and an unidentified third man, unmentioned by Cardon but included in news reports) were arrested, the investigation and their apparent release from custody came remarkably quickly: They’re taken off the Henry on 14 November and are “rejoicing” with their fellow passengers on shore on 19 November.
The New Orleans newspaper Daily Picayune reports the story as follows on 17 November (too bad for our sake that it wasn’t written a few days later to tell us about the resolution of the matter, but we takes what we can gets in the history business):
More Mormon Troubles.
It will be recollected that the late English paper spoke of a party of one hundred and sixty-eight English Mormons being on their way out to this country, with the design of colonizing with Joe Smith at Nauvoo. A letter from the active and intelligent Capt. Taylor, the boarding officer at Belize, to a friend in this city, gives us the next notice of their whereabouts.
Capt. Taylor, in one of his cruizes, on the 14th inst., at the bar of the N.E. Pass, was hailed by Capt. Pierce, of the ship Henry, on board of which the Mormons were. Capt. T. boarded the ship, when he was informed by Capt. P. that the passengers were then, and had been in a state of mutiny, from the time they were three days out from Liverpool. At the request of Capt. Pierce, and on his affidavit, Capt. Taylor made prisoners of the Rev. John Snyder and two others whom Pierce pointed out as the ringleaders.
Capt. Taylor took the prisoners ashore with him. They have been since brought up to the city by the towboat Swan.
(I have not as yet had opportunity to search the English newspaper database for this story, nor have I yet found it reported in other American papers.)
A little Googling fleshed out the story a little more. La Balize (rather than “the Blaize” as Alfred Cardon, or at least his transcriber, has it) was an old French fort (the earliest French installation in United States territory, apparently) located at the mouth of the Mississippi River, downriver from New Orleans. Ocean-going vessels wanting to continue to New Orleans needed a local pilot (indeed, the site of La Balize is now known as Pilottown) to help them navigate the labyrinth of the Mississippi River delta with its shifting sandbars, and steamboats could also tow sailing ships upriver more efficiently than those sailing vessels could carry themselves (I haven’t gone deep enough to know whether steamships were used in 1842). Captain Pierce probably held the Henry at the mouth of the river waiting for a pilot, rather than merely irritating his passengers. Those passengers would not have been familiar with navigation practices in that area, and if the captain didn’t explain to them what he was waiting for, they easily could have assumed it was mere harassment on his part.
“Capt. Taylor” is Captain William G.B. Taylor of the U.S. Navy, who had been stationed at La Balize at least since 1831 and perhaps as late as 1847 (he is referred to as “late” in an 1850 report, but whether that means he was deceased or merely no longer stationed at La Balize is unclear to me). According to his occasional appearance in newspapers, his duties sometimes involved chasing down and seizing pirate ships. He had his family with him at La Balize, and, as evidenced by his willingness to take a dying child to his home for care, and subsequently to bury that child, Captain Taylor was a compassionate man – if we had a Mormon equivalent of Israel’s Yad Vashem, I might nominate him as one of the “righteous among the nations.”
And that is how you expand our knowledge of Mormon history, one tiny bit at a time.
Very nice, Ardis! It’s fun seeing your process of taking a small hint somewhere and verifying the facts and fleshing out the details and making it into a real story.
It looks like “Rev” John Snider may be Canadian John Snider (1800-1875), and we all know how hot-headed Canadians can be. : )
His family’s biography doesn’t mention a mission to England, but his entry in Pioneers and Prominent Men does, as does his entry at the Joseph Smith Papers Project which, however, gives dates of 1842-1843, citing “JS, Journal, 26 Mar. 1842 and 23 Jan. 1843.” So some discrepancy there.
If this is the right man, he was mentioned three times in the Doctrine and Covenants.
Never mind…no discrepancy in the dates. You mentioned the January date, and it agrees with the JS Papers documentation.
It’s interesting that they use “mutiny” to describe a disagreement between the ship’s captain and its passengers. I thought you had to be a crewman to mutiny.
Brilliant detective work, dear Ardis. I always love hearing the rest of the story.
Serendipity. Several of my projects have started out with little more than what you had here. It’s almost as if a voice is saying “There is more to this story, if you can find it.” Love this.
Phineas Young wrote to Brigham Young regarding the mutiny in a letter dated 14 December 1842 in conjunction with trying to shepherd Oliver Cowdery back into the church. The following is my transcription of an excerpt of the letter which is available online at
https://catalog.lds.org/assets/feba23e3-20d3-47ce-a609-214dd8ecb2e5/0/0
(the correct page order is pg 2, 4, 1 and 3)
on what they label as page 1, it says in part,
…There is a serious affair now before the Church to wit, the case of Brother John Snyder who the Weekly New Era Morning Post , says, was arrested on the 14th Nov. on board the ship Henry by Capt Taylor, the Boarding officer at the Balize, with two other persons ringleader(s) of a mutiny and [unknown] in the calaboose at New Orleans; now if the High Council think proper to authorize me to raise funds to defray expenses; Brother Oliver will start for New Orleans and do all for the Brethren that Can be done he will wait for an answer from you, therefore if you feel disposed to write line it to this place…
Snyder was later released in January of 1843. For a little more detail, see article “Return of Oliver Cowdery” by Faulring at https://publications.mi.byu.edu/fullscreen/?pub=973 especially section around footnotes 10-12.
Enjoy
Really, really fun find, Steven — thanks for finding or remembering this post, and sharing your find!
(The multiple links took this to the spam folder. I’m sorry it took me so long to find and free it.)