One of the women from Church history who is remembered by name by virtually anyone who has even the barest knowledge of Church history is Emma Hale Smith, wife of the Prophet Joseph Smith. She was the loving wife who stood by her husband through 17 years of tumultuous marriage and social upheaval. She was the faithful Latter-day Saint who served as her husband’s scribe for part of his translation of the plates, who compiled the Church’s first hymnbook, who was the first general president of the Relief Society. She is the woman whose tragedies in life inspire sympathy – the woman who lost so many children in infancy, the woman who took in infants whose mother had died, the woman whose husband was torn from her through violence, leaving her to raise her still-young children alone. She is the honored subject of the visual arts, of plays, of descendants’ celebrations. She is the “Elect Lady” of scripture.
That’s all true … in 2015. But that wasn’t always the case. Before 1984, before Linda King Newell’s and Valeen Tippets Avery’s sensitive Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith, Emma Hale Smith was one of the great villains of Mormon history. She was the woman who had stayed behind in Nauvoo, denying Brigham Young’s authority as president of the Church. She was the woman who betrayed Joseph’s memory by marrying an adulterous non-Mormon. She is the one who helped her son establish that wicked and apostate church, the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. ((Please understand that in this paragraph I am reflecting the attitudes I knew in the 1960s and ’70s.)) She is the one of whom Brigham Young said: “Joseph used to say that he would have her hereafter, if he had to go to hell for her, and he will have to go to hell for her as sure as he ever gets her.” ((Journal of Discourses, 17:159.)) Brigham also supposedly said that “Emma Smith is one of the damnedest liars on earth!” accusing her of twice attempting to murder Joseph Smith by poison. ((I have not seen the original minutes, but this is reportedly a statement Brigham Young made in General Conference on 7 October 1866 edited from the talk before it was published in the Deseret News.)) She is the one about whom I said something sympathetic in 2010, only to have my aunt spit back in anger, “That woman kept Joseph’s children out of the Church!”
If you were born after the mid-1970s, you might not remember this negative portrayal of Emma Smith; you might find it hard to believe she was ever pictured this way in our collective memory – but I can attest that this is the view of Emma I grew up with. I remember the surprise I felt as a young woman reading a pamphlet I had been given at some Church meeting – it was a brief biography of Emma, one which gave her an “out” for the “terrible woman” she had become: perhaps, the writer opined, Emma had received such a shock at seeing her husband’s dead body brought home from Carthage, that she had had a nervous breakdown, and that accounted for her erratic behavior after that point. It may be hard for younger readers to believe in 2015, but the possibility of mental illness was such a positive thing, in comparison to how Emma had earlier appeared to us, that it evoked our pity and began the restoration of Emma’s reputation.
Emma is, perhaps, a special case. Few women have been so reviled in Church history – few women have had such a lofty pedestal to fall from. Emma for generations was the pinnacle of Wicked Witchiness in Church history.
But Emma was not alone in her despised coven. Probably the second most oft-told story of the wicked witch is that of Mrs. Marsh – Elizabeth Godkin Marsh, wife of Thomas B. Marsh. (A show of hands, please: How often have you heard her called by her full personal name? Ever hear her maiden name before? Or is she always just “the wife of Thomas B. Marsh,” or even “that woman with the milk strippings”?) Her traditionally told story, if you need a reminder, is that she and “Mrs. Harris” (that’s Lucinda Pendleton Morgan Harris) made a deal to exchange the last pint of milk from milking their cows, so that each in turn would have enough extra cream to make a bigger, better cheese. Mrs. Marsh kept back part of her strippings, cheating Mrs. Harris, who took the case to the high council. And then, by supporting his wife, Thomas B. Marsh lost his position in the Quorum of the Twelve, and apostatized. In the words of George A. Smith, speaking nearly 20 years after the fact, “This little affair, you will observe, kicked up a considerable breeze, and Thomas B. Marsh then declared that he would sustain the character of his wife, even if he had to go to hell for it.” ((Journal of Discourses 3:283-284)) (There’s an awful lot of hell-going where wicked witches are concerned, isn’t there?)
When general church histories ((That is, those that tell the history of the Church generally; not women’s biographies and autobiographies, and not histories of the Relief Society)) mention so few women as having roles in early Church history, it is simply astounding how many of those few women appear because they created difficulty for the early Church and its leaders:
One of these is the Miss or Mrs. Hubble (current scholarship suggests two possible identities for this woman, but neither is yet conclusive) who claimed to be a prophetess at Kirtland. In the 1970 history, Ms. Hubble “declared herself a teacher for the Church. Because of her sanctimonious demeanor, many were deceived, being unable to detect her hypocrisy. The wiser members, having the spirit of discernment, readily discovered she was a counterfeit and uncovered her fraudulent intent.” Ms. Hubble appears on pages 170-71 of that history, and except for passing references to Joseph Smith’s female relatives seems to be the first woman to appear in the history. In the 1992 history she is “sanctimonious” and an “interloper”; in the 2005 history, she is a “rival” to Joseph Smith. Interestingly, although she is named in the text, she does not appear in the 1970 index, and in the 2005 history she is listed only as “Hubble” — she does not, therefore, figure into my earlier count of indexed women in those two histories (she is indexed as “Mrs. Hubble” in the 1992 history and so is correctly counted there).
Still another of the very few women to appear in early narrative Church history, and in a negative light, is Lucy Harris Harris (daughter of Rufus Harris, wife of Martin Harris). Lucy evidently opposed her husband’s assistance — especially his financial commitments — in the translation and publishing of the Book of Mormon. She demanded confirmation of the existence of the plates, going so far as to ransack the Smith home searching for them. ((Bushman, Rough Stone Rolling, 66.)) It was at Lucy’s insistence that Martin Harris asked to borrow the 116 pages of manuscript; when the manuscript was lost, it is Lucy who was suspected of having stolen it “with the intention of altering it.” ((Bushman, Rough Stone Rolling, 67.)) A wicked witch, surely.
In the first post of this series, I noted that among the women named in the indexes to Mormon histories were Ann Lee (founder of the Shaker movement) and Jemima Wilkinson (founder of western New York’s Jerusalem Community) – of the eight women named in the 1970 history, two of them were non-Mormon women. And make no mistake – these two non-Mormon religious reformers are not spoken of in Mormon histories as models of religious seeking. They are very much examples of the tendency to write women characters as wicked witches.
From the 1970 history, for example:
Ann Lee, once unhappily married to a village blacksmith, turned misogamist and taught her disciples that marriage was evil and should not be countenanced. In the Shaker communities the men and women lived in separate quarters, and the children born to couples prior to their acceptance of Shakerism belonged to all members.
As we come further forward in time, we find our written history dotted with the stories of Ann Eliza Webb Young, who divorced Brigham Young and went on the anti-Mormon lecture circuit … Lulu Loveland Shepard, the very popular anti-Mormon speaker from Pittsburgh who often donned temple robes to give her lectures … the Woman’s National Anti-Polygamy Society which raised funds to lobby Congress for anti-Mormon legislation … the National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union which fought the donation of silver to the Battleship Utah by the people of Utah, because a single piece of that silver was engraved with an image of the Brigham Young Monument … the many women’s groups who protested against the seating of Mormon apostle Reed Smoot in the U.S. Senate … the unnamed temptresses who were party to the downfall of missionaries abroad … the “selfish” girls and wives who kept their men at home rather than sending them on missions …
Wicked Witches are not, of course, the only women who appear in written Mormon history. In the next part of this short series, we’ll look at another role women have taken in our published histories.
The “She Shall Be an Ensign” series:
Women as Actors in Church History
Addendum
Wicked Witches
Damsels in Distress
The Princess in the Tower
The Heroine’s Journey
The History of the Church Told through the Lives of Its Women
Thanks for this, Ardis. I taught my seminary class about Emma Smith’s life and several students said they didn’t know why she got such a bad wrap. To quote one student, “her life SUCKED!”
Anyways, I love this series.
I grew up in the shadow of Kirtland in the 70s and 80s, and she was still pretty well celebrated in LDS seminary and Sunday School classes (she was treated like majesty by the RLDS tour guides at the temple).
I had an encounter with some social context for the “hell-going” this morning at the piano. I had dragged out a book I’d bought at Mount Vernon some years back, “George Washington: Music for the First President,” and was playing through the pieces for the heck of it.
I did not expect that the topic of several of the songs – clearly of the type to be sung at a pub – was how awful a predicament it was to have a wife. An example was “Of All the Simple Things” which last verse read like this:
Anyway, about the “hell-going”, I wonder if, when Joseph was reported to have said what he said about going to Hell to fetch Emma, it wasn’t meant or at least heard by the listeners in the context of the bar song (or its classical antecedent) “Orpheus & Euridyce,” as reported in this same songbook:
I just read the discourse you referenced “Emma Smith is one of the damnedest liars on earth!” accusing her of twice attempting to murder Joseph Smith by poison.3 ” It is on page 2378 in The Complete Discourses of Brigham Young” published by Signature. BY did say Emma tried to poison Joseph twice.
J, thanks for your support. Your students are far more sympathetic and empathic than my group was at their age.
queuno, you’re sure right about the RLDS (Community of Christ) respect for Emma, which never wavered. I’m glad you mentioned that.
Coffinberry, that’s an insight I haven’t seen anywhere before, and I love it. I honestly don’t know without research what the context was for Joseph saying that, if in fact he did say it, nor do I know how aware he would have been of classical myth. When I end up adopting your idea, I’ll remember to give you credit. 🙂
Something about well-behaved women rarely making the history books, comes to mind–but perhaps the next installment of this series will prove me wrong. 🙂
Our history wasn’t always very good at subtlety or nuance during my growing up years (60s). Mormon Enigma was probably my first real exposure to the New Mormon History, and while I know a lot of folks were scandalized or upset about it, my recollection is that it made everyone seem so…human. What a concept.
I am excited to see what comes out of this project. Surely, for Emma Smith, we can find some space between The Wicked Witch of the West, and Glinda the Good Witch of the North. As for the rest of the women in our history, let’s get their names, as a first step.
I heard of the “‘to hell and back” quote from Brigham and I’m about 10 years later than the demographic you suppose that view ended with. (Mormon Enigma was considered “anti” literature by my parents.)
I suppose there’s some relation between this archetype and Mother Eve. Most of the Mormon literature emphasizing that we should honor Eve for partaking of the forbidden fruit is of fairly recent provenance.
As for witches in Modern history, can we add the (obviously non-Mormon) fortune teller in the 1820s who was consulted by the mob to find the plates and told them to look in the coopers shop?
I believe the idea of giving Emma an “out” was taking hold when I started really paying attention to stories about her and, I’ll admit, it has colored my view of her ever since. One thing I’ve observed over the years is that we humans like reasons. We need to be able to make sense of what we perceive to be senseless. Therefore, Emma had to be suffering from “x” in order to make the choices that she did; right? The problem is that the motivations we try to give to the actions of others are way too simplistic. There is so much more nuance to every story.
We humans also like our villains. Somebody needs to be responsible certain circumstances happening the way they did. Thomas Marsh was an Apostle, the president of the quorum for goodness sake. He wouldn’t have gone to the lengths he did over an argument concerning milk strippings unless Elizabeth Marsh (thank you for reminding me of her name) was pushing the agenda; right? That seems to take away his complicity. I don’t think I’ve ever come across an account of this story which claimed that she put the quill in his hand when he wrote and signed his “affidavit” and gave it to the Missourians.
Lucy Harris has always been an enigma to me—the only thing I’ve ever heard about her is her supposed role in the 116 page incident and her not liking Martin Harris giving money to Joseph Smith. Other than that, I know nothing of her. As for the other women, besides Ann Lee, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of them. This is why I keep coming back to this blog, because of the things I learn. Thank you. I look forward to the next installment.
We always learn from you, Ardis. Thank you for sharing.
“She was the woman who betrayed Joseph’s memory by marrying an adulterous non-Mormon.” I brought up a theory on another blog that sounded conspiratorial. I admittedly haven’t read Enigma or any other lengthy Emma bio’s. I noted she married Bidamon, and after 17 years of marriage to him, he slept with a widow, fathered a child, and supposedly Emma “took the child into her home and raised it as her own.” At this point, Emma was about 60 years old. Why wouldn’t the birth mother have raised her own child? And to top matters off, on her death bed Emma supposedly encouraged Bidamon to marry said widow, which he proceeded to do about a year after Emma’s death. So, we have Bidamon with a mistress at least (if not sooner) 17 years into their marriage, then he’s able to marry that mistress about 15 years later upon Emma’s death. I know we have things indicating Emma was anti-plural marriage, but it almost seems as if she was perfectly fine with Bidamon living a plural life (sans the actual plural marriage qualification) by actively sleeping with a mistress during their marriage. Am I missing something? What if, in fact, Emma was okay with plurality, and the RLDS buried the relationship between Emma, Bidamon and the widow/mistress so as to validate the RLDS faith?
Terrific stuff, Ardis. Thank you.
Steve, my only hesitation about accepting that Brigham said that — he was certainly capable of saying it! — is that this discourse, as recorded in the Signature set, is cobbled together from four or five sources, It wasn’t published in full at the time, and this interesting bit does not appear in the version that was published. I’m not quite sure where this bit came from and whether it’s reliable — the one place I’ve seen that discusses its origins refers to Brigham Young’s “private” copy which doesn’t make any sense to me. He didn’t write his talks out in advance, so every record was one made by some clerk or observer. Perhaps the clerk gave a copy to Brigham to revise before publication — still, it isn’t like Brigham had a personal set of original notes, and there isn’t anything like that in his office files. Perhaps this is a reference to the Church minutes collection, or the steno notes of the clerk who recorded it? In any case, the origin for this paragraph is still murky in my mind, so I hesitate to accept it without that qualification.
The response of all of you here is absolutely wonderful, as far as I’m concerned. Thank you all. It’s rewarding to see what you like, what you hope for, what you remember, as far as LDS history goes. I want to add to that.
Once again I’m thankful I had the mission presidents that I had. The second, with his wife, published “Women’s Voices: An Untold History of the Latter-day Saints, 1830-1900.” We were taught about lots of Mormon women, many whose stories still resonate with me almost 40 years later.
So, in addition to Emma we learned about (for example) women such as Lydia Goldthwaite Knight and Vilate Murray Kimball.
I’m not sure which of that book’s co-authors was your mission president’s wife, but either way, you lucked out!
I was born after the mid-70s, but I still got the “Emma as wicked witch” impression as a kid. I distinctly remember wondering how Joseph could have married such a horrible woman – as a prophet, wouldn’t he have recognized what she was? By the time I hit seminary and college, the depiction was much more sympathetic (clearly she must have suffered a nervous breakdown, poor girl). The pendulum has swung far to the adoration side (especially in paintings and film). To be honest, having a younger generation grow up idolizing Emma actually complicates the reaction to historical polygamy – girls are much more likely to identify with Emma’s perspective.
I was born at the very tail end of the ’70s, and I think Emma’s reputation was being rehabilitated as I grew up. She was acknowledged, if not celebrated, exactly, as the first Relief Society president and creator of the first LDS hymnal, and in general, as someone who had to deal with a lot of really crummy situations. (Possibly because of my youth, the amount of said crumminess that had to do with polygamy wasn’t generally mentioned.) Pre-martyrdom, she was at least all right.
Post-martyrdom, there was general sympathy — she was never the villain of those stories, as they were told to me — but many people were happy to make Emma a foil to Mary Fielding, who did everything right while Emma did everything wrong. It wasn’t until my later teens (mid-to-late ’90s) that I remember anyone suggesting that maybe the Church left Emma, instead of the other way around. It’s about that same time that I remember first noticing Emma appearing, glowing and saintly, on Ensign covers. Maybe I’m noticing a change that was strictly personal: I was paying more attention to the Ensign, and outgrowing the simplified church history stories we tell to kids. But it really seems to me as if Emma’s reputation shifted as I grew up.
Your timing seems right to me, Mary Ann and Mike R. It didn’t happen overnight — the aunt I mentioned in the post never did catch up and some of the adulation I see in artwork goes too far, IMO. There was quite a bit of shifting over that whole generation, in my observation.
I grew up at the same time you did, Ardis, but I didn’t remember hearing anything really negative about Emma Smith. Maybe it was simply because in my home I didn’t heart much negative about ANYBODY. My parents were always very good at suggesting that there were circumstances I didn’t understand, so I should withhold my judgement as God could judge quite well without my help.
As a result, the first time I ran into someone in Relief Society who passionately attacked Emma Smith, I was quite shocked. (This would have been the mid 80’s. Sorry, I guess I was raised in a bit of a bubble.)
My son was in charge of Elder’s Quorum lessons one year and taught a number of them from “Daughters in my Kingdom,” on the theory that if it was relevant to the women, it was relevant to the men. (Cambridge, MA). He said that he had looked into the Sister March and the milk strippings story, and he didn’t find any contemporary references to it. He wondered if it was sort of an after-the-fact explanation. I didn’t do the research myself. (That’s probably why he’s a professor and I’m not.) You would probably know more about that than either of us.
But all of this does tie into the rather bizarre but common idea that women are weak, foolish, inferior humans who are never-the-less capable of completely controlling the men around them and therefore should be held responsible for anything that goes wrong.
There are a number of things in this vein that I heard as a teenager that I now wish I could go back and point out the logical ramifications to the speaker and say, “Do you really, really mean that? Because if you do, you’re stupid.”
We need to put the views of Emma Smith into perspective. As people struggled with plural marriage in the 19th century, it was important to them to feel that they were following Joseph Smith’s example and doctrine. You can understand how it made them feel for Emma to say that Joseph Smith did not believe in plural marriage. If they believe her, it would have them question their commitment to the principle themselves and that their lives were a fraud.
I grew up in the 50’s & 60’s culture of the “wicked Emma” but always felt there was something wrong with that feeling. Years latter after obtaining a degree in History and becoming a genealogist I took some classes in historical law focusing on the rights, or rather the nonexistent -rights. of women pre 1921.
In 1844 a widow’s only right to anything, even her own clothes, was tied to her dower (not dowery) which was, in the best of cases, 1/3 of her husbands property after all debts had been paid. The following is a quote from the Wikipedia article on Emma Smith, “…Joseph had been trustee-in-trust for the church, as a result, his estate was entirely wrapped up with the finances of the church. Separating the church’s property and debts from Emma’s personal property and debts proved to be a long and potentially dangerous process for Emma and her family.” So Emma was in a very precarious situation legally. Non of her sons were close to legal age (21) so she had no protection if anyone were to come against her to recover any of the property tied up with the Church or her personal property.
She did exactly what any woman of sense would have done in that day and age, she married a man who was known as a friend but who did not have ties to the Church. The marriage protected both her children and her during what obviously was a long process.
Joseph and Emma’s marriage seems to have been a love match, but 2nd marriages in those day were almost always for legal protection of property and children’s inheritance. There may or may not have been any intimacy because of the nature of the agreements made at the time of the marriage.
As is often the case with human kind we too often look at others and judge them based on our own circumstances and view of life. Those of us who remember having our long standing credit cards canceled when we married, even though we still held the same job and were basically still the breadwinners in our families, can understand in a very small way how vulnerable Emma may have felt after Joseph’s death. Not only did she loose the love of her life but it put her in real jeopardy of loosing her children, her property, and leaving her destitute with no skills to support herself in a world where there was no Welfare.
Jeff, Kathleen, I really do appreciate your acknowledging the very real human difficulties involved on both sides in creating Emma’s longstanding reputation. Emma had good cause for her behavior, and Church members in Utah had legitimate reasons for their response to that.
We’re probably all relieved that a more complex view of Emma has replaced the earlier one-sided view … which all goes to support my point for this series that Emma, like other women, has been used more as a symbol than as a real person in our published histories, until the present generation.
Excellent work! I am old enough to remember the vilification of Emma as a staple of any church discussion on her. At minimum, there was always tongue-clucking over her faithlessness for breaking with the Brighamites, but at worst, there was the implication that she was an upstart with nefarious, selfish motives. Mormon Enigma certainly turned that notion on its ear.
Well written!
Ardis: This post is so timely, as a student in my women’s history course just brought this up yesterday. She heard from her mother about how Emma’s reputation was so heavily vilified as the mom remembers, but the daughter (my student) can’t remember any of those constructions of Emma. This was all in the context of our class discussion of the Minutes of the Female Relief Society of Nauvoo, and what was going on behind the scenes, including Emma’s struggles with Joseph’s polygamous marriages, the secrecy, and insider tensions and hurt that kept Emma from even attending the meetings of her own organization at times. The students were overwhelmingly sympathetic to Emma’s pain and trials during those two years– a backstory that has been neglected in our optimistic retelling of the founding of the Relief Society. Thank you for bringing attention to this!
Perhaps it is just a web rumor, but I recall reading something about how the milk strippings story was made up to discredit the Marsh family and cover up his disagreement with the other apostles over something.
Anyone else familiar with that?
John Hamer’s post at By Common Consent, and David G.’s followup at Juvenile Instructor, set the record straight about Thomas B. Marsh and Brigham Young and George A. Smith, posted during the last two rounds of Doctrine & Covenants Gospel Doctrine lessons.
Thank you so much for this post, Ardis. I remember very well being a young teenager in the 1950s and my mother telling me that Joseph said he’d go to hell for such a woman as Emma. And my Mom saying, “And he would have to go to hell to get her!”
I started reading Mormon Enigma but so far haven’t been able to get past the first few chapters. What challenges she faced during her life! Thank you as well to the commenters who pointed out what a difficult situation she was in as the widow of a controversial figure. I can imagine that once the shock and reality of her husband’s death sunk in, Emma had to figure out what she could do to protect her children.
I’m just finishing up that biography now. It does get into quite a bit of the nuance that usually doesn’t make it into discussions of her life, includes quite a bit about how the saints at the time viewed her, good, bad, and Brigham.
I took a history class called “Women in American History” from Val Avery about a year after Mormon Enigma was published. She was quite bitter at the time. She was disfellowshipped because of the book – mainly told she could make no mention of it in any church setting. She and her husband were also going through a divorce, largely because of the controversy that she had stirred up.
She was a tough lady! I’m glad to see that she is being recognized for her role in revising Emma’s reputation.
I wish I had known her — I met her once in a crowd, but that’s as far as my personal contact ever went. Both she and Linda needed to be tough, I suppose, to survive the criticism thrown their way. Neither was disfellowshipped, although they were barred for about a year (May 1985 to May 1986) from speaking about church history or about the book in Church settings only, a circumstance that gave rise to rumors of discipline. No restrictions on membership or fellowship were imposed.
If I were ever to be unfairly remembered, I could only hope for a team like these two women to restore my reputation!