In Our Ward: Lesson 17: “What Shall I Do that I May Inherit Eternal Life?”

Lesson 17: “What Shall I Do That I May Inherit Eternal Life?”

Mark 10
Luke 12, 14, 16

Purpose: To help class members understand that we must be willing to sacrifice the things of this world to obtain a place in the kingdom of heaven.

Lesson Development

1. Trusting in riches can keep a person out of the kingdom of God.
2. Seek heavenly, rather than earthly, treasures.
3. Followers of Christ must be willing to forsake all to be true disciples.
4. Seek spiritual wealth with enthusiasm and energy.

Scripture Discussion and Application

[Before class begins, write “The Kingdom of God” on the board.] The Kingdom of God – we can be a little vague about what we mean by that, thinking of the Kingdom of God as the current Church and our participation in it, or the Kingdom during the thousand years when Christ will reign personally on the earth, or the eventual Celestial Kingdom where those who have been judged worthy to live in the presence of God throughout eternity will dwell. But taking it all as a whole, what are some of the traits or qualities of the Kingdom of God? What kind of people do we need to become to be worthy of the Kingdom of God? [Accept any suggestions; list six or more suggestions – in one- or two-word terms – on the board. This needs to move quickly, so don’t allow discussion at this point, and settle for fewer suggestions if it drags.]

[Pick out two or more of the suggestions – but again, don’t let the discussion bog down here; this isn’t the point of the lesson but only a way to sneak in the backdoor and disarm the usual rationalization about money – and prompt a short discussion about whether or not we really believe what we say about the Kingdom of God.] Do you really believe that “every knee shall bow and every tongue confess that Jesus is the Christ”? Or will there always be people in the Kingdom of God why deny that? How about this one – “righteous” – Have you ever been in a classroom talking about righteousness and had anybody say, “Well, being righteous is okay for some, I suppose, but I think there will be evil people in the Celestial Kingdom, too, because ‘there must needs be opposition in all things’?” No? We all accept what the Lord has said, that “no unclean thing can enter the Kingdom of Heaven,” and we don’t feel any impulse to claim that he didn’t really mean that?

[With any luck, someone will have suggested something to do with money, or material possessions, or our obligations to care for each other. If so, select that suggestion; if not, simply ask:] What about this one? Have you ever heard anyone claim that Jesus didn’t really mean what he said when he told the rich young man to sell all that he had and give to the poor? Or that our obligation as Latter-day Saints is to help only worthy people, and then only as little as possible? Have you heard anyone get angry because he saw someone he knew was receiving welfare assistance bringing home a pizza? [Pause, and wait for comments. Depending on what those comment are, summarize them and say something like:] So, then, we believe that Jesus meant what he said about these other things [pointing to the keywords on the board that have been discussed] but we don’t believe he really meant what he said about money? or Why do we rationalize the truth of what Jesus taught about riches, but not these other things?

[Note: I’ve written this outline as though the point of these parables is uniformly to give to the poor, when of course it is not. Adapt this to suit whatever angle class suggestion takes: reliance on wealth rather than on God; covetousness; measuring the worth of ourselves or others in terms of wealth – anything might be just as appropriate. The point is to win support for taking Jesus’s teachings seriously, and do it early in the lesson in an impersonal way, to avoid having to do it in the event some class member tries to rationalize these teachings.]

Today’s lesson is drawn from Mark 10 and Luke 12, 14, and 16, all teachings and parables about the proper use of money. I hope as we discuss them, we can do so in a way that shows we take Jesus’s instruction seriously – or, if we can’t do that, that at least we will admit that we treat teachings about money one way, and teachings about everything else another way, and ask ourselves why that is so.

Let’s start with Luke, chapter 12, with a story that is less familiar than some of the other teachings having to do with money.

Luke 12: 13-15

13 ¶And one of the company said unto him, Master, speak to my brother, that he divide the inheritance with me.

14 And he said unto him, Man, who made me a judge or a divider over you?

15 And he said unto them, Take heed, and beware of covetousness: for a man’s life consisteth not in the abundance of the things which he possesseth.

The man in the crowd addresses Jesus as “Master” – or “teacher” or “rabbi” – and asks him to resolve a dispute. This man does not appear to be a close associate of Jesus – he is “one of the company, “one of the crowd.” Why would he address Jesus as “Rabbi” and ask him to settle the dispute? [A rabbi could be expected to know the law and to be able to judge wisely between rival claims.]

But Jesus declines to take the role of rabbi here. Why do you think that might be? [Perhaps because his mission is greater than that assumed for him by the man in the crowd.]

Look back at verse 1 of chapter 12. What is the atmosphere in which Jesus is trying to teach?

Luke 12: 1

1 In the mean time, when there were gathered together an innumerable multitude of people, insomuch that they trode one upon another, …

This is not an easy atmosphere in which to teach, is it? Instead of resolving a personal problem of one man in the crowd of thousands, Jesus instead chose to give a lesson that was applicable to everyone who heard him: “Take heed, and beware of covetousness.”

What is “covetousness”?

Jesus didn’t just tell the man to follow the law, or to be fair and just. He warned him against covetousness? Why do you suppose he brought that idea into the discussion?

Does this passage teach that Church members are required to give up legitimate claims under the law, in order to avoid covetousness?

A number of you brethren have served in bishoprics and other councils. I’m not asking you to break any confidences, but in your experience in general, how often do people come to local leaders and want them to resolve disputes over money? Is greed or covetousness very often a factor? What have you learned from your experiences in this area, about human nature and money? Do you have any generous counsel for class members in this regard?

At this point, Jesus tells the crowd a parable related to the men’s dispute over their inheritance.

Luke 12:16-21

16 And he spake a parable unto them, saying, The ground of a certain rich man brought forth plentifully:

17 And he thought within himself, saying, What shall I do, because I have no room where to bestow my fruits?

18 And he said, This will I do: I will pull down my barns, and build greater; and there will I bestow all my fruits and my goods.

19 And I will say to my soul, Soul, thou hast much goods laid up for many years; take thine ease, eat, drink, and be merry.

20 But God said unto him, Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee: then whose shall those things be, which thou hast provided?

21 So is he that layeth up treasure for himself, and is not rich toward God.

In what way is this parable related to the brothers’ dispute, and to covetousness?

Is it wrong to save and provide for your future, your family’s future?

How about that last verse, verse 21: “So is he that layeth up treasure for himself, and is not rich toward God.” What might Jesus have meant by “rich toward God”?

Is it impossible to both lay up treasure AND to be “rich toward God”?

As you think of your own life, or the lives of people you know well, what would be some warning signs that you care more about treasure than about being “rich toward God”?

Giving up covetousness, giving up our reliance on money as security, are not the only things Jesus Christ asks us to sacrifice in order to be his disciples. Let’s read another of his parables:

Luke 14:16-24:

16 Then said he unto him, A certain man made a great supper, and bade many:

17 And sent his servant at supper time to say to them that were bidden, Come; for all things are now ready.

18 And they all with one consent began to make excuse. The first said unto him, I have bought a piece of ground, and I must needs go and see it: I pray thee have me excused.

19 And another said, I have bought five yoke of oxen, and I go to prove them: I pray thee have me excused.

20 And another said, I have married a wife, and therefore I cannot come.

21 So that servant came, and shewed his lord these things. Then the master of the house being angry said to his servant, Go out quickly into the streets and lanes of the city, and bring in hither the poor, and the maimed, and the halt, and the blind.

22 And the servant said, Lord, it is done as thou hast commanded, and yet there is room.

23 And the lord said unto the servant, Go out into the highways and hedges, and compel them to come in, that my house may be filled.

24 For I say unto you, That none of those men which were bidden shall taste of my supper.

Although Jesus often explained his parables, this is one parable he left up to his listeners to interpret for ourselves, so let’s do that.

In our experience, when a man hosts a party – in this case, “a great supper” or feast – and invites guests ahead of time, who are the people the host invites to attend, normally?

Usually, when Jesus tells a story about a lord and his servants or his guests or his tenants, he intends “the lord” to represent the Lord – God the Father, or Jesus Christ as his son. If that’s the case in this parable, who are the friends and honored guests that the Lord invites to his table? [Israel, his chosen people, his friends who were supposed to know and love him.]

But instead of coming to the feast as invited, the guests prefer to tend to their own affairs.

If we apply this parable to the lives of modern-day Israel, what are some examples of how we sometimes insist on having things our own way rather than sacrificing our personal – and even trivial – activities to take advantage of the blessings God tries to offer us?

In the parable, when the lord’s friends refused to accept his invitation, the lord sent his servants out to “beat the bushes” — too “go out into the highways and hedges” – and bring in anyone they could find – the poor, the lane, the dirty, the pagan – to enjoy the blessings the lord had prepared.

There are three classes of people in this parable: the intended guests who refused to come; the outsiders who did not expect to be invited, but who were almost compelled to come and enjoy the feast; and the servants the Lord sent out to find those new guests. Which of these groups do you identify most strongly with? Why?

There comes a time when it’s too late to change your mind – notice that in the last verse of this parable, the Lord will not accept his original guests, even if they tried to come at the last minute: “For I say unto you, That none of those men which were bidden shall taste of my supper.”

Have we reached that point, yet, in the course of our lives or of the world, when it is too late to repent, and sacrifice our own will, in order to receive the blessings the Lord wants to offer us?

If you identify with the invited guests, what can you do to be sure you wake yourself up and accept the invitation before it is too late?

If you identify with the outsiders – the poor, the wounded – what can you do to take advantage of the unexpected invitation?

If you identify with the servants sent out to find new guests, what can you do to welcome those guests and make them feel comfortable at the Lord’s table?

I’d like to step out of the New Testament for a minute and into our own Church history, and tell you about a Latter-day Saint who read this parable and applied it very personally. She clearly saw herself in the role of the Lord’s servants.

Hettie Hilda Harper was 18 years old, what we would call today a Young Woman, although in England in the 1922 there wasn’t any such program in the industrial town where she lived. It was apparently a pretty tough neighborhood, where children were neglected and roamed the streets hungry and dirty, without being taught anything recognizable as good manners. Hettie’s mother died, leaving Hettie, her father, and two much younger sisters that Hettie felt responsible for raising. The family was LDS, but there were apparently no other Mormons in the area, except when missionaries would come through once every other week and hold a cottage meeting in the Harper home.

“Having a very strong testimony of the Gospel,” she once wrote, “with the Lord’s help, I commenced to teach [my sisters] the beautiful truths which made life worth living.” She had never heard of Primary, but she essentially reinvented it, holding classes in her home for her two little sisters and two of their best friends, in the afternoon after school. “We commenced our classes as the grown-ups, with hymn and prayer, then another hymn, followed by the lesson. … I taught them to pray vocally and to take part of the lesson.” The little girls loved the activity so much that they talked Hettie into holding class nearly every afternoon.

At the same time, Hettie tried her hardest to interest some of her own friends in attending the cottage meetings held by the missionaries. It didn’t work. “Most of my former friends deserted me and persecuted me because I tried to teach them the Gospel. My life would not have been worth living had it not been for my father and the few children, for at that time, when all was against us, we would gather in our little kitchen away from the world and sing and praise our maker for the knowledge we had of the restored gospel.”

The little girls spoke of their lessons with other friends, who asked if they could come, too. At first Hettie told them no, “for I was not fond of lots of children, and especially those living around for they appeared very ragged, dirty and ill mannered. Many times I had heard them swearing and fighting and I didn’t desire them in my home.”

But as the children clamored to come, Hettie’s own friends grew more distant. One day, as Hettie read the Bible for comfort, she “commenced reading of the man who invited his choicest friends to his wedding feast. I read how all his friends made excuses and how the man sent his servants to the by ways and hedges to gather in anyone who would come, that the house could be filled. Suddenly I thought of the rough children who pleaded to come in my home; then I thought of those whom I had been most desirous of sharing my treasures with – yet they wouldn’t come and partake.

“Then an idea came to me; I thought I’ll do as the man spoken of in the Bible. I’ll let anyone come to our feast who would like, that my house can be filled.

“As soon as my sisters told their school friends I had given them permission to come, the result was amazing, for they flocked to our house in droves. I was bewildered and didn’t know what on earth to do with them. We were used to peace and quiet, and here was about fifty children, shouting, swearing and laughing, and all determined to get side.

“I never remember seeing so many children wanting to go in a house at one time and I almost was terrified at the sight. There were boys and girls of all sizes and ages. … All were dirty and untidy, with rough hair and very bold faces. Some were eating great thick chunks of bread and jam.”

With the support of her father, Hettie regularly held two Primaries a day, with as many as 70 children at a time, crowded into her tiny house. By the time Hettie’s sisters were old enough to need a Beehive Girl program – which Hettie started – enough of the children and their parents had joined the Church that the mission organized a branch in their town.

Hettie Hilda Harper didn’t necessarily give up monetary wealth in order to follow the Savior, although I suppose there was inevitably some cost involved in what she did. What was she willing to sacrifice, though, to be a disciple?

Probably few if any of you have ever heard of Hettie before – disciples are not often famous for their good works. Does Hettie remind you of anyone in our ward or stake whom you would like to mention, with or without name, who are “rich toward God” because they have been willing to sacrifice temporal concerns for heavenly ones?

We’ll close by reading the story that we most often talk about when we talk about sacrificing the things of this world.

Mark 10: 17-22:

17 ¶And when he was gone forth into the way, there came one running, and kneeled to him, and asked him, Good Master, what shall I do that I may inherit eternal life?

18 And Jesus said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God.

19 Thou knowest the commandments, Do not commit adultery, Do not kill, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Defraud not, Honour thy father and mother.

20 And he answered and said unto him, Master, all these have I observed from my youth.

21 Then Jesus beholding him loved him, and said unto him, One thing thou lackest: go thy way, sell whatsoever thou hast, and give to the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven: and come, take up the cross, and follow me.

22 And he was sad at that saying, and went away grieved: for he had great possessions.

When Jesus counseled this rich young man to give away all his goods, what did he offer him in exchange? [Treasure in heaven.]

In what way does this young man correspond to the guests who were bidden to the supper, but who did not come?

Our last question of the day is one that I will not call on anyone to answer aloud. We’ll end our lesson with you think about this:

If you, individually, are not yet at the point where you would willingly sacrifice your worldly advantages – your money, your time, your skill, whatever it is you have to offer – what will it take to bring you to that point?

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "In Our Ward: Lesson 17: "What Shall I Do that I May Inherit Eternal Life?"." Keepapitchin.org, 17 May 2015, https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/17/in-our-ward-lesson-17/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2015, May 17). In Our Ward: Lesson 17: "What Shall I Do that I May Inherit Eternal Life?". Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/17/in-our-ward-lesson-17/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/17/in-our-ward-lesson-17/">In Our Ward: Lesson 17: "What Shall I Do that I May Inherit Eternal Life?"</a>

8 thoughts on “In Our Ward: Lesson 17: “What Shall I Do that I May Inherit Eternal Life?””

  1. I read something not too long ago refuting the “eye of the needle” story about it being a Jerusalem gate as being untrue. I thought it was you or Julie Smith but haven’t been able to find the reference. I wanted it because our Gospel Doctrine teacher today brought up that story as true. Was it in one of your lessons?

  2. Not me — Julie mentioned it here, linking to an Ensign article. I think Benjamin the Scribe may also have mentioned it, but if so I can’t find the link immediately.

    Hard to know what to do as a class member when someone brings up a story you know isn’t true — even if you’d had the Ensign link handy, I mean, it would still be awkward.

  3. It is awkward. I usually try to bring it up myself, before anyone else gets the chance, and quickly refute it and move on, so as not to embarrass anyone who is trying to contribute.

  4. Amy, that’s the tack I took to ward off what I’ve seen too often in this kind of lesson: the tendency to dismiss the teachings about money by listing all the exceptions anybody thinks there should be to what Jesus said. I hoped if I brought it up first, nobody would dare bring it up in a way that I couldn’t deflect. (It almost worked, by the way — only one woman tried to raise an exception, and it so happened that I could let me eyes slide to the woman behind her who was also trying to comment, and we never got back to the problematic one.)

    It’s even harder when you’re a class member, like Sharee, and it’s the teacher who teaches an error. I suppose most or all of the time we just let it slide, if it isn’t critical.

  5. I’m occasionally tempted by the Luke Skywalker approach: “No! That’s not true!” I usually save my outrage for the political comments, though. The person telling the story about the gate is usually trying to make a decent point about casting off worldly possessions, becoming humble, etc. (Anyone who is just trying to say the wealthy can be saved is better off reading a couple verses down to “With men this is impossible; but with God all things are possible” instead of telling a story about a camel that has to drop all its burdens.)

    So, if the teacher lets the story slide (or actually teaches it) I’ve sometimes taken the approach of acknowledging the point, but refuting the story from the text itself (less awkward, I think, than the article-as-proof approach). Something like this: “We do need to be humble to be saved. I have reason to doubt that story though. When Jesus says ‘It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle,’ the disciples’ reaction isn’t sensible, as if a camel going through the ‘eye of a needle’ gate is something they’ve all seen in Jerusalem. The way the disciples react — ‘well, who in the world can be saved, then?’ — makes it sound like Jesus just said something that sounds impossible. This isn’t a case where the disciples misunderstand; Jesus himself agrees that it’s impossible — maybe not for God, but it’s impossible for us to be saved on our own terms.”

    Other times, of course, I just let it slide, roll my eyes, and mutter “citation needed” to my neighbor. It’s also possible that my approach is just as awkward as anything else you could say. (I don’t have a particularly well-calibrated awkwardness meter, as it turns out.)

  6. Mike R., you never come across as arrogant or belligerent, the way some are when they contradict somebody else. I think with your usual courteous tone and support for the point the teacher was actually trying to make, your approach could work very, very well.

  7. I really like your approach, Mike. I’m going to have to work on being charitable (and smooth) enough to respond that way when I’m the student.

    Ardis, that was what I really appreciated about your lesson–you structured it in such a way that no one could object, by the time you got to the most controversial passage, you had everyone taking Jesus’ words seriously by force of logic. It was really brilliant. I’m teaching the same lesson in two weeks and I’ve been worrying about how I could keep the class from devolving into endless rounds of “but he didn’t really mean that” or “but that doesn’t apply to me!” Your solution is so elegant, I am in awe.

  8. If you think to do it, Amy, I’d love to have you comment here after you’ve taught, on how you handled that problem. The more experiences, the better this can be as a resource for teaching in the future.

Comments are closed.