She Shall Be an Ensign: Women as Actors in Church History

A 1983 Friend article asks its young readers, “Can you identify these women in Church history? Match the descriptions with the names.”

The women:

1. Eliza R. Snow
2. Aurelia Spencer Rogers
3. Romania Bunnell Pratt
4. Emma Hale Smith
5. Lucy Mack Smith
6. Martha Hughes Cannon
7. Elmina Shephard [sic] Taylor

The descriptions:

a. First woman in United States to be elected a state senator
b. Mother of first prophet in this dispensation
c. First president of the Young Women
d. President of the first Primary
e. First president of the Relief Society
f. Well-known poet and author
g. First woman medical doctor in Utah

The answers:

(1) f, (2) d, (3) g, (4) e, (5) b, (6) a, (7) c.

How did you do? Would you have realized Elmina Shepard Taylor’s maiden name was misspelled if I hadn’t flagged it for you?

Brittany Chapman, co-editor of the marvelous series Women of Faith (with three volumes published, a fourth due out in a few months, and even more on the drawing table), tells about an informal survey she and some colleagues made last year, asking adults attending Gospel Doctrine classes to name five women from Church history. Most couldn’t come up with five names. Of those they remembered, the most frequently listed were Emma Smith, Eliza R. Snow, and “that woman with the cow and the milk strippings.”

How would you do – can you name five women from Church history? Could you have done it without the lists already appearing in this post? Could your family members do it? Your ward members? (Keepa’ninnies are not your average Latter-day Saints with regard to knowledge of history, of course …)

Since the 1970s, Mormon historians, especially its women historians, have made a special effort to study women and bring the lives of Latter-day Saint women of the past back to the awareness of the Church. We have done this primarily in two ways:

First, through biography, either collected biographies like Women of Faith, the best current example; or through biographies of individual women, like Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith by Linda King Newell and Val Tippetts Avery; or through studies of the works of individual women, like Eliza R. Snow: The Complete Poetry, edited by Jill Mulvay Derr and Karen Lynn Davidson. Lavina Fielding Anderson’s Lucy’s Book, the very best edition of Lucy Mack Smith’s history of Joseph Smith, might also be described as an “examination of women’s work” – the raising and observation of her prophet-son – as much as an autobiography by Lucy.

Second, through organizational history, like the official Church publication Daughters in My Kingdom, and Women of Covenant by Jill Mulvay Derr, Janath Russell Cannon, and Maureen Ursenbach Beecher. Even while focusing on the institution of the Relief Society, the lives and roles of individual women receive considerable attention in such histories.

When it comes to telling the history of the Church as a whole, though, rather than a history specifically of women or of women’s auxiliaries, women tend to … well, fade into the background, if they appear at all:

The index to Ivan J. Barrett’s 1970 Joseph Smith and the Restoration: A History of the LDS Church to 1846, which was the text used in my Church History class at BYU in about 1980, names these women, and these women only:

Mary Fielding, receives one mention, which mention really has more to say about her brother than about Mary herself: “James Fielding, pastor of a church in Preston, having learned of the restoration of the gospel through letters received from his sisters, Mary and Mercy, exhorted his congregation …” Mercy, although mentioned just as [in]significantly as Mary, is not named in the index.

Mrs. John Johnson, whose crippled arm Joseph Smith healed, receives one paragraph where she doesn’t act herself, but is acted upon, by her husband, by Ezra Booth, and by Joseph Smith. “Mrs. Johnson” isn’t honored even with her own given name (Elsa), in either the index or the text.

Polly Knight, the ill woman who vowed to live until she reached Zion (she did), one mention, where she is identified as “Newel’s mother”; the text does give her a nice paragraph, where she speaks and acts for herself.

Ann Lee and Jemima Wilkinson, both non-Mormon religious figures.

Mary Elizabeth Rollins and her sister (who is neither named in the text nor included in the index) appear in a brief but nice handling of their rescue of the unbound sheets of the Book of Commandments from the sacking of the Mormon print shop.

Emma Hale Smith and Lucy Mack Smith are both listed with several mentions; the references to Emma’s role in Church history are numerous enough that her index entry is subdivided into seven topics.

The Relief Society also appears in the index, pointing to two places in the text.

That’s it. Eight women are named in the index. In contrast, 96 men are named there, not counting references to male groups like “Three Witnesses” or “Council of Fifty.”

1992’s second edition of The Story of the Latter-day Saints by James B. Allen and Glen M. Leonard does a little better than the 1970 book: 54 women are named in the index (overwhelmed by 569 named men). Many of those women – like Mrs. Rutherford B. Hayes, Mrs. Martin Harris, Mrs. Benjamin B. Ferris, Mrs. John Johnson – again! – are denied their personal names. Many other women are mentioned in passing, as half a married couple: Helvecio and Ruda Martins, Rendell and Rachel Mabey, Edward and Elsie Dharmarajuy.

By 2005, Richard Lyman Bushman’s Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling (primarily a biography, but doubling as a history of the Church in its first generation), lists 86 women in its index (( That is, if I counted correctly; women are – properly – cross-referenced under maiden and married names, and I may have counted some women twice. )) Most of these women do not actually do anything to contribute to the mission of the Church, though; they are named because they are sisters or plural wives of Joseph Smith, or because they are family members of other significant men, sitting, as it were, on the wagon seats next to the men as they ride into Church history: “Her younger sister, Elizabeth Ann [Page], would later marry Oliver Cowdery” – the “her,” Catherine Whitmer, is likewise not an actor in the narrative, but simply a relative of a male actor: “Hiram Page was the Whitmers’ son-in-law, the husband of their daughter Catherine.”

In that same index, I count 478 men listed by name (not counting groups, such as “First Presidency” or “Twelve Apostles”).

In the 1970 history, about 7% of the named and indexed persons were women (that’s 14 men named for every woman mentioned). In the 1992 history, about 8.7% of the named and indexed persons were women. In the 2005 history, the relative number of named and indexed women has climbed to 15% (7 men named for every woman mentioned). That’s, uh, progress – although, as mentioned, not all references are created equal: Far, far more of the men are named to acknowledge active roles, if only for a brief moment, in the history of the Church. The vast majority of the women named would seem to have made little contribution to Church history beyond being members of men’s households.

Ziff at Zelophehad’s Daughters helped me with this post by constructing this graph, showing the relative appearance (or non-appearance) of women in the recent standard histories of the Church.

.

.

His calculations show that, should the present trend continue, we can expect to see a Church history featuring roughly equal numbers of male and female participants in the year 2189.

When women do appear as actors in Church history, not merely as family members of men but as active participants in Church history, how do they usually appear? That’s next in this short series.

The “She Shall Be an Ensign” series:

Women as Actors in Church History
Addendum
Wicked Witches
Damsels in Distress
The Princess in the Tower
The Heroine’s Journey
The History of the Church Told through the Lives of Its Women

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "She Shall Be an Ensign: Women as Actors in Church History." Keepapitchin.org, 15 May 2015, https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/15/she-shall-be-an-ensign-women-as-actors-in-church-history/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2015, May 15). She Shall Be an Ensign: Women as Actors in Church History. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/15/she-shall-be-an-ensign-women-as-actors-in-church-history/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/05/15/she-shall-be-an-ensign-women-as-actors-in-church-history/">She Shall Be an Ensign: Women as Actors in Church History</a>

19 thoughts on “She Shall Be an Ensign: Women as Actors in Church History”

  1. I remember the feeling of shock when I was working on the biography of Annie Chidester and learned that Mary Parker Chidester was one of the members of Zion’s Camp. Furthermore, not only did she go every step of the way, she also did so with two toddlers.

    It was dismaying to realize that as familiar as I was with Church history, I had no clue there were women involved in Zion’s Camp. So, yes, I agree that there is a problem, and, yes, it should be noticed and addressed.

  2. Yes, there is a problem. A couple of issues with which I am familiar shed some light on this issue. When I did my article on the 1873 colonization effort to Arizona, there were only five women, and over one hundred men on that journey. I only know the names of two of them, Charlotte King, and Lark Stevens. I could find no names for the other three. This seems typical of many of the vanguard colonization efforts, where the ratio of men to women is considerably skewed.

    In my article about Siberia, we were able to find lots of letters home from the men to their wives and mothers, but it appears that none of the letters written by wives and other women were kept by the soldiers or their families. My own father-in-law doesn’t have any of the letters his wife (girlfriend at the time) wrote him during WWII, but she kept all his letters home.

    And FYI, I knew five of the seven names correctly, but I can name quite a few more Mormon women from church history, much of it thanks to the efforts here at Keepa to tell women’s stories.

    To some extent, we are victims of our culture. Men don’t keep things, but wives, mothers, and sweethearts do.

  3. The LDS church got its start in inner city Boston in the early 1980’s when 4 black Carribean American women who worked together as nurses took a vacation to Washington, Dc. They toured the visitors center at the Washington Temple in Maryland. They contacted the church to ask where the nearest services were held and found that it was a long distance away. They begged for something closer, so meetings were held once a month, then twice a month, and finally weekly. These women dragged their husbands, children, and friends kicking and screaming into the church and kept them thee. The unit became an official branch in 1985. My time there was challenging-partly because I wasn’t yet confident enough to call stewards to repentance. As the church grew, these quiet sisters stepped back into the shadows, and I’m afraid that some local church leaders didn’t ever realize what they had accomplished. These sisters have now gone on their their rewards, which I trust will be considerable. But the lovely chapel, the wards and branches, and the temple just outside of Boston are there because of Lillian Smith and Esther Corbin.

  4. Women in Church history–say prior to WWII?

    Kirtland/Nauvoo era I can think of only three of the top of my head.
    *Lucy Mack Smith
    *Emma Smith
    * Mary Fielding Smith
    Oh, and the non-corrolated Fanny Alger.

    Early Utah, another three
    * Aurelia Rogers
    * Eliza Snow
    * Jane Manning (who has never apeared in anything corrolated, methinks)

    And late 1800’s (tilts heavily into the “approved” list of general relief society presidents)
    * Emmaline Wells
    * Bathsheba Smith
    * Elizabeth McCune

    And famous for complex polygamy relationships.
    * Helen Mar Kimball
    * Zina D. H. S. Young

    THere’s a few other nameless ones I could come up with. In addition to “the women with the strippings” I’d add
    “The woman who healed her son at Haun’s Mill”.

    I didn’t even recognize the Pratt, Cannon, and Taylor in the original list.

    How far beyond the year 2200 do we have to go until women can rise to the height of their own stature, and not because of their married surname? (Did you notice that only three of the 15 women in this comment were not married to a member of the Q12?)

  5. Is the problem that we overlook women’s contributions to “history?”

    Or that there are fewer women noted because they didn’t make nearly as much contribution to “history?”

    I think there is some of the first, but more of the second. Which means the linear projection above is wrong. We’ll never reach parity in the telling of history because there wasn’t parity in the making of “history.”

    Or is the real issue that our idea of “history” is wrong, that maybe we’re focusing on the wrong things?

    I think this is the genius of Keepapitchinin — the recognition that history is about the “little people,” too. It’s about the ordinary folk that don’t get written up in the history books, but whose stories are powerful and important just the same. With this view, women are (at least) at parity in the making of history, and should be (at least) at parity in the telling.

  6. Lindberg, I think that’s a great insight, since with women precluded from the priesthood/administrative offices, the most highly visible church positions and biggest decisions will always be male-centric.

    That said, the second part of your comment reminds me of Neal A. Maxwell’s quote:

    We are accustomed to focusing on the men of God because theirs is the priesthood and leadership line. But paralleling that authority line is a stream of righteous influence reflecting the remarkable women of God… The story of the women of God, is, for now, an untold drama… [but] when the real history of mankind is fully disclosed, will it feature the echoes of gunfire or the shaping sound of lullabies? The great armistices made by military men or the peacemaking of women in homes and in neighborhoods? Will what happened in cradles and kitchens prove to be more controlling than what happened in congresses?

  7. My score on the quiz was -3; I missed Pratt, Cannon, and Taylor. I know about Cannon, but I mistook her for the first medical doctor. I felt slightly smug about knowing Aurelia Rogers, but continuing on through your list of recommended books which includes many that I haven’t read makes me humble again. There are many that I haven’t read, and a couple I’ve never heard of. I need to improve my scholarship. I’m only an amateur, but still. Thanks for the valuable recommendations.

    I’ll continue to try to not be discouraged and cynical about our invisibility. It’s been this way for centuries, and it doesn’t keep us from salvation. (Does it?) In my imagination the Lord has seen fit to record of the lost parts of history, some of us would find it most fascinating.

  8. I love this discussion — thank you all for contributing.

    This is all leading to something that will become clear in about ten days.

    Lindbergh and TOClark draw attention to an important point: If by “history” we mean a record of the institutional development of the Church, then it will necessarily be overwhelmingly male. But if we’re talking about the Church, about Zion, and the history of its people, then women’s stories ought to be included a lot more often than they are, and in different ways than they have been represented. When I note the date of 2189 as being the possible expected point of parity, I don’t mean to suggest that numbers need to be precisely even … but I will argue with anyone who insists that 15% adequately reflects the significant contribution of women in Church history!

  9. Because I have pioneer ancestors, the history or the church and the history of my family are rather connected in my mind. And surprisingly enough, in my family history women and men achieve parity in every generation.

  10. I remember sitting in MWHIT being shocked at the presentation; then being surprised with myself that I was shocked. Bc: it’s subconsciously known to all of us. Thanks for your great work, keepa.

  11. Hi Ardis and Everyone, I’m late to this conversation. I read the post when it first appeared and then the ensuing comments. I think of my own family’s history in the Church and realize it’s women-centric. The main characters are all women–except for a polygamous great-grandfather who first abandoned his plural wife (my great-grandmother) at the Manifesto, then continued to father children with her. The women kept the diaries, autobiographies, thinly veiled “novels,” … the history. That’s what my history is composed primarily of: women’s narratives. So the post and graph leaves me very sad.

  12. Two comments. First, it would be great if some of the conversation that was happening elsewhere about this post, including Facebook, would migrate over here. (Thinking specifically about discussion of the graph.)

    Second, I find Laura and Gary’s comments interesting. I’d suspect that representation would be specific to the origin and personality of any given family.

    For example, take two large early Mormon families, George and Ann Prior Jarvis, and John Tanner and his family. George and Ann came from strongly matriarchal East London, and subsequent family history efforts are consequently very balanced, remembering pretty much everyone in the family equally.

    The Tanners, on the other hand, are a strongly patriarchal family, and with the largest family history efforts of the 20th century headed by George S. Tanner, N. Eldon Tanner, Hugh B. Brown, and the rest of the gang, you’d barely know there were women involved, except for Louisa Maria, since she had the distinction of being married to an apostle.

    So, family histories may fall anywhere on the spectrum, but it would be hard to make a case that community and church histories have been anything but entirely male-centric. (I can back this up with additional numbers if any of you is so bored that you want to know how histories of Washington County, Utah, have included or ignored women’s experiences. Hint: the percentages look pretty much like the ones Ardis found, including materials written fairly recently.)

  13. Amy T, I’m surprised that you consider the Tanners a strongly patriarchal family when it comes to Church/family history. Isn’t this the same group that is tied into “The Four Zinas“?

    Gender and Mormonism is such a minefield.

  14. An LDS-owned book publisher asked me to write a baby-naming book featuring names from The Book of Mormon. They were shocked when I informed them only six women were mentioned in the book, so it wouldn’t be very thick. I expanded it to include the Bible. Not much improvement. Other religions holy scriptures. Ditto. Greek mythology. A bit better. Norse mythology-much better. Those vikings had to depend upon everyone, so the female got a fair shake. Still, I had to leave out many male names and really scrape to come up with a whole book of baby names.

Comments are closed.