Late in 1891, future apostle James E. Talmage and his wife May Booth Talmage celebrated the arrival of a son, Paul. He was their second child; his older brother was named Sterling.
Several weeks later his Aunt Bessie (his father’s sister) wrote to Talmage to acknowledge Paul’s birth and to send a book as a gift. She asked Talmage why he hadn’t named either of his sons “James,” and reminded him that it was a longstanding Talmage family tradition to name a son for his father.
Talmage explained to his aunt why he had departed from that family custom (although he did give his third son, born in 1898, the name James). ((The Talmages also had daughters Zella, Elsie, Lucille, and Helen, and a fourth son, John.))
Care to speculate what his reasons were? I’ll post again late this afternoon with what he told his Aunt Bessie, but it could be fun to see what potential reasons we can come up with.
Ahem. Paul is a totally awesome name–surpassed only by Last. End of story.
Aha! My matchless powers of deduction begin to unravel the mystery of somebody’s pseudonym!
Something to do with deference to May?
As an aside, May is the sister of Joseph Wilford Booth, who spent so many years in the Turkish/Armenian Mission.
Because correcting a child while calling him by your own name is too strong a reminder that you’re probably responsible for most of what he has become and calling him a different name allows you to almost believe that it’s not your fault the kid turned out the way he did.
I like Mark’s idea.
Was his father named James?
My immediate assumption was that it’s because the confusion between father and son is inconvenient. But that’s probably too obvious to be correct.
Colorful, Mark, as always? 😀
Yes, Carol, James E. was son of James J., son of James E., son of James.
Wife’s grandfather?
To elaborate; sometimes names from the wife’s side are used more when the line is going to die out.
Second Nephi 3:15 puts a lot of pressure on a man to make sure he’s sharing his name with the right son. Wouldn’t want to mess up any unrevealed prophecies. Naming his third son Junior worked for Joseph Smith Sr.
The old traditional Scottish naming pattern goes: first son named after paternal grandfather; second son named after maternal grandfather; third son named after father. Thereafter sundry uncles get dibs. But I don’t think Talmage had any Scots blood…
Hmmm. Because he learned in writing JTC that James was really just Jacob?