These Were Their Questions

The other day I invited you to guess what kinds of questions Church members in the first half of the 20th century wrote to ask Church leaders – what was on the minds of Latter-day Saints of that era? While I haven’t kept anything like a statistical record, here is my subjective impression of the most frequently asked questions in the correspondence collections I have surveyed:

(It’s worth noting that many people wrote simply desiring to know the answer to their question, whatever the answer happened to be. Very often, though, it’s clear that some people had become embroiled in arguments in their families or wards and were looking for ammunition in the form of an endorsement from a General Authority, less for genuine information than for winning the argument. And in a small but significant number of cases, people really did try to set Church policy by calling on leaders to adopt and teach the letter writer’s personal philosophy.)

Without question, Word of Wisdom-related questions were the most frequently asked.

Sometimes these were simple requests for explanations (“What are ‘hot drinks’?”); other requests concerned the history of our understanding of the Word of Wisdom (“Section 89 doesn’t mention tea and coffee – why are they forbidden?”)

On only one point did questioners try to get around the provisions of the Word of Wisdom: Assuming that caffeine was the reason for the coffee-and-tea taboo, many people asked whether it was all right to drink Sanka or other decaffeinated versions of coffee. In every other instance that I can recall, people wrote seeming to want to expand the prohibitions contained in Section 89: Some advocated vegetarianism, or at least the avoidance of milk and eggs. A surprising (to me) number wanted support for their opinion that pork should not be eaten. Some wanted a ban or at least a curtailing of sugar in the diet. Others called for including all caffeinated sodas in the “banned” category. More than one person wrote practically demanding a complete list of all forbidden sodas.

There were other questions which, while not strictly concerning the Word of Wisdom, related to food and health: A number of people questioned whether it was healthy to use aluminum cookware, or whether fruits and vegetables should be eaten raw so as not to destroy vitamins in cooking. I remember a letter from one woman who practically demanded that the Church order its members not to can food, because canning destroyed the nutritive value of foods, and caused people to sin by eating fruits and herbs “out of season.”

This may be a surprise; I don’t think anyone guessed this: Sons of perdition. My subjective impression is that, barring only the Word of Wisdom, the preoccupation of Church members throughout the early 20th century is the matter of sons of perdition. A few people are afraid that they are sons of perdition, for some reason, or that someone they care about has become one. More people are curious about the future of sons of perdition – will they be dissolved as spirits and have to begin their eternal progress all over again, for instance. But by far the most common question starts, “My priesthood quorum was talking about sons of perdition last week, and we couldn’t agree on just how one becomes a son of perdition. Can you please tell us how someone becomes a son of perdition?” So far I haven’t seen any response from any Church leader that matches what my reply would be: “Why do you want to know? Is it your aspiration to become a son of perdition?” My jaw drops every time I come across another version of the sons of perdition question. It’s mind-boggling how many people seem to have obsessed about it.

Marriage. People had a lot of marriage-related questions. I’ve seen letters from both men and women asking whether it was wise to marry such-and-such a person, as if Church leaders had any way of advising people whom they had never met. Sometimes men wrote about the wisdom of marrying a widow sealed to a previous husband. Women (maybe men, but more often women) asked for advice on saving troubled marriages. I’ve been surprised by the number of people (almost always men) with questions about someone else’s second marriage (almost always the second marriage of a woman): “She was married in the temple; now she is widowed and is engaged to marry a non-member. Will she go to hell?” (Honest – they asked that!) Some people wanted exceptions to policies about how soon after baptism they could go to the temple for marriage, or whether they could be married civilly and then a week or two later, when it was convenient, travel to a Utah temple for sealing.

“Status of the negro,” as it’s usually phrased. There aren’t all that many questions, but they do come along regularly throughout the era. There’s an interesting progression to the questions: Early in the century, people seem merely curious, as though it’s a purely theoretical question that came up in a Sunday School discussion. A little later, say, the 1930s, people’s questions become a little more academic – they want to know whether Moses was “married to a negress” or how the “seed of Cain” survived the Flood, or other specific questions. And then later, beginning immediately after World War II, people’s questions turn abruptly into civil rights questions – those who write do not like discrimination, and they ask how the Church can justify discrimination, and they want to know when it will end.

The location of the Lost Tribes is a frequent question – are they together in one body? Do they live at the North Pole? Are Church leaders secretly in touch with leaders of the Ten Tribes? (All of which questions amuse me, because people haven’t bothered to learn which tribes are “lost” – ever hear of Ephraim?) A related batch of questions has to do with British Israelism – did the Lost Tribes settle in England or Ireland?

Science-related questions, concerning evolution, pre-Adamites, and the age of the earth, were asked by a huge number of Latter-day Saints. You can see by the tone of the letters that many, many people are simply perplexed by what they’re learning in school or from reading magazines – they want help in reconciling what science was teaching them, and what they had either been explicitly taught in Church or merely assumed was Church doctrine. They aren’t often argumentative, and usually don’t seem to be in the midst of a faith crisis – they simply want to know how things fit together. There are some people who are argumentative and dogmatic on both sides of every question, who want Church leaders to bring everybody else in line with what they assume is the Church’s position. I think the tone of these questioning letters surprises me more than any other – people wrote for information long before they reached the point where they felt they had to choose between faith and reason.

Plural marriage. I cannot remember seeing a single question from an ordinary, active member of the Church with a question about plural marriage, either historic, or in the next life, or about current beliefs, beyond the simple question of whether or not the Manifesto came by revelation or by outside pressure. But there are a lot of questions about plural marriage from two different extremes: Fundamentalists wrote all the time, trying to justify their position, or to call General Authorities to repentance for their presumed apostasy in abandoning the practice. Members of the then-Reorganized Church (now Community of Christ) wrote just as often, condemning the “Utah church” for “lying” about Joseph Smith, for slandering his memory by claiming that LDS plural marriage began with Joseph Smith. (It fascinates me that people at both extremes – the extremes of “plural marriage should never have started,” and “plural marriage should never have ended” – were completely familiar with the Church’s position that Joseph Smith had practiced plural marriage. I have to believe that mainstream members of the Church in the first half of the 20th century were as familiar with Joseph Smith’s polygamy as the extremists were. I don’t know how that changed, so that learning of Joseph’s plural marriages was a complete surprise to so many members recently.)

Adam-God. That’s a big one, with lots of questions. Sometimes people ask questions as if they think they’re supposed to believe it and they need information to reconcile the idea with other things they believe; at other times, people only want to know whether Brigham Young ever taught it.

Tithing. I have seen surprisingly few questions about tithing – a few questions, now and then, about paying on gross or net, but that’s about it. Oh, there was one man who wanted a tithing discount due to depreciation of his dollars due to post-war inflation, but otherwise tithing calculations don’t appear to have been much on the minds of our grandparents’ generation.

Birth Control. Yup, another big one. Those questions take two forms – Young couples are asking whether, or how, to use birth control; local leaders are looking for books or other information on the technical aspects of birth control so they can advise the couples who come to them. There is both the assumption that the Church opposes birth control, and the assumption that of course it’s fine, but because family life is so important the Church should advise on planning of families. It’s an interesting duality.

Garments. I don’t think any commenter mentioned this, but it’s a frequent topic of questions. The Church hasn’t always had an official source for garments, and people had questions about whether this or that dealer was selling approved garments – apparently at one time some entrepreneur was manufacturing and misrepresenting as official a garment that was modified to have narrow shoulder straps rather than sleeves, and it took a while for the Church to stamp out the idea that those modifications were acceptable. During Workd War II lots of people questioned whether soldiers should wear the garment, in light of the fact that it would inevitably be exposed to view and perhaps ridicule  in barracks or field life. When the official pattern did change, people wrote to ask whether shortened sleeves and legs were in fact acceptable. Post World War II, people occasionally wrote to ask about laying off their garments for this or that activity. Quite a few people wrote to say they had been inactive, including laying off their garments, but were now wanting to reconnect with the Church and wondering whether they could just put on the garment again or whether they needed any kind of permission to do so.

Then there’s a huge body of questions that are not at all related to each other, but are similar in the fact that they ask for interpretations of some passage of scripture, or some term used in scripture. Sometimes people propose their own interpretations and seem to be seeking approval or support; at other times people are baffled and simply hope somebody can explain a verse for them.

To address some guesses from the earlier post which haven’t really turned up:

I don’t think I’ve ever seen a letter from someone asking whether they should confess such-and-such a sin to a bishop. I’ve seen people confess to this or that in mail to General Authorities – not often, though.

John Birch has never come up in the correspondence I’ve seen, but then, I don’t usually go much beyond 1950, and it’s possible that people asked for advice about that a few years later. I have seen quite a few political questions, not usually about specific candidates, but often about whether some proposed civil legislation is a good idea or not.

Haven’t seen many questions (pre-1950, at least) about “When are we getting a temple here?” I think perhaps the first half of the 20th century was a time when people hardly expected temples outside of Utah – even though Hawaii and Mesa and Cardston had been built. One exception to this is that some sisters – always sisters – in England were so certain that a temple would one day be built in England that they sent monetary donations to Salt Lake to be credited toward the building of that temple, decades before the London Temple was announced. That’s faith, I’d say.

Space race: I’ve seen exactly two letters where people asked about the possibility of going to space. One of those, I remember, was in 1950 – it sticks with me because it is so early.

Women’s roles. I don’t see many questions about that, either general questions or questions concerning specific activities. Very early in the century there were some questions about women and priesthood that sound very much like today’s discussion, but through most of my era that just doesn’t seem to come up.

Haven’t seen a single movie rating-related question, that I can recall. I’ve seen a few questions about whether moviegoing was an appropriate Sabbath activity, but otherwise people don’t appear too concerned about media in those years, unless it counts that many people want to know whether this or that Mormon-themed book has the endorsement of the Church, or not.

I also haven’t noticed anything like “where the church keeps the gold plates” – but I have seen queries about whether the Church has the sword of Laban.

Immigration. Yes, a big concern of the era, but not at all for the reason we see it concern people today. I don’t think I’ve seen any letters complaining about immigration, or asking the Church to do anything to curtail it. Quite a few people, though, following World War II, have questions about sponsoring European Church members who want to emigrate. They are either Europeans asking whether American Church members will sponsor them, or American Church members offering to sponsor complete strangers, as long as they were Church members.

War. Very few questions, before, during or after wars – a few people write to say that they’ve heard this or that General Authority had prophesied that World War II would end by such and such a date, and they want confirmation. I’ve also seen correspondence between General Authorities and personal friends who discuss the progress of a war, or their hopes for abolishing war, but that is more private discussion than the kind of questions we’re looking at here. A question or two about the League of Nations, and then about the United Nations, but not much.

Haven’t seen a single Mother in Heaven question. A number of questions about Book of Mormon geography, but otherwise nothing memorable about the Book of Mormon. Ditto Mountain Meadows – it’s mentioned occasionally, but I can’t recall any specific questions.

A few New Deal questions (and related questions about Canadian programs). People want to know if it’s okay to accept pensions and subsidies and other government payments. The flavor of those questions is that Church members don’t see any reason to decline government assistance when their own taxes are being paid to support such programs, but they just want to confirm that they aren’t going against Church policy by accepting those benefits.

Nothing that I can recall about Jackson County, or the Second Coming, or the sealed plates.

–oooOooo–

As I wrote in the earlier post, I like to keep general tabs on the questions people wrote to Church leaders. It helps me understand what was on the minds of Church members, and what was being discussed in classes and between neighbors (and sometimes rivals). I’m intrigued both by the questions that are still questions today, and the questions that barely register on our radar today.

Any surprises? Anything that I’ve missed in this post?

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "These Were Their Questions." Keepapitchin.org, 07 Jan 2015, https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/01/07/these-were-their-questions/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2015, Jan 07). These Were Their Questions. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/01/07/these-were-their-questions/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2015/01/07/these-were-their-questions/">These Were Their Questions</a>

19 thoughts on “These Were Their Questions”

  1. It would be interesting to know how these kinds of questions compare to questions asked post-1950. I suspect there’s considerable overlap. Thanks for keeping tabs on this, Ardis.

  2. The preoccupation with sons of perdition is surprising. I correctly predicted the absence of pre-1950 questions about movie rating; at least in America, there weren’t really movie ratings until the MPAA rating system replaced the Hays code in 1968.

  3. EmJen, I think it wasn’t this post. I think it was because I had an important work assignment to complete by 9:00 this morning, and all those sons of perdition and their friends were determined to distract me. But the work got done anyway (and it was GOOD work), and J. Max fixed Keepa.

  4. Is the sons of perdition a strictly male club? Is that why only men were asking about it? Is it possible for there to be a daughter of perdition. If not, why not? And is it a good thing or a bad thing?

    Oh, and please don’t attempt to answer these questions!!

  5. Why do you ask, Laura? I’ll bet you want to be president of the Distress Society of the Daughters of Perdition, don’t you!

  6. J. Max is good people. I assume you mean J. Max Wilson.

    ““Why do you want to know? Is it your aspiration to become a son of perdition?””

    The Sith in me snarkily wonders if they wanted to know how much sin they could get away with without being really damned.

  7. I’m not surprised by a lack of movie ratings questions pre-1960. I think the industry was entirely governed by the Hays Code before the late 60s. LDS sensibilities would have been most compatible with the Hays Code.

    I continue to be fascinated by LDS interest in the Word of Wisdom, the only section of the D&C which opens by explicitly declaring that it was not a commandment.

  8. “I don’t know how that changed, so that learning of Joseph’s plural marriages was a complete surprise to so many members recently.” I don’t know either, but I suspect that it has to do with older generations dying off, the rapid addition of new converts unfamiliar with that history, a correlated curriculum focusing on introductory material and praxis, the simmering down of LDS/RLDS feuding, the need to condemn apostate polygamous groups, and public relations successes distancing the Church’s reputation from polygamy.

    At least, when I compare Joseph F. Smith and Heber J. Grant to David O. Mckay and Gordon B. Hinckley, I’m unsurprised that Mormons earlier in the 20th century would have been more familiar with polygamy, including Joseph’s involvement

  9. I’d make it the Distaff Society of the Sons of Perdition.

    And, speaking of Sons of Perdition, I remember attending priesthood meeting with my dad in southern Utah County, sometime in the mid-1990s, where the topic (in the HP group) was “Will Sons of Perdition be resurrected?” My dad thought it was a ridiculous way to spend an hour of our lives (and I didn’t disagree).

  10. My husband believes that attending an HP quorum meeting is a ridiculous way to spend an hour of his life. Fortunately he plays the piano, so he spends that time in the Primary with a group he finds more congenial.

  11. I’m waiting for Deseret Book’s “Perdition: A Step-by-Step Guide for HP Quorums.” That would be a big seller.

    ps- Glad J. Max got you back up.

  12. I may be wrong, but it appears that some of the questions caused language in some of the Handbooks that would be produced later, i.e. word of wisdom, marriage, birth control, tithing. Also, that Beehive is the only authorized distributor for temple garments.

  13. David R, I’m absolutely certain you are right. People act as though the Handbook were a constitution, written in advance to control what happens later. But I am certain that the Handbook is the end result of endless questions answered by endless personal letters. At some point, somebody said, “Hey, we should compile the answers to all these questions so we can just point to them rather than having to write individual letters every time it comes up again in the future.”

  14. Great and fascinating article. As usual, I’ll drag in Orson Scott Card (Saintspeak, 1980):

    son of perdition — Judging from the fact that the Lord hasn’t mentioned any daughters of perdition, this looks like one more position that only men can hold.

    I joined the Church in 1967 at age 14 (only member in my family) and knew very quickly that Joseph Smith had practiced polygamy; as you note, it was a bone of contention between the LDS and RLDS Churches, so the Church certainly wasn’t doing anything to hide or downplay it — quite the contrary.

    A lot of these other issues were still being kicked around at that time. In fact, in the 60s and 70s, the Church was apparently getting so many requests for the “official Church stance” on so many topics (home birth, astrology, etc.), that they finally said, in effect, “Look, you have brains and the Holy Ghost — figure it out yourselves.” I think that may have been the impetus both behind the abolishing of the Priesthood Bulletin and the announcing of the 3-fold (now 4-fold) mission of the Church.

  15. Heh. I find myself thinking of the 1931 First Presidency letter that said “Leave geology, biology, archaeology and anthropology, no one of which has to do with the salvation of the souls of mankind, to scientific research, while we magnify our calling in the realm of the Church.”

    In other words: The General Authorities are busy doing the work of the Church. Quit pestering them with questions about geology, biology, archaeology, and anthropology. Go find a scientist instead.

    It seems like those four areas, at least, ought to have been in the realm of “Look, you have brains and the Holy Ghost — figure it out yourselves.”

  16. I’m late to the party, but I loved this post so much! Thanks so much Ardis, for compiling these questions and pulling out the big themes. What a fascinating read!

Comments are closed.