The Case of the Infant Elder

In 1890, a boy – past his eighth birthday, but not yet baptized – fell gravely ill in Fountain Green, Utah. Doctors told his parents that he could not live. His parents were beside themselves. What would happen to their unbaptized son? They sent for the elders … but not for the reason you might expect. Oh, they undoubtedly did ask for a healing blessing, but they asked for something more …

-oOo-

Ever since I began doing work in Mormon history, I have focused on collections of correspondence, beginning with the letters received (and to a much lesser extent, letters sent) by Brigham Young. People wrote and clerks saved thousands upon thousands of letters, which add up to a fascinating and thorough picture of Church history during those years, coming, as they did, from all kinds of people and all kinds of places with every kind of problem or report or request. I’ve continued to search correspondence collections of church leaders, missionaries, and “ordinary folks” whose papers have ended up in the various archives to which I have access – nothing, to me, is more thrilling than the discovery of another collection. Opening the first box, turning the first pages, anticipating what I’ll find – okay, I get goosebumps just thinking about the possibilities. If you didn’t already know it, I’m a little odd. Or maybe a lot odd. Anyhoo –

One pattern I’ve noticed in correspondence is that when someone – anyone, man or woman, general authority or local leader – gets a reputation for having “the answers,” Latter-day Saints write to that person in droves, asking doctrinal and historical questions. Usually, I’m more interested in the questions people ask than in the answers that are written – answers tend to be remarkably stable over the decades, reflecting what any of us would expect to be said according to our familiarity with Church teachings. The questions, though, reflect what is on the minds of the Saints, and are sometimes surprising. Quite possibly the four most frequent queries of the 20th century have been “What is the status of the negro?” “Am I at risk for becoming a Son of Perdition?” “Is Coca-Cola against the Word of Wisdom?” and “Is my sister/daughter/friend [always a woman] going to hell because she was widowed after a temple marriage and then married a non-Mormon?”

Sometimes letter writers give the background of their questions, and sometimes that background exposes some odd practices that have cropped up in corners of the Church. These kinds of questions, more than any other, have taught me the greatest respect for Church leaders who respond: It’s one thing to recite a well-worn answer to a well-worn question. It’s another thing to correct a developing practice that could threaten the purity of doctrine and the stability of the Church.

Back to 1890, in Fountain Green, and the apparent deathbed of that young boy.

Believing their son to be dying, unable to have him baptized due to the severity of his illness, his parents still wanted to make some provision for his future life. Apparently not sufficiently versed in the doctrine of temple ordinances for the dead, but reasoning that in order to be “a priest to the Most High” a man required ordination to the priesthood, the parents asked the elders to ordain their dying son an elder.

This was not an isolated occurrence – I’ve seen at this time multiple reports of dying boys being ordained – although, of course, by our understanding, the practice was completely unnecessary and violated now-well-established principles (among them, that ordinations to the Melchizedek priesthood are directed at the stake level and require presentation of the candidate for approval). So, in accordance with his parents’ wishes, the dying eight-year-old was ordained an elder. No harm, no foul, right? If it was an unnecessary, even improper, ordinance, there would be no harmful aftereffects, right?

Except that the boy didn’t die. He recovered. Then he was baptized, and reordained an elder, in the apparent belief that the first ordination was proper but not quite regular since the child hadn’t yet been baptized.

Now comes the sticky point. His parents presented their priesthood-bearing eight-year-old to the local Elders Quorum and expected him to be received there and treated as a full member of the Quorum.

Quorum members objected, writing to Salt Lake leaders to ask, “Where the Authority is, ore where Can such be found in the writeing of the Church and by Whom, and where is the legality of such Action?”

As mentioned above, this was not the only such instance of a young boy, even a male baby, being ordained on his apparent deathbed, in the mistaken belief that such ordination would be of value to the child after death. It isn’t the only case of an infant Elder who recovered, and then claimed membership in a quorum. But the case is one of those that brought the budding, unauthorized practice to the attention of General Authorities, who eventually ended it, so effectively that I’ve seen no trace of it in the 20th century.

I wonder what I’m going to find in a correspondence collection today …

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "The Case of the Infant Elder." Keepapitchin.org, 16 Dec 2014, https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/12/16/the-case-of-the-infant-elder/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2014, Dec 16). The Case of the Infant Elder. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/12/16/the-case-of-the-infant-elder/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/12/16/the-case-of-the-infant-elder/">The Case of the Infant Elder</a>

17 thoughts on “The Case of the Infant Elder”

  1. This happened to a relative of one of my ancestors (last name of Powell) who, when a young man, was hunting on Mount Nebo in Utah, & got horribly mauled by a grizzly bear (which, I was told, as a child, actually tore off the young man’s face- which of course, is just the sort of story we young children reveled in- the more gruesome, the better) but didn’t immediately die from his injuries. In fact he lived thru the night & was subsequently was ordained an Elder, perhaps in the hope of making things easier for him in the afterlife. He died the next day. Every time any of my family drives past amount Nebo (usually on our way to Disneyland) we invariably tell the ‘grizzly’ story of the ‘Grizzly & the Elder.’

  2. All sorts of curious things happening in Sanpete. Glad they put the kibosh on that practice.

    That’s a great story, Ardis!

  3. This fits right in with the tired old joke about the unruly boy in Primary being calmed–to the point of sleeping through class–by being ordained a high priest.

  4. I absolutely love this. The Q12 and FP took this up a number of times, and concluded that while the practice was fine, surviving children should proceed through regular ordinations as they would have had they not been ordained on their near deathbed.

  5. Actually, you’re not that odd. I can still recall the excitement of my mission president as he recounted how, while digging in some church archive, he found in some uncatalogued folder a piece of the shirt Joseph wore at Carthage. FYI it was yellow.

  6. I think this is a good illustration of the divine purpose motivating the often maligned ‘correlation’.

  7. You continue to amaze me with the stories you find. I envy you being able to comb through all of those files.

  8. “The Case of the Infant Elder”

    Wasn’t that an early Conan-Doyle/Sherlock Holmes novelette?

    Ardis, your research is always unique and eye-opening. Thanks for sharing it with us.

  9. My great grandfather was endowed at age 13 in 1878. I don’t know the ultimate source of the explanation, but I remember my father saying that it was because he was quite ill, and it was thought that the endowment might help his recovery. I don’t know if it was a required practice at the time for him to have been ordained an elder before being endowed. After a very cursory search, I couldn’t find an ordination date for him.

    Just now, looking to see what the internet knows, I saw that some of his siblings were also endowed as young teenagers. A 15-year-old sister is listed as having been endowed the same day he was. It’s possible that they were both sick, though it does make me wonder if receiving the endowment at a very young age was simply a common practice of the time, and not necessarily related to health.

  10. Left Field, I’ve seen other similar early ordinances from that same generation — Indianna Mary Maybert, the unfortunate adopted daughter of Brigham Young, was a 15-year-old when she was endowed in St. George in 1878, which is so very similar to your examples that I’m tempted to think we’ve discovered a pattern, even thought I don’t know for certain how common that was. But then as well as now I think a young man would have had to have been ordained — the temple makes no sense without Melchizedek priesthood, no?

  11. There were a number of young teenagers who went through the temple in 1877-1878 in St. George. I think I mentioned them in the biography of Lucy Bigelow Bunch. Yes, link here, although the mention is quite brief.

    Left Field, assuming the endowment took place in St. George, your father’s explanation may be an attempt to explain a practice he didn’t understand and that didn’t last very long, rather than him actually passing down information preserved through the generations. I’ve seen people make similar attempts to explain adoptive sealings that show up in the records, since many people don’t understand that practice, either.

  12. Amy T, verily. Though going to the temple to access the temple healers or baptism for the dead would be a normal thing. I know of a girl who was endowed at 14 in the 1930s because her patriarchal blessing said to. That is an extreme outlier.

  13. Before I thought about the timeline, I was imagining it being done in the Endowment House, since my people were in Morgan County, and my great-grandfather was born there. However, after my great-great-grandfather died in 1868, his two widows took their family (including my great-grandfather as a child) to Orderville and joined the United Order. So the St. George Temple would’ve been where he was endowed.

    Aside from the vagaries of my own memory of what my father told me a few decades ago, there’s no telling where the information came from. Dad knew his grandfather, but he died when my father was eight, so it seems unlikely that he got the story directly from him. My father did a lot of oral history recordings of his father and some of his siblings, so it could be something he got from one of them, though there’s still a question about whether they had accurate information as well. On the other hand, being endowed at a young age for his health is not mutually exclusive with being endowed at a young age because it was a common practice at the time. But it doesn’t seem like the poor health story is necessary to explain it.

    It does seem like there was a lot of it going around at the time, and not just in my family. Perhaps they were so excited to have a new temple that they wanted everybody to go. I had considered if young endowments might have been a United Order thing, but neither Maybert nor Bunch had any connection to the Order that I could see.

Comments are closed.