Guest Post: Hitler and Mormon Art

Glen Nelson of Mormon Artists Group finds a fascinating story about a Mormon’s musical reaction to the world of Nazi Germany. You can sign up through the above link to have a newsletter with Glen’s articles delivered to your email box.

-oooOooo-

In 1930, an American Mormon student in Oldenburg, Germany shook hands and chatted with Hitler. Out of curiosity, Wendell Cannon Irvine of Salt Lake City, Utah had attended a large Fascist rally on a Saturday afternoon in October, and then he returned to his hotel. A few hours later, when he went down to supper, he learned that Hitler was staying in the same hotel, and jokingly, he mentioned that he’d like to meet “this Herr Hitler.” A few minutes later, Hitler strode through the lobby, and the hotel attendant interrupted the procession to introduce “a young American scholar.”

Irvine recounted the experience in an article that appeared in The Improvement Era the following November (all the Church’s early magazines have been scanned and are available for viewing at archive.org. Here’s a link to “Adolf Hitler: The Man and His Ideas”). The article is interesting for many reasons, but principally because it documents an early Mormon encounter with a terribly evil human being.

Today, readers of the article want to know whether the author was as mesmerized by Hitler as many Germans were. We wonder how the dictator was described and if the author was able, in 1930, to predict the horrors that were to follow.

The 28-year old Irvine admits that he had witnessed a powerful display of oratory, but to his credit, he sees through it. Here is a paragraph toward the end of the article:

And so today, this “man without a country” goes eternally “stumping,” expounding his doctrines of anti-everything except the Dictatorship of Adolf Hitler. He has 5,000,000 followers in Germany, who, when they are not occupied in having street brawls with Communists, are aiding in the furtherance of the Hitler program. Hitler says: “Disenfranchise the Jews; execute the profiteers; expel the dirty alien; repudiate Versailles and reparations; abolish department stores and force trade back to the small merchants; wipe away parasitical unearned incomes; BE GERMANS!”—and these thoughts are echoed throughout all of Germany by the five million adherents of the Hitler faith. Hunger and depression stimulate them, and the silver tongue of a political fanatic acts as a drug upon their confused minds and bodies.” (The Improvement Era, Nov. 1931, p. 55)

But this is a newsletter about Art. What has this glimpse of history to do with it? I thought of Irvine this week as I read another account of Nazi Germany as seen by a young Mormon artist, this one by Leroy Robertson, one of the great composers in Mormon culture.

In the winter of 1933, Robertson was studying in Berlin. At the same time, a friend named J. J. Keeler joined him from Leipzig, where he had been studying the organ. Hitler was named chancellor in January, and a few weeks later, the Reichstag was set ablaze, and Nazi storm troopers swarmed through the capital.

Leroy and J. J. witnessed the terror up close because they were staying in a Jewish neighborhood. They stood helpless as shopkeepers’ businesses were looted and destroyed, and as families were hauled away in the night. The two Mormons were mistaken as Jews and harassed as well, but they managed to escape. Robertson, who was on sabbatical leave from teaching at BYU, decided to stay and finish his work, but Keeler left for London.

When Robertson heard that Hitler would be speaking at a large arena in Berlin, he determined to witness for himself this man. Robertson and an LDS missionary serving in the city fabricated press passes to sneak by the S. S. guards. They posed as reporters of The Improvement Era, and they took copies of the Church magazine as proof. Checkpoint after checkpoint they passed anxiously. At each blockade the two men showed their homemade credentials. Their forgeries were impressive enough that Robertson and his comrade ended up on the front row of the press box, directly above Hitler’s podium.

This story is told by Robertson’s daughter Marian Robertson Wilson in the best biography I know of a Mormon composer, Leroy Robertson Music Giant from the Rockies (Blue Ribbon Publications, Salt Lake City, Utah, 1996), a superb account of the composer’s public and personal life.

Wilson writes: “Hearing Hitler at such close range repelled Leroy and awakened in him a dreadful foreboding as to what lay ahead. This contempt and fear he continually expressed in several compositions dating from this time.” (Wilson, p. 102)

How does the experience of Nazi Germany manifest itself in American Mormon music? An important example is Robertson’s “Etude in G minor for Pianoforte,” (1933). It was composed in a single burst on a Berlin street, with paper balanced on Robertson’s knee, “…he began to write as quickly as he could, oblivious to all else. The music came almost faster than he could notate it. When he breathlessly ceased writing a scant few minutes later, he had composed, nonstop, from beginning to end…which he never changed a single note thereafter.” (Wilson, pp. 102-103).

A recording of the etude is included in the 1995 CD “Leroy Robertson, A Treasury of Chamber Music,” performed by Matthew Robertson. It is an agitated, restless, and dramatic work. In it, you will hear the turmoil of a city ready to burst into flames. You owe it to yourself to take a listen. (It is listed as Concert Etude #2.)

Often, we think about Mormon art as a vehicle for uplift and prettiness. To me, those limitations gut the potential power of art. As strongly as any Mormon work I can think of, Robertson’s concert etude and the stunning “Quintet in A Minor for Piano and String Quartet” (1936), begun at the same time, embody a different kind of thinking—a probing, anxious, journey through the human condition in difficult times. And, if I dare go a bit further, I have to say that I listen to Robertson’s rapturous “The Lord’s Prayer” differently now, in light of his experiences in Berlin.

To say that Mormon art is about being exclusively positive makes little sense to me. Rather, great music is a product of the way we process what is happening to us in our lives viewed through a lens of creative art. No one listening to the roiling, nervous, and intense works of Robertson composed during this Berlin era can say they are sweet and pretty. What they are, it seems to me, combine into a brilliant—even triumphant—document of creation amid destruction, of good over evil.

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "Guest Post: Hitler and Mormon Art." Keepapitchin.org, 13 Nov 2014, https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/11/13/guest-post-hitler-and-mormon-art/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2014, Nov 13). Guest Post: Hitler and Mormon Art. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/11/13/guest-post-hitler-and-mormon-art/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/11/13/guest-post-hitler-and-mormon-art/">Guest Post: Hitler and Mormon Art</a>

5 thoughts on “Guest Post: Hitler and Mormon Art”

  1. I had never thought of LDS music as positive or negative, more uplifting (or failing to uplift, in some cases), but this is a fascinating explanation and example of how it isn’t just one thing or the other, it is, as you say, about a “journey through the human condition”, with all its attendant emotions. Thanks, Glen, for an eye-opening post.

  2. “the best biography I know of a Mormon composer”

    That’s rather slim pickings. But thanks for the recommendation; I just put a copy in my shopping cart.

    And thanks for sharing this insight into Robertson’s music. Something to remember next time we do a Robertson hymn in church.

  3. I didn’t turn my head at “Hitlerites”–I don’t think it was uncommon, especially before the war. Its close relative “Hitlerism” was also common–I just found an article in the March 1932 Atlantic Monthly entitled “Hitler and Hitlerism–Man of Destiny.”

    I suspect that if I looked longer, I could find some Churchillian references to Hitlerism.

    As to the original post: Thanks, Glen.

    J.J. Keeler returned to the United States, joined the music faculty at BYU, and was still there during the 1960s when I first became aware of the place. The old tabernacle organ was then in the Auditorium of the Joseph Smith Building, and Bro. Keeler didn’t allow anyone other than his students to touch it. So our BYU student ward had organists assigned to it, who didn’t live within the ward boundaries. (It made for some fabulous music!)

  4. Excellent Post. I am a musician and I learned something new about Leroy Robertson today. Thank you.

Comments are closed.