The Trials of Cora Birdsall: part 5

The bishop’s court directed Cora to deed her meadow to James E. Leavitt for $100, on 1 November 1901, giving her until 15 November to comply or appeal to the stake high council. Instead, she immediately appealed to the First Presidency, who responded on November 12 that the correct procedure was to take her case before the stake high council. Cora delayed doing so, until in September 1902, her stake president gave her a deadline: She must appeal to the high council later that month, or – Well, he gave her a deadline, but did not specify what would happen should she miss that deadline.

Cora did finally appeal. Whether she delayed her appeal yet again, or whether the council couldn’t schedule her case in September, we cannot know. But her appeal was finally heard before the stake high council, at the Tabernacle in Richfield, on 21 October 1902. The court convened at 4:00 p.m.

In case you had ancestors there at that time, you may want to check the officers for familiar names: William H. Seegmiller, Joseph S. Horne, and James Christiansen, stake presidency; Jacob M. Lauritzen, clerk; and high councilmen O.A. Andelin, Andrew Poulsen, Hans Christensen, Poul Poulsen, Thomas Ogden, Simon Christensen, Lauritz Lauritzen, Peter E. Westman, Morten Jensen, Joseph H. Thurber, Niels P. Petersen, and Gottlieb Ence – a nice mix of Danes, Englishmen, and a Swiss, pretty well representative of the population of Sevier County.

The council quickly moved through preliminary items: roll call, prayer (by Hans Christensen), and a note that both Cora Birdsall and James E. Leavitt were present. President Seegmiller read Leavitt’s original complaint, and Bishop Magleby’s decision.

Then the council considered the complexity of the case. Section 102 of the Doctrine and Covenants, in outlining the conduct of high councils met as courts, notes three levels of complexity: not difficult, difficult, or more difficult. The difference matters only in that either 2, or 4, or 6 high councilmen are appointed to speak, either to ask questions or to speak on behalf of the parties should a councilman feel that a party’s rights or dignity were at risk. In this case, the council decided the case was “a difficult one,” acknowledging that it wasn’t a clear-cut case of provable fact, but neither was it so complex that it would take the wisdom of a Solomon to arrive at a solution. Four councilmen (Lauritzen, Westman, Jensen, and Thurber) were appointed speakers.

The court considered whether the appeal could go forward without the presence of Isaac Birdsall – he had refused to come to this hearing, as he had refused to attend the bishop’s court. They decided it was not necessary for Isaac to be there.

Leavitt first “made a statement of what he expected to prove” – how interesting it would be to have his verbatim words, or at a least of summary, of his expectations! But we have only this notation in the minutes. Someone asked whether he was willing to abide by the court’s decision – as an ex-member of the Church, the court had no authority over him, no leverage to apply if he did not choose to follow the court’s direction. They accepted his word that he was willing. (My question is – what did he have to lose? He had no right to the land according to civil law; the worst thing that could happen, from his point of view, would be for the church court to agree with federal laws, telling him he had no right to the land. He was risking nothing.)

Cora also made a statement about what she expected to prove. The court did not ask her whether she would abide by their decision – as a member of the Church, it was expected that she would obey the council. And if she did not, she had her membership, or at least her good standing in the Church, that the court could withdraw.

The first witness at this trial, as at the bishop’s court, was Hulda J. Leavitt, wife of James E. Leavitt. I still do not understand why she was permitted to testify. Her testimony is nothing but hearsay – what does it show except what she could only have heard from her husband? He was there – what value is Hulda’s testimony?

(I am posting the testimony as recorded for all witnesses, partly so you can feel like you were there in the courtroom, but also so that if you spot something that I have missed – something in Hulda’s testimony that is not hearsay, for instance – you can point it out. My natural sympathy lies with Cora, and I need your help to be sure I’m being fair to Leavitt.)

Hulda J. Leavitt, witness on the part of the accuser, testified:

Leavitt turned out two cows to apply on the deed. I knew the cows. The pasture was fenced and we lived there and used the pasture since 1883.

Question by Morten Jensen: Did you live on the land or adjoining it? – Answer. We lived near the land.

Did you know that the land was in Birdsall’s entry and that he was to deed it to Leavitt? – Answer. Yes.

Do you know if you had the use of the land after Cora Birdsall filed on it? – Answer. I think we did.

Was Leavitt allowed to move the fence? – Answer. No.

Was he allowed to move a certain ice house on the land? – Answer. He was not.

Question by Joseph H. Thurber: What kind of a house was it that Bro. Leavitt was to have moved? – Answer. It was an ice house built of logs.

Was there any corrals on the land which Leavitt got from Birdsall? – Answer. I am not sure.

Question by Simon Christensen: Did you ever hear a conversation between Leavitt and Birdsall about the land? – Answer. I heard them talk about the cows.

Neighbor James W. Parker was the next witness. He testified that Leavitt was using the meadow when Isaac Birdsall filed a claim on it, described the improvements Leavitt had made, and reported a conversation he claimed to have had with Cora, that “she expected to do what was right about the land,” but what that “right” was is not recorded in the minutes. Beyond those points, he, too, seems to be a hearsay witness – he may not really have known exactly when Isaac claimed the land; he was not a party to any agreements between Isaac and Leavitt as to whether two cattle were paid by Leavitt as land rent – Cora’s claim – or as payment toward future ownership – Leavitt’s claim.

Parker’s testimony:

J.W. Parker, witness on the part of the accuser, testified:

I remember when Leavitt bought the land from Kent Farnsworth. Farnsworth went on the land and lived there till the fall of 1885. In the spring of 1886 I moved on the land and lived there during the summer. Leavitt let me have the use of the land for fencing part of it. It was good pasture land, being part meadow. I had the use of the farming land and pasture for sowing lucern and fencing. In 1895 Leavitt was using the land. Isaac Birdsall first took the land under the timber-culture act. The river runs on the east side of the land. The corral is on the land next to the road. There is an ice house on the land. While Isaac Birdsall had the land entered James E. Leavitt was in possession. Leavitt put up on one side 80 rods of fence and on the north and 60 rods and an additional 60 rods. The fence consisted of three wires and one pole. Leavitt used the land for pasture – cut no hay.

Question by Morten Jensen. You understood that the land was in the Birdsall entry? – Answer. Yes; Cora set out some trees about three years ago and she told me she expected to do what was right about the land. Isaac Birdsall had permitted his entry to lapse and his daughter Cora had entered the land at that time. By agreement the river was on the line and the land on the west was Leavitt’s and that on the east was Birdsall’s. When cattle belonging to either party got across the line they would be driven back.

Question by Jos. H. Thurber. Were the cattle turned out by Leavitt to pay for the use of the land or to apply on the deed? – Answer. I understood that the cattle were to apply on the deed.

Question. What would the fence be worth put up, Leavitt? – Answer. About 40 cents per rod. The ice house and part of the corral was on the land in dispute. The corral and ice house were put up by Leavitt.

The next witness called was Charles A. Leavitt, brother to James E. Leavitt. His testimony, although it sounds straightforward, is a little muddled. He doesn’t get dates right, for one thing – He recalls that Isaac needed money to “prove up” on his claim two years before Isaac actually asked for it; that confusion in dates makes it appear as though the two cows were paid in response to Isaac’s request for cash (i.e., as purchase money for the land) – but the cattle were paid long before Isaac needed to prove up. In fact, cattle would have been useless to Isaac as an aid to proving up – he couldn’t turn cattle in to the Land Office, and couldn’t have sold them for cash any more readily than Leavitt could.

The most telling question, in my opinion, is the final one by O.A. Andelin: Why did Leavitt want to remove his fence and icehouse? Charles Leavitt didn’t know (this was another hearsay question anyway) – but if Leavitt owned the land, as he claimed to, why would he have wanted to remove his fence? He did not remove the fence (but later testimony would show that he did want to, but Cora would not let him – he did not remove his improvements by her deadline, and she claimed it had been abandoned).

Testimony of Charles A. Leavitt:

I have been personally acquainted with this land for fourteen years. James E. Leavitt had the use of the land. Birdsall and Leavitt kept cattle each on his own land. In 1892 I rented the pasture and used it. Birdsall never questioned my right. Leavitt was away from home and Birdsall asked me when he would return, as he (Birdsall) needed money to prove up. Leavitt wrote me to raise the money at the bank, and I reported to Birdsall. I helped my brother drive two cows to Birdsall and deliver them to him, and my brother told me he was turning them out on a deed to the land. One cow returned and Leavitt traded a harness to Birdsall for the cow.

I never knew about any dispute regarding the land till Cora Birdsall got possession of the land. My brother told me that Cora Birdsall forbid him taking the ice house and the corral off the land.

Question by Morten Jensen. When were the cows delivered to Birdsall? – Answer. Eleven or twelve years ago. In 1892 Birdsall came and asked me for money to prove up.

Question by P.E. Westman. Were the cows turned out in payment of the land or as rent for the use of the land? – Answer. I don’t know. I understood that it was in payment of the land. The land in dispute was claimed at first by Frank and Kent Farnsworth, who sold it to James E. Leavitt. Birdsall got possession of the land by filing on it.

Question by O.A. Andelin. Why did your brother desire to remove the improvements form the land? – Answer. I don’t know. Did he ever remove the fence? – Answer. No.

The court took a dinner break, and reconvened at 8:00 p.m., when Cora’s side of the question was heard.

Cora’s first witness was her mother.

Testimony of Mary Birdsall:

When we came to Utah we were not Mormons. We came in 1881. We did not know it was the custom of one person to take up land for another. We wrote to the land office in 1881 or 1882 and found that the land was vacant. We took the land under the timber-culture act. Leavitt never made any arrangements with Isaac Birdsall for the land. Isaac Birdsall needed money to prove up, and he offered to give Leavitt some land for the amount needed, which was about $225. I remember of one cow being found on the premises, but it was returned. The harness was given in payment of pasturage.

Leavitt was notified by Birdsall not to put any improvements on the land. I don’t think the corral is on the ground. The only offer that was ever made was to give land for money to prove up.

My husband’s time to make proof expired without proof being made. Cora Birdsall paid Leavitt for the fence on the north side of the land. She then told Leavitt to take his other improvements off the land. The fence on the east side was put up while Birdsall was away and without his knowledge. Leavitt did not occupy the land, as it was used by other people just the same as by him.

Other people who had occupied the land as squatters were intimidated and Birdsall was not inclined to be very strict about the use of the land. Isaac Birdsall first entered the land under the timber-culture act ten years ago, but the trees would not grow, and he then entered the land under the preemption act, but never made proof under either act. Leavitt and another party came to see about getting the land, but my husband told me that he never made any arrangement with them.

Question. Is it not a fact that Leavitt had exclusive control of the land on the west side of the river? – Answer. Not with our consent. Leavitt’s brother talked with Birdsall about furnishing money to prove up and Birdsall agreed to accept the money and deed him the land, but Leavitt never furnished any money.

Question. Did Leavitt’s horses ever come over on the east side of the river? – Answer. Yes; and other animals.

Question. Did you not tell him to keep them on the west side? – Answer. We told him to keep them off the trees.

Question by Simon Christensen. How much did Cora Birdsall pay for the fence? – Answer. Fifteen dollars.

Question. Is it not possible that your husband might have made an agreement with Leavitt that you have not heard of? – Answer. He told me he had not.

Question by Poul Poulsen. When did you learn that? Did your husband tell Leavitt when he needed the money? – Answer. Yes; he told him the time was short.

Question. Do you know how many acres of land Leavitt wanted? – Answer. They did not settle on anything, because Leavitt did not have the money. Cora Birdsall filed on the land, I think, in 1893.

Question. When did Birdsall send the note to Leavitt to not put improvements on the land? – Answer. In 1883.

Question. Were improvements placed on the land after that? – Answer. Yes; a fence was put up by Leavitt to keep the cattle from the trees.

Question by Jos. S. Horne. If the land was public pasture did anyone ever pay for the use of the land except Leavitt? – Answer. One man offered to do so.

Question. Who was that man? – Answer. Mr. Barney. But we did not claim anything.

Question by Andrew Poulsen. How much was the harness worth? – Answer. About $25.00.

Question by Simon Christensen. What land was Leavitt to have for furnishing the money to prove up? – Answer. The land on the west side of the river.

Question by Hans Christensen. What kind of land is it? – Answer. Good land.

Question. And you only charged one set of harness for the use of it? – Answer. We never considered he had the use of the land.

Question. Why did you fence along the river and not around all the land? – Answer. We just fenced what we were cultivating.

Question. Is it not a fact that Leavitt had the use of the land for twelve years? – Answer. I don’t know that he had possession of the land at all.

Question. He was not ordered off, nor were his cattle stray-pounded on the west side of the river? – Answer. I can’t call to mind that they were.

Question by William H. Seegmiller. Were you present when Leavitt came over to see about furnishing money to prove up the land? – Answer. Yes; I was in the house when Birdsall went to see about the money. He wanted me to go with him to see what was said. He might have had an understanding with Leavitt and I not know it.

Question by Jas. Christiansen. How much money would it take to prove up on the land? – Answer. About $125.00.

Question. Did Leavitt agree to furnish this? – Answer. I so understood.

Question. And yet the amount of the land he was to have was not agreed upon? Answer. Not that I know of, only that it was to be land on the west side of the river. We settled on land near Monroe and also at Salt Lake City, and moved off because others claimed it, while we might have filed on it.

Next witness, Elsie Birdsall Taylor – Cora’s younger sister and my (widowed) great-grandmother. She didn’t know much to add.

Elsie Taylor, witness on the part of the accused, testified as follows; When we came to the place it was used for pasture by people all around there – used as a common herd ground. We did not know that anyone claimed it. I left home in 1890, and since then I know nothing about it. I don’t know Leavitt. I know my father entered the land under the timber-culture act. He settled on the land in 1881 or ‘2.

Question by Jos. S. Horne. Have you ever heard anything about Leavitt having any claim on this land? – Answer. No, sir.

That was all the testimony taken. The high councilmen appointed to speak for both sides gave their conclusions, but not one word of those arguments is recorded in the minutes.

Then Leavitt and Cora were allowed to make last statements.

Leavitt’s statement — accepted as he made it, without further questioning:

I bought Kent Farnsworth’s half interest in the south forty for $200.00 in 1883. A short time after I got notice from Birdsall that he claimed the land. I talked with Birdsall, and we decided on the east bank of the river for a line. Birdsall was to get forty acres in the Butler entry for eighty acres on the west side of the river. After this, Butler bought ten acres of the forty he was to deed to Birdsall from Birdsall. Butler and Birdsall had a falling out and Birdsall came to me and stated that he did not want the Butler forty, but if I would give him $150.00 I could have the land across the river on the west side. We agreed that the fence should be on the west side of the river.

I put up 160 rods of fence, three wires, and a pole. After the line was decided on I bought the other forty of Kent Farnsworth and later bought the other half of the first forty from Frank Farnsworth. I fenced on the east side of the river with a pole fence and it was partly washed away. I put up a wire fence on the west side of the river. The fence I sold to Cora Birdsall was on the north of the land. The south fence is about 37 rods long. Robert Ross has an interest in it. I was away when Birdsall wanted money to prove up. I wrote my brother and told him I was under no obligations to furnish money only for the deed, but I tried to raise the money anyway but could not. I offered to file on the land and deed him his if he would relinquish his entry, but he would not. Later Cora Birdsall filed on the land.

The money I paid to Cora Birdsall was paid as lease money in order not to invalidate her claim against the Government. This was done by agreement. In 1897 I was moving an ice house and she forbid me to move any of my property off the land. Some words followed. Later, Cora Birdsall came to my place and wanted to know how I felt about the land matter, and I told her that I felt that I had been robbed. She asked me to wait awhile. Later she came to my place and stayed over night and promised that she would do what was right. She had been counselled in the matter by her bishop. She said she was sorry she could not take counsel from her folks. When she got her patent she wanted me to come over and talk with her folks about the matter. A short time later I went over and she treated me with contempt, and has done so ever since. I told her I intended to press this matter in the church courts. She got her patent about four years ago.

Cora’s statement — actually, rebutting prior testimony, and interrupted by further questioning by the court; she does not appear to have been able to make a summary statement at all:

I can’t say anything about my father’s affairs. I don’t know anything about. Brother Parker said I said I was willing to do what was right about the land, which is not right. The fence on the east side of the river is 75 or 80 rods long. It does not run clear through. The fence on the north I bought from Leavitt. I also bought the fence on the south from Bro. Ross. I sent Leavitt notice in the fall of 1894 to move the fences off the land on the west side of the river. It was not so that I made a bargain with Leavitt about the land. When he did not remove his improvements, I thought they were mine, and I afterwards forbid him taking them.

What Leavitt stated about me promising to do what was right about the land is all false. I never talked with him about the land. I homesteaded the land. My expense did not exceed sixty dollars. He has talked to me about the land, but I never answered him.

Question by Pres. Seegmiller: You did not recognize Leavitt’s right to the land, but to the fence? How can you explain this? You don’t believe Leavitt had any right to that land? – Answer. No, sir.

Question by Simon Christensen. If you were placed in Leavitt’s place and paid for the land and possessed it, would you feel right if you were treated as he is? – Answer. Yes, sir.

What have you heard your father and mother say about this land question? – Answer. Nothing whatever.

Question by Hans Christensen. If Leavitt had entered the land in place of yourself when your father’s time expired and driven your father off from the other part of the land, would he be doing right? – Answer. Yes.

Question by Morten Jensen. Are you willing to do what is right about this land? – Answer. Yes.

How old are you? – Answer. Thirty-three.

The stake presidency then retired to consider the case. They issued their decision the next day, 22 October 1901.

Having read the testimony, how do you think they should have decided? Why? How do you think they did decide? Why?

(Part 1) (Part 2) (Part 3) (Part 4) (Part 5) (Part 6) (Part 7) (Part 8)

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "The Trials of Cora Birdsall: part 5." Keepapitchin.org, 01 Jul 2014, https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/07/01/the-trials-of-cora-birdsall-part-5/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2014, Jul 01). The Trials of Cora Birdsall: part 5. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/07/01/the-trials-of-cora-birdsall-part-5/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/07/01/the-trials-of-cora-birdsall-part-5/">The Trials of Cora Birdsall: part 5</a>

28 thoughts on “The Trials of Cora Birdsall: part 5”

  1. Ardis, There must be some kind of backstory regarding Leavitt and the other members of the court … something that might help to explain their apparent deference to his version of events. For the time being, I’m going to assume that the members of the court are all trying their best to figure out a fair, just solution. Still, it does seem that Cora is disadvantaged in several ways (e.g., single, being a woman, still having the ability to find a husband, etc.). Anybody else feel this way?

  2. I don’t know. It just gets more and more confusing, and I don’t envy that council.

    Why, though, did they re-hear the case? Was that the procedure for appeals from bishop’s courts in 1900? To hold a new trial, rather than simply reviewing the proceedings in the original trial?

  3. Why did they re-hear the case? I’m still stuck wondering why they heard it in the first place. This is 1902, not 1862.

  4. Gary, you have anticipated points I want to make in the next part, after reporting the outcome of this hearing. Like you, I think that everyone on the court was doing his very best to find out the truth about the two claims and any understandings that might have existed between the Leavitts and Birdsalls. I think they really tried to do what was right.

    But the sheer number of questions from such a number of questioners must have come at both Mary and Cora as a barrage. Neither of them were really businessmen or had engaged in anything like this before. They must have felt some deference to the council itself, and to the men who were church leaders — unlike Isaac, they both felt bound to respond to the church court system, which would have been an entirely novel, and, I think, frightening experience for them.

    In addition to all the handicaps you note, Gary, I have one to add: Most or all of the men on the council were farmers and landowners, whose own land claims could very well have been at risk if the Mormon custom of yielding land to prior claimants were not upheld. That would predispose them, I think, to supporting Leavitt’s claim.

    I don’t know why Leavitt let the church, or whether there was a formal severing, or what connections and relationships he may have had to others in the community, beyond his family and the few farmers whose testimony shows a working relationship. Possible reasons for deference may have been because he was a man conducting the same kind of business they were, and he was a long-time local man while the Birdsalls were still somewhat outsiders despite having lived in the valley for 20 years at this point — remember how the neighbor boys lynched Cora’s brother, for instance, and Isaac’s apparent alienation.

    Mark B., there isn’t much of a record of the testimony in the bishop’s court — it’s briefer and doesn’t really reveal much. Maybe that’s the reason for the rehearing. Or maybe stake courts routinely reheard evidence then, as they do not generally do now. I don’t know.

    Amy, they should NOT have reheard the case, and the bishop’s court should not have heard it in the first place. The church had years earlier announced that they would NOT be involved in matters governed by civil law. That little matter doesn’t seem to have been raised at all, by anyone, at this point. The good brethren of Sevier County seems to have simply gone right along as they had for decades, regardless of political agreements, regardless of statehood, regardless of anything.

  5. To answer the question about Hulda’s testimony, no, I don’t see any hearsay in it, except for that last line. She mainly testified to the nature of her husband’s use of the property (whether it was real, continuous, open, etc.) in support of his claim. If I were James’ attorney, I would have called her as a witness in the first instance, too (and not waited to call her as a rebuttal witness).

    Anyhow, as to the larger question of how the case should come down, unfortunately Cora’s testimony here doesn’t come off at all as compelling. In fact, the best witness (by far), in my opinion, was her mother. Her mother focused on the legal right to the land. Cora, instead, seemed intent on going down a list of minor facts that she wanted to correct from the prior testimony (i.e., the exact length of the fence, the exact amount of her expenses). But this list of corrections seemed possibly distracting from the larger point. The effect is weak.

    And, mostly, her repetition that she knew “nothing” about what her father had said or done relative to the land is not helpful, to say the least. Ack! Why did she say it that way? This was frustrating to read.

    This case proves the saying that the law is not so much concerned with the truth, but with what you can prove in court. Cora needed an attorney. She’s losing here.

  6. Isaac Birdsall’s wish to not appear and testify seems significant since Leavitt’s claim is that there was an agreement between them prior to Cora Birdsall’s claim on the land.

    The order by the bishop’s court to accept $100 for the land isn’t what Cora Birdsall wants, but it doesn’t sound like an unequitable solution either.

  7. I’m with Gary, there has to be something not apparent for a bishop’s court and high council in 1902 claiming any jurisdiction in a land dispute that by this time is clearly a matter of federal land law (at least to my non-legal background). I can understand hearing this to potentially take action against someone’s standing in the church, but the emphasis here seems to be on getting Cora to deed the land to Leavitt, not about her conduct as a member of the church. I can only assume that in rural Utah in 1902, local law enforcement was probably still deferential to church discipline, and enforcement of federal laws was spotty at best.

    I will give the stake president credit that he waited until Cora was willing to appeal and attend. On the other hand, by participating, Cora is acknowledging that they have some jurisdiction and claim to authority here.

  8. Just an anecdote from my time as bishop. We had a member, I will call him “A,” a really great guy, but who had on occasion a really bad temper. Another member of our ward, member “B”, came to ma and said, “Bishop, the church’s good name is in jeopardy,” and proceeded to tell me about a property line dispute the first member was having with his non-member neighbor. Member A had just moved into the house, and had the property lines surveyed just so he knew for sure where the line was between his back yard, and his neighbor’s, which was not fenced at the time. Member A put a string line along the surveyed property line, and the non-member neighbor promptly built a new fence six inches on member A’s side of the property line.

    Member A had a conversation or two with the neighbor, that included some yelling about Christmas lights and other things, and ended up with member A taking a chainsaw and cutting down the neighbor’s fence, crushing some bushes that the neighbor had planted behind it.

    At this point, member B asked me, “Bishop, what are you going to do?” I told him that I was going to do nothing, that this was not at all any kind of a church issue, and if he knew what was best for him, to distance him as far away from the dispute as possible, or it might become a church issue, and not in a good way.

    Eventually, the neighbor, who never again spoke to member A, rebuilt his fence on the correct side of the surveyed property line, and member A moved to another house in our stake a couple of years later. No church disciplinary hearings about this. I would have suggested a more subtle approach than the chainsaw, but justice apparently prevailed in this situation.

  9. Interesting, kevinf. I’m aware of a property use dispute between member-neighbors in our last ward, with appeals to the bishop over it. The bishop correctly referred them to seek their civil remedies. Anyhow, good thing the dispute didn’t involve something serious, like saving church pews!

  10. Regarding hearsay: Hearsay traditionally involves testimony of an out-of court statement, that makes an assertion, where the testimony is offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted in the out-of-court statement. So, it’s not even hearsay when Hulda testifies that she heard Leavitt and Birdsall talk about the cows; it’s evidence that the cows were involved in some sort of deal. It would be hearsay if she went further to testify that the cows were payment for the land, not rent, because she had heard Leavitt say say so, in that conversation.

    They really need to ask more/better questions. If you’re going to have an adversarial proceeding, it seems like Cora or an advocate for her should be allowed to question the witnesses, not just the high council. Cora or her advocate should also be able to object to testimony for reasons like lack of personal knowledge. Hulda may have had personal knowledge that Leavitt turned out two cows, that they lived near the land and used it, that Leavitt did not move the ice house or the fence, that a conversation occured, etc. If Mormon land law follows use of the land rather than legal ownership, at least some of that is probably relevant. However, it’s not clear if she has any personal knowledge that the cows were “to apply on the deed,” what terms they had the use of the land on (own or rent), whether Leavitt was not “allowed” to move the fence or the icehouse, or just failed to move them for another reason, etc.

    A skilled advocate would be able to object and cross-examine to tease out the basis for her knowledge. It’s not clear, though, if that kind of advocacy was even allowed in church courts. Also, there are usually exceptions to the hearsay rule that could be probelmatic for Cora. For example, if Hulda says that the cows were “to apply on the deed” based on statements she heard Leavitt make, then that’s hearsay and should be excluded. But if Hulda’s testimony on that issue is based on a statement she heard Cora or Isaac Birdsall make, it might be admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule. (Statements made by a party or an unavailable witness, against their own interests, are admissible as non-hearsay or as an exception, because why would you lie in a way that doesn’t even benefit you?)

    Of course, I’m importing a lot of law about hearsay in this discussion from current law. I have less of an idea what hearsay law was like over a century ago. Also, of course, if we’re applying the law, we’d be in an actual court, and Cora would get the land. My guess about church courts is that if you think the Holy Ghost is going to inform your decision, you might decide you don’t really need fancy-schmancy procedure like the hearsay rule.

  11. David, I would just submit that if you want the Holy Ghost to inform your decision in a church disciplinary hearing, you ought to make sure you should even be having the hearing in the first place.

    I wonder if the high council members in those days treated church court sessions over things like land disputes differently than a court about apostasy or adultery? That seems almost a given in this circumstance.

  12. Mark B., I’ve been looking up things I should already have known, like this: Apparently rehearing the case at the stake level was ordinary procedure. For instance, B.H. Roberts takes it so for granted in his A New Witness for God that he doesn’t offer any explanatory comment in his outline of procedure, merely stating: “In the event of the parties or either of them being dissatisfied with the decision of the bishop, an appeal lies to the high council of the stake, where a re-hearing is given to the case.”

    Thanks for all the explanation on hearsay. I thought most of what Hulda said was hearsay, since I doubt she personally investigated the terms of Isaac’s claim, or was part of any conversation between Cora/Leavitt about moving his fence or ice house. That doesn’t seem likely when she didn’t even know whether Leavitt’s improvements included corrals, or whether the Leavitts had used Cora’s land after she filed her claim — she doesn’t appear to have been closely involved in Leavitt’s work. It’s one thing to ask Mary those questions when Isaac wasn’t there to ask, but when Leavitt was present it just seems strange to me that they would go to Hulda for that information.

  13. Since the hearsay rule exists because we don’t trust the jury to give appropriate weight to out-of-court statements, especially when there’s no opportunity to cross-examine the person who made the statement, I can see why a church court, claiming to be led by the Spirit, might not think the rule that important.

    Unfortunately, the hearsay rule does go to that sticky little issue of “study[ing] it out in your mind.”

    All the issues Mike Rasmussen and David Y. raise simply underscore the point that Amy T. and Ardis made above–there’s just no reason that this dispute should have been in the ecclesiastical court system in the first place.

  14. This discussion has reminded me of the story of one of our early Eminent Women, Ann Fairfax Washington Lee. Ostensibly over child sexual abuse, the trial of her abuser, the Rev. Charles Green, also served to highlight tensions between ecclesiastical and landed or government power in colonial Virginia.

    As with Cora’s trial — although I’ll be interested to see the final result — Ann Washington’s trial seems not to have done her too much good but created a lot of stress and hardship.

    A couple of years ago I read Roger Williams and the Creation of the American Soul: Church, State, and the Birth of Liberty (John M. Barry, 2012.) It was a fascinating exploration of religious liberty and the separation of church and state.

    I hope you write Cora’s story into a journal article, Ardis, since it highlights age-old tensions in our society, and a few specific to Mormon history.

  15. Having read the testimony, I think the lease, receipt for rent, whatever that paper was, should have been dispositive. If the practice was to give quitclaim deeds, then the usual rule that any contract or conveyance regarding land needs to be in writing should apply in Mormon church courts, too, and Leavitt simply should have gotten a deed, or at least a written contract.

    I suspect it didn’t go well for Cora, with so many of Leavitt’s witnesses saying the cows were for the land itself, not for rent, and Cora not spending much time rebutting that or attacking the credibility of those witnesses. I think the writing should trump all of that, but I doubt that it did. I also hesitate to attribute any improper motive to the high council, but I have to wonder if any of them were also involved in unwritten land deals that they wanted to protect

  16. My great-great-grandfather is Hans Christensen from Richfield, UT. He was a member of the Sevier Stake High Council from 1887 to 1903. He was 62 years old at the time of this hearing. He owned land. He had 2 wives and 18 children.
    This series is fascinating. Thank you, Ardis.

  17. mahana, it must be fun to see inside one activity he was involved with — so often we know an ancestor was a missionary or a bishop or whatever, without knowing any details. I’m glad you’re enjoying this!

  18. Cool connection, mahana! Thanks.

    By the way, Ardis, did the series ever identify the exact location of the land in question? I apologize if I missed it. The only thing I could find was a general description (in Part 3, I think):

    Isaac’s land was located on the Sevier River (both east and west banks), between Monroe and the nearby village of Joseph. This land included a natural meadow of approximately 40 acres (some estimates put it higher; the meadow was not formally surveyed during the period we’re talking about) on the west side of the river.

    I’d love to pull up the satellite image of the area on Google Maps.

  19. “North West quarter (1/4) of the South East Quarter (1/4) of Section One (1) in Township Twenty-five (25) South, Range Four West of the Salt Lake Meridian” — this is the description that appears on several documents later than the point we’ve reached.

    Never thought of doing that, David. If you find it, please post a link.

  20. Yep. Cora needs an advocate. Someone to explain the situation like Ardis did in part one of this series.

  21. She may have needed an advocate; finding a good one may have been a challenge. Earlier today I pulled up Utah Digital Newspapers wondering what kind of legal representation was available in town. (Was there any chance that she would have been able to take advantage of legal representation at a hearing of this sort? I’m assuming she wouldn’t have.)

    The digitized Richfield paper doesn’t start until 1906, but the first column of the first available copy starts with this story:

    The usual unvarying monotony of the regular monthly meetings of the board of county commissioners was unexpectedly enlivened by a scene last Monday that can be accounted no less than thrilling for the few seconds while it took precedence over all other matters then under consideration.
    As a result of this unusual and spectacular “specialty between acts,” some blood was drawn from its natural courses, the county clerk’s office is minus a window glass, and two of Richfield’s attorneys’ faces are wearing the mark of contact with each other’s fists….

  22. The Sunday School teacher in me wants to ask, “And how can we incorporate this into our own lives?”

  23. If the utility at http://www.earthpoint.us/TownshipsSearchByDescription.aspx for converting township, range, and section to latitude and longitude is correct, then the pin on this google map should be at the center of Section 1 in T25S R4W of the Salt Lake Meridian. https://goo.gl/maps/4JuHZ

    I couldn’t find a quick way to outline the particular plat, but a section is a square mile, so the NW quarter of the SE quarter should extend from this central pin 1/4 mile (1320 ft) south and east — about to the river.

  24. Wonderful, Mike. I had wondered if there was a site capable of converting public land survey descriptions into latitude/longitude . . . and you found it! Thanks.

    It’s exciting to see the area on your link provided. The terrain is, shall we say, pretty “severe.”

  25. Nice, Mike, and nice pun, David. It is striking to look at that patch of dry ground and think of all the hard feelings and suffering it caused.

    My husband has been very busy recently but I’ve briefly mentioned this series in a few random minutes here and there. His reaction to this latest post and discussion was to wonder why the high council didn’t follow the scripture or statement of belief in Doctrine and Covenants 134:10-11:

    10 We believe that all religious societies have a right to deal with their members for disorderly conduct, according to the rules and regulations of such societies; provided that such dealings be for fellowship and good standing; but we do not believe that any religious society has authority to try men on the right of property or life… They can only excommunicate them from their society, and withdraw from them their fellowship.

    11 We believe that men should appeal to the civil law for redress of all wrongs and grievances, where personal abuse is inflicted or the right of property or character infringed, where such laws exist as will protect the same…

    (Trying to remember back to my college days, wondering when the Doctrine and Covenants became canonical.)

    Perhaps the high council feared that various rights or assumed rights to the land in their community would not be protected if litigated, so they considered themselves not bound by this principle? That they were free to hear and decide the case and do whatever they needed to do to keep their communities running in order, even if it was contrary to the practice of the Church and could only be done by stripping the livelihood from newcomers to town, including a poor single sister?

    (I know my questions ignore much of the history of the land conflicts as explained in a previous post and in Dr Alexander’s article. It was a time of transition, a time to work out these issues, and sometimes working out the issues came with real personal costs. So, it’s good to remember Cora and the price she paid to help the Church make the transition.)

Comments are closed.