Guest Post: Thaddeus Stevens, Mormon Defender?

I will have to admit that I knew next to nothing about Thaddeus Stevens, the Republican congressman from Pennsylvania played by Tommy Lee Jones in Steven Spielberg’s 2012 movie, Lincoln, prior to seeing the movie. I had read Doris Kearns Goodwin’s book, Team of Rivals, about Lincoln’s presidency, but Stevens was not given much mention there. A quick resort to Google turned up many hits about Thaddeus Stevens, and his remarkable career. Several entries noted, however, that Stevens was a defender of “Indians, Jews, and Mormons” in addition to his abolitionist views.

Mormon defender? I had to know more. Over several months, I did occasional searches, and read two biographies of Stevens, including a quick skim of Fawn Brodie’s Thaddeus Stevens: Scourge of the South. Brodie and other biographers have nothing to say about Stevens’ defense of the Mormons, which surprised me. Surely, if Stevens really was a defender of the LDS church, there must be some link somewhere.

The Church History Library has almost nothing about Stevens in their catalog. I did learn a few things, though, along the way. Stevens, much like his slightly younger contemporary, Thomas L. Kane, was something of an idealist, an advocate of unpopular causes and disenfranchised individuals. He promoted free public education in Pennsylvania, where he settled after growing up in Vermont, and began reading for the law. He was also an early member of the Anti-Masonic party, disagreed with the Missouri Compromise of 1850, was utterly opposed to the Fugitive Slave Act, and was an ardent abolitionist.

Stevens was part of the defense counsel for the Christiana Riot case in 1851 where fugitive slave hunters attempted to apprehend six blacks suspected of being runaways in Christiana, Pennsylvania. Several white men were helping to hide the black suspects, and a confrontation between the slave hunters and the local residents escalated into a riot, in which the owner of the alleged fugitive slaves was killed. Five whites and 38 blacks were arrested and charged with treason. Stevens and other lawyers successfully defended the case, and charges were dismissed.

I also discovered that Stevens argued a case before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 1848 that touched on religious freedom, and seems to be the first instance where he portrays the Mormons in a sympathetic manner. The case involved the strict Sunday closing law enacted by the Pennsylvania legislature in 1794. The case before the court was an appeal to overturn the conviction of one Jacob Specht, a Seventh Day Adventist who closed his business on Saturday, and was open on Sunday, observing the Sabbath according to his own religious convictions.

Stevens blends many aspects of religious liberty throughout his argument, including the interesting reference to the danger of making “the Christian religion … a part of the common law.” In so doing, he claims, then “the Jew, the Hindoo, the Pagan, are perpetual malefactors. They of course, are beyond the protection of the law.” He likens this argument to the practice of the English government in the 15th and 16th centuries, when it became “a convenient excuse for sending to the block any one who became obnoxious … if such a tyrant were a Roman Catholic, the heresy of the reformation was sufficient. If he were a Protestant, adhering to the church of Rome was equally so.”

Stevens’ far ranging argument cites how Henry VIII disposed of his enemies, like Thomas More, or his wives, when he tired of them. He recites scripture from the Old and New Testaments. He invoked the worst crimes of the Spanish Inquisition in the name of Christianity. The Congress of the United States in 1829 tried to pass laws restricting a number of activities on Sunday, he related, but those proposals were reported by committees in both the House and Senate as unconstitutional.

Turning to the specifics of the Sunday closing law, Stevens rightly states that by enforcing Sunday as the only recognized Sabbath unfairly privileges as specific mode of worship, thereby creating a preferential and therefore unconstitutional class.

But he saves his reference to the Mormons until he has to convince the court that they are the correct body to right the wrongs created by the 1794 law. It is the court’s specific responsibility to rule, as the legislature first has not repealed the law, and the executive branch is primarily weak when it comes to doing the right thing in opposition to the prevailing public opinion. He first points to Pilate as an example of a weak executive who refused to overturn the demands of the mob.

“Can they trust to popular justice, or an executive trembling before the people?” he declares. “Let the unhappy Mormons answer. Because they were foolish enough to believe, and independent enough to express their belief that the Golden Plates of Mormon were as authentic as the Tables of Moses, an infamous majority of their Christian neighbors voted them out-laws, murdered their Prophets, robbed them of their property, expelled them from their homes, and drove them as exiles to the shores of the Pacific Ocean. Although this was all planned and avowed in open day, and proclaimed for months, yet they found no protection from a weak, despicable Executive [Illinois Gov. Thomas Ford], who stood in greater awe of the Sovereign people than he did of the Constitution, which he had sworn to support. If the Constitution sleep, is there any safety in the teachings of the pulpit? … To the Judiciary then, and to them alone, can civil and religious liberty look for relief, when assailed by majorities forgetful of the true principles of our government. That they will prove true to their high duties, we have the most confident hopes.”

The hopes, however, appear to have been in vain. The court, ruling to affirm the judgment of the lower court, recognized the “ingenious argument addressed to us by the counsel of the plaintiff.” Justice Thomas Bell declared that some day must be selected for a day of rest, and that Sunday was not a poor choice. It did not, however, assume to “assert the supremacy of Sunday as of Divine appointment.” Citizens of Pennsylvania were still at “full liberty to shape [their] own convictions and to assert them to the extent of a free exercise of [their] religious views.”

This was the first of a number of positive references to the Mormons over Stevens legal and legislative career, and I am working to uncover more. Part of the problem is that Stevens is alleged to have burned all of his personal papers and letters shortly before his death, leaving primarily just his public speeches and legal writings to document his remarkable life.

But the question that I have been trying to answer, and so far can only speculate about, is how did Stevens become informed about the Mormons, and why was he sympathetic? In a follow up post, I will link him both to the more famous and personally invested Mormon defender, Thomas L. Kane, and Joseph Smith’s Nauvoo confidant, Dr. John M. Bernhisel, who later served as Utah’s territorial delegate to congress for much of the same time frame as Stevens’ service there. Then I will show that connection to Kane and Bernhisel to be mostly coincidental, and not as substantial as a couple of generations of Mormon historians were led to believe by an offhand remark by John Bernhisel’s son, which leaves me still with the question, why was Stevens so sympathetic to the Mormons?

Cite Keepa

Regrettably, meanies have stolen content from Keepa in the past! I'm confident you will choose honesty and cite this page like this:

MLA: Parshall, Ardis E. "Guest Post: Thaddeus Stevens, Mormon Defender?." Keepapitchin.org, 30 Apr 2014, https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/04/30/guest-post-thaddeus-stevens-mormon-defender/.

APA: Parshall, A. (2014, Apr 30). Guest Post: Thaddeus Stevens, Mormon Defender?. Keepapitchinin.org. https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/04/30/guest-post-thaddeus-stevens-mormon-defender/

HTML: <a target="_new" href="https://keepapitchinin.org/2014/04/30/guest-post-thaddeus-stevens-mormon-defender/">Guest Post: Thaddeus Stevens, Mormon Defender?</a>

9 thoughts on “Guest Post: Thaddeus Stevens, Mormon Defender?”

  1. Thanks, Kevin! Interesting post.

    One minor quibble: the Missouri Compromise occurred in 1820, when Missouri (and Maine) were admitted to the Union. The Compromise of 1850, coming, as you may deduce, 30 years later, superseded the Missouri Compromise. Stevens, who was 28 years old in 1820, may well have supported both the Missouri Compromise and the Compromise of 1850, but they were two different things.

    And a puzzle: the First Amendment, with its religious liberty clauses, was not understood as restricting state powers in those pre-14th Amendment days, but Stevens seems to rely heavily upon appeals to the constitution in his arguments before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Perhaps the state constitution contained a similar protection of religious liberty, or maybe lawyers then based their arguments on the principles of the Federal Constitution, even if it was not strictly applicable.

    And, finally, the language in that court’s decision could have been lifted nearly verbatim from Justice Scalia’s opinion in Employment Division v. Smith. Sure, a Sunday closing law incidentally burdened Jews and Seventh Day Adventists more than worship on Sunday Christians, but it was a law of general applicability and, hey, deal with it. Sort of.

  2. Stevens, not unlike Joseph Smith, may have lamented that the US Constitutional protections in the Bill of Rights were not operative against state governments. Brother Joseph did not think highly of “states rights doctrine.” In fact, he said it stinked. Both seemed to hope for something like a 14th Amendment to help protect the rights of disfavored minorities. And Stevens was able to help accomplish that after the Civil War.

    I’m looking forward to more in this series. Good job, Kevin!

  3. Great post — intriguing! Looking forward to the rest. Will have to rely on historian commenters to answer your question why Stevens knew about and was sympathetic to the Mormons. I suspect he was well-read and informed on the issues of the day; and his sympathies may have been simply an inborn predisposition to look out for the little guy.

    I loved this line: “If the Constitution sleep, is there any safety in the teachings of the pulpit?”

  4. Mark, you are right about the Missouri compromise being different than the 1850 compromise. I kind of forgot that. Also, as a non-lawyer, I did not catch that distinction about an appeal to the Federal Constitution being out of the ordinary for a time when popular sovreignity was the rule.

  5. David, I am also hoping that some historians may notice this and have more information about how and why Stevens got connected with the Mormons. I have a few answers, but they raise just as many questions, so Part II will address what I know, what we thought we knew, and what we still don’t know. Thanks for the comments.

  6. There are lots of interesting aspects to this story; the Christiana Riot is a quite a story in itself, and definitely one of the more interesting events to happen in Lancaster County.

    This is a great subject to explore, Kevin. I’m looking forward to the rest of it.

  7. “There are lots of interesting aspects to this story; the Christiana Riot is a quite a story in itself, and definitely one of the more interesting events to happen in Lancaster County.”

    Ain’t that the truth! And Lancaster County sets the bar high for that.

    It may also be worth noting that, here in Lancaster County, there were several other sabbatarian groups (besides Jews and Seventh-Day Adventists) of which Stevens, practicing law in that vicinity, might have perchance been aware and had on his mind during the course of that trial – for instance, the Seventh-Day Baptist sect that had founded Ephrata.

    Incidentally, a correction to the post: Jacob Specht was a member of Ephrata’s subsidiary Seventh-Day Baptist (not Adventist) community at Snow Hill, as their society ledger and a few other sources attest.

  8. JB, thanks for dropping by. And thanks also for the note about Jacob Specht and the Seventh Day Baptists. Palmer and Ochoa did not make that distinction in their collection of Steven’s letters and speeches when they discussed the case. The Christiana Riot trial is fascinating, and plays a role in part II of this series.

  9. It was fun to see all the lawyers responding to the legal issues in this piece

    I don’t know any more about Thaddeus Stevens than I saw in Lincoln, and have no idea where you’re heading with this in the next post, Kevin, so I’m as eager as anybody else to see what you have to say. Some of my favorite posts are intersections with Mormonism by famous people, and contributing to Mormon history by correcting past assumptions, and it sounds as though there will be elements of both in this continued story.

Comments are closed.